peaches's manga / #she a 3(314)

01/30/21 ch 12 plot: 2.5-3 story: 3 art: 5 writing: 3 uke: 3.5 seme: 3 chemistry: 4 skinship: 3 overall: this story sometimes makes me want to pull my hair out jesus christ edit 08/22/21: by ch 39 i realized he really was a poor uke :( edit 09/27/21: chapter 44 is just chefs kiss for me it was so adorable i had the sudden urge to add .5 to the ratings of the categories because up until this point they all improved anyway so i figured they actually deserve the raise

plot: 3 story: 3 art: 4 writing: 3 uke: 4 seme: 4 chemistry: 4 skinship: 3 overall: cute i adore their child

plot: 3 story: 2.5 art: 4 writing: 3 uke: 3.5 seme: 3 chemistry: 2.5 skinship: 1.5 overall: she funny she cute she aight

plot: 3 story: 3 art: 5 writing: 3 uke: 3.5-4 seme: 4 chemistry: 5 skinship: 5 overall: so far it's alright but lately it's just sex ,,i kinda wanna know how the story will progress guys u might wanna tone it down a little bit edit 09/06/21: by ch 30 theyre doing good now lol edit 03/07/22: ch 56 shes a 3.5/5 now hence the 4 stars edit 03/19/22: ch 58 it endedddd yayyy i mean it was an okay read. i dont think i recalled getting bored while reading even while waiting for the updates. it didnt leave me hanging unnecessarily. the story was alright but there were definitely some plot holes that im hoping the epilogues/ side stories will explain. but even without the side stories it shouldve already been on the main story :/ anw all in all she was nice shes still a 3.5 04/24/22: ch 61 i actually really liked the first epilogue because it gave me a peek of seme’s pov. kinda nice

plot: 2 story: 2 art: 5 goddamn writing: 2 uke: 4.5 seme: 4.5 chemistry: 4 skinship: 3 overall: dang my rating seems kinda low but it's just season 1 so it will still improve i guess? so many unanswered questions hence the low score on the storyline. i would die for the uke tho he deserves all the happiness in this world. i would also want to kill that mf who did horrible things to uke like fr i would gladly chop his dick off and feed it to himself

plot: 3.5 story: 3 art: 4.5 writing: 3 uke: 4 seme: 4 chemistry: 4 skinship: 2.5 overall: uke is so pretty seriously whenever i see a pretty uke i automatically bump up the score of the story's total average ahah #noshame

plot: 3.5 story: 2.5 art: 3 writing: 2.5-3 uke: 3.5 seme: 3.5 chemistry: 3.5-4 skinship: 1.5 overall: gets hella confusing through time and the art may be pretty but it's really bloody annoying that all relevant characters look the same smfh

plot: 3 story: 3 art: 4 writing: 3 uke: 5 seme: 4.5 chemistry: 4 skinship: 0.5-1 overall: cute, simple

plot: 3 story: 3 art: 4 writing: 2.5 uke: 5 seme: 4 chemistry: 4 skinship: 2.5 overall: she alright

plot: 2-2.5 story: 2 art: 5 writing: 2.5 uke: 4 seme: 3.5-4 chemistry: 3.5 skinship: 2.5 overall: it's alright love the art edit 06/12/22: paused at ch 51 , i was like damn.. theres a season 2? like, why,, lol i dont think it's good when from a reader's pov theyre disappointed theres a season two lmfaoo i bookmarked it at ch 51 honestly idk if i'd wanna continue reading it in the future but who knows lol also shes now 2.5/5