Going to be 100% honest and brutal:
The story seems kinda cliche. It's just a revenge story, except guess what, the tyranical overlord is the one that you gotta get revenge on. This is reminding me a lot of cinder, minus the fairy-tale aspects. There's no mystery, we know who did it from the start. It seems like your average "teens doing things that no teens would ever be able to do while otherthrowing the government". There's no depth, and there's this entire thing about how robots are bad and stuff, which i mean could be interesting if you use that as a tool to talk about racial prejudice, but otherwise I just don't see the point.

The main character seems a bit young to be "avenging his lover"; most 15 year olds haven't even dated, let alone developed deep enough feelings to seek "revenge". Heck, if I'm reading this correctly, that means that he had a lover when he was 14. This means that he started dating this person at age 13 at the EARLIEST. He also seems to be extremely bland. You don't have any weaknesses or anything listed here (other than "impulsiveness", which come on, that isn't anything on his character), and he seems too much like a stereotypical good guy. Also, what's up with the scar? What happened to him? Try to add some other weaknesses that could cause some people to dislike him, and events that happen in their life that shape them as a human.

Mina is a bit better, as lazyness can be a negative trait, but overall she's just a generic side character. Nothing special. Maybe add some motivations?

Sapphire is also close to becoming a bland and boring character. She's seeming a bittt too much like a mary sue; everyone hates her for no reason despite the fact that she's literally the nicest person around, and doesn't seem to have any flaws. Only having her backstory be "she was treated like trash" when there doesn't seem to be any reason for it makes things seem unrealistic. Maybe there could be some reason why she's picked on? Is it because she's a robot? Is she from a place that has a history of robot brutality? Everyone, even the random people of a town, have to have reasons for their actions.

Ren looks pretty good, however again, mysterious hacker is still kind of cliche. Maybe add a compulsion or something to make her weird or unique? or have her hint at a tragic past? Again, needs more depth to the character.

Ok, Dion... Just saying that Kind and Bossy/Apathetic are KIND OF contradictory??? Like, they're clashing. I don't really see how this person could actually exist. And how exactly is he popular? Is it because of his kindness? His good looks? Why is he so loyal? How is he dependable? What does he bring to the table?

And where is the description of Melantha? Don't tell me she's just going to be evil and that's it? You gotta go into villian motivations and stuff man.

Characters are wayyyy too young for this situation. If you want to go down this route I'd reccommend making Elyot's motivation be something family related and not about their lover. Add more depth. Add motivations. Remember every single person, even if they're just a part of a mob, has motivations and purpose.

Like the plot itself isn't inherently bad, it's just extremely bare bones and simple and at the risk of becoming cliche. You need to add things to set it apart and make it seem like an actual world.

Anyways, I'm looking forward to seeing how this turns out.
Janyia March 13, 2021 7:08 am

Ohh Yeah I made this story a few months back actually, The reason why I made them so young was because IDK I just thought about kids around my age group if that makes sense,

queer March 13, 2021 3:19 pm

no yeah that makes total sense. i used to do that too. it's just the older I get, the more I realize that younger characters really don't make that much sense. But they can still definitely work!

FRUITY PEBBLES March 13, 2021 6:44 am

queer- you just wrong a whole essay on like 12 slides lmaooo

Celestia March 13, 2021 6:27 am

Are you a book reviewer irl or something ?

queer March 13, 2021 6:32 am

LMAO I just read a lot man XD

Janyia March 13, 2021 6:22 am

wait can yall not see my side notes-

Janyia March 13, 2021 6:21 am

I will redo this immediately !!

METHod March 13, 2021 6:21 am

Queer pls- why did you write a whole ass review on a Google Slides, lmao.

queer March 13, 2021 6:24 am

I do what I feel like I need to do.

Janyia March 13, 2021 6:20 am

Man, This hurt, BUT IS EXACTLY WHAT I NEEDED PLZ MARRY ME~~~

queer March 13, 2021 6:26 am

no problem. i can see the side notes btw.
like the story is really promising. you just need to flesh out the characters and story a bit more to make it seem real.
again, looking forward to seeing updates :)

Janyia March 13, 2021 6:26 am
no problem. i can see the side notes btw.like the story is really promising. you just need to flesh out the characters and story a bit more to make it seem real.again, looking forward to seeing updates :) queer

You'll want me to update it?

queer March 13, 2021 6:30 am
You'll want me to update it? Janyia

OH DUDE I MEANT I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO SEEING WHERE THIS IS GOING-
Like, I'm intrigued. The concept of a group of younger people who all have a grudge against their tyrannical overlord, working together to unite their country and overthrow the government is always a plot I can get behind. It's promising, and I can see it going places.

+
Janyia March 13, 2021 6:46 am
OH DUDE I MEANT I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO SEEING WHERE THIS IS GOING-Like, I'm intrigued. The concept of a group of younger people who all have a grudge against their tyrannical overlord, working together to unite... queer

Actually, Melantha is a character with a background too but later will be something else~ I want all of my characters to have depth even the "Bad guys" So okay I will work on this, and give these characters some fuckin depth, and maybe more like more personal information and personalities

+
13 03,2021
9 followers

unpopular opinion

46 people did / 11 want to do

All questions about this thing

Hottest questions

how old are y'all
182 answers188 followers
PLEASE MAKE A SEXY WOMAN IM STARVING
151 answers149 followers
Unpopular Yaoi Opinions?
96 answers114 followers

Unanswered questions

1 followers