Manga Scenario

Pretend you are in a romance manga (any genre). In this, the most popular player of the school asks you out.
Hearing rumors about how they tend to not be in any long term relationship which has made many of their exes sad- but how they are also very experienced in making a partner feel good- how would you respond to their confession?

Their confession is this:
"I like you because you don't seem to be into me, like everybody else. Care to give me a try?"

WHAT WOULD YOU DO?(๑•ㅂ•)و✧