peaches's manga / #reread(28)

plot: 3/5 story: 2/5 art: 4/5 writing: 3/5? uke: 3/5 seme: 2/5 chemistry: 3/5 skinship: 1/5 overall: i decided to reread it after i saw my 1 star rating and thank god i did. my first time reading it there was a part in the story that was unclear and wasnt disclosed properly that made me hella confused and if it wasnt for someone's comment clearing it up i wouldnt understand. with that knowledge in mind i reread it after a while and became more forgiving lol but overall it's just ok

plot: 3 story: 3 art: 5 writing: 4 uke: 4.5 seme: 4 chemistry: 4 skinship: 2 overall: i think ive reread this three times? this was also the first ever bl i remember liking sm !!!!!

plot: 4/5 story: 4/5 art: 5/5 writing: 3.5/5 uke: 5/5 seme: 5/5 chemistry: 5/5 skinship: 5/5 overall: beautiful uke !!!!!! one of the prettiest ukes in existence and i say this with confidence!!!!!!! beautiful art GOOD story and GREAT COUPLE oh my gOD they make me wanna kms for being single and that says a lot about how adorable they are

rated it 5/5 at first for the chefs kiss skinship but reread it again and realized the mangaka-san did 2nd lead hella dirty haha so i guess 4/5

plot: 2.5 story: 3 art: 3.5 writing: 3 uke: (fl) 3 seme: (ml) 2.5 chemistry: 3 skinship: 2.5 overall: (ive read this wayyyyy before as in the time when i was still into heterosexual couples which was a long time ago lmao so my rating will be based off of a memory that may or may not be right bc i have long since forgotten this) i remember rereading this before hence the reread tag. i first read it what, ten? 11? 12 years ago and i remember liking it so much it became one of my favorites. it was when i was fairly new to reading manga so obviously i didnt have that much standards lol but this has sentimental value to me bc the nostalgia is strong in this one. ten years ago i would've rated this 5/5 but now it's definitely just a strong 2.5-3 in total. i still remember some of it which is rare lol this story molded me to who i am today lol jk

plot: 4 story: 4 art: 5 writing: 5 uke: 5 seme: 5 chemistry: 5 skinship: 4 overall: my god. this is an easy 5-star rating despite still being ongoing. seme is a candidate for one of the best semes he is literally AN. ANGEL. i feel for uke sooo much he's so relatable and he's sooo lovely as well i ADORE HIM. i love them both so much i love the characters of their characters i love how simple yet realistic the story is i love their skinship oh my gOD i love everything about it!!!! this is a well deserved spinoff story (then eventually a sequel) given to them!!!!!!! 5/5!!!!! ps. if they breakup i will simply pass away no questions asked

plot: 3 story: 2.5 art: 4 writing: 3 uke: 4 seme: 3 chemistry: 4 skinship: 2.5 overall: had to reread to recall stuff bc it's been so long since its last update and, well, it's alright !!!! i like seeing happy ukes and happy families !!:)

plot: 2 story: 2 art: 4 writing: 2 uke: 3 seme: 2.5 chemistry: 2 skinship: 0 overall: had to reread bc it's been so long since its last update that i forgot the story and damn i cant believe i was bamboozled into reading a shounen ai

x 2 stories x plot: 3, 3 story: 2.5, 2.5 art: 5 writing: 3, 2.5 uke: 4.5, 4.5 seme: 4, 2 chemistry: 4, 2 skinship: 0, 0 overall: had to reread bc i forgot abt it and it's alright w me since i like this author v much

× 2 stories × plot: 2, 2.5 story: 2, 3 art: 5 writing: 2, 4 uke: 2.5, 3.5 seme: 2, 3 chemistry: 0, 4 skinship: 0, 0.5 overall: had to reread bc vol 2 was suddenly added after a couple of months of it listed as completed and i forgot about the whole story. the second story was wayyyyyy better like imo it shouldve been a different book since the vol 2 only just focused on the first story anyway. also, the placement of the 2nd story sends me lmfao like it just appeared out of nowhere???? the first story didnt exactly end in the most obvious way so i was confused as hell when the next chapter was an entirely different story to the first one lol