peaches's manga / #poor uke(129)

plot: 3 story: 3.5 art: 5 writing: 3.5 uke: 3-3.5 seme: 2.5-3 chemistry: 4.5 skinship: 4-4.5 overall: side stories took too long to finish that idk if whats left of my memory of this is credible enough to make a rating. i remember the huge misunderstanding they had that frustrated the fuck out of me and it wasnt their fault it was the mf who assaulted uke jfc this story was wack i also remember getting pissed with ukes parents like his mom physically hurt both uke and seme upon coming out like bitch, it's one thing to hurt your own child it's another to hurt someone else; both of which are bloody terrible esp when all they did was LOVE. you think loving each other is a mistake? bitch YOU are the mistake. i havent forgiven that bitchass yet i aint forget

plot: 2 story: 2 art: 2.5 writing: 2 uke: 2-2.5 seme: 1.5-2 chemistry: 2 skinship: 3 overall: i literally dont remember shit about this just one or two things maybe that i used to help rate this like the last time i read this was 6 mos ago way before my rating system made its first appearance. this is not much worth rereading as well hence the decision to not reread it just to give it a more decent rating than it already has. it's a no for me but i will continue reading in case it changes my mind about it edit 08/20/22: ch 75 wtf theres a season 3????? i wish there wasnt?????? i think wishing a book wouldnt continue says a lot lol

collection of story total average: 3/5 overall: good writing. the first one was cute. i thought the second one was bad at first but then i realized the depth of it and it was a waste that it was rushed i feel like it could be developed more. the third one could also be a separate book tbh all of the three stories could have their own respective books that i would love to see. so much toxicity yes but it got my attention ig

colletion of stories 1st story: 4/5 2nd story: 2.5-3 3rd story: 2.5-3 overall: good writing. i like all the ukes. i like all the semes except the 2nd story i just think hes a dick. also on the 3rd story i consider uke's current bf his seme instead of the brother which was actually the seme and the focal point of the story but since he is blood related lets just ignore that and give the seme position to the current bf who seems adorable

plot: 2 story: 1.5-2 art: 4 writing: 0 uke: 1.5-2????? seme: fucking 0 chemistry: 1 skinship: 2.5 overall: emphasis on the shitty seme tag cuz mf a psycho jesus christ 1.5/5 edit 02/28/23 ch 41: tf is this bullshit? their dirty talk is more like shit talking 04/13/23 ch44: what in the cringe hell is this????????????? writing is now a 0

01/30/21 ch 12 plot: 2.5-3 story: 3 art: 5 writing: 3 uke: 3.5 seme: 3 chemistry: 4 skinship: 3 overall: this story sometimes makes me want to pull my hair out jesus christ edit 08/22/21: by ch 39 i realized he really was a poor uke :( edit 09/27/21: chapter 44 is just chefs kiss for me it was so adorable i had the sudden urge to add .5 to the ratings of the categories because up until this point they all improved anyway so i figured they actually deserve the raise

plot: 3 story: 3 art: 2-2.5 writing: 3 uke: 5 seme: 2 chemistry: 3 skinship: 0.5 overall: the art was so disappointing. everything was "too light" it started physically hurting my eyes. even on black and white mangas and webtoons there are enough shading and shadows to balance everything out but this one is just too bright all throughout. they added colors to the hair and eyes in an attempt to make their characters pop up but to no avail. the colors they added were also light it's frustrating. typing this while my head is aching. also almost dropped this at ch 14 i think bc of the inconsistencies and the way they missed several opportunities to develop the good writing they had at the beginning.... anyway im too emotionally invested in this now to let go of this lol i hope it gets better from here and i have to commend them FINALLY removing the stupid fringe/bangs of mc lmfaooooo they erased the line that separated it from his hair it took them what, 30 chapters? but im glad lmfao

plot: 1.5 story: 1.5 art: 2.5 writing: 1.5 uke: 1 seme: 0 chemistry: 0 skinship: 0.5 overall: fuck seme jesus edit 06/20/22: ch 40 like, ew lol the sex was cringey asfuUUUCKKK idk the chemistry really wasnt there luv just pure unadulterated lust lmao and sure thats fine but if i dont feel the chemistry the sex will come out as cringey to me. also, i didnt even notice the long absence of this book's updates ahahah shes that unremarkable ur honor. thank god the art makes up for it. also jesus uke STAND TF UP 09/05/22: ch 50 art is dead. shes bland. uke annoyed tf outta me . seme.. seme can fucking choke. literally bad writing with these characters and the story is slowly going down the drain. nothing to look forward to this anymore 09/15/22: ch 51 the art really is dead. ever since he was put in that room the art died like the proportion of the bed was off, colors were literally nothing aside from their hair, and movements? who even is she amiright. characters have completely gone to shit to the point that uke fucking annoyed me to no end hes just so push and pull like STAND TF UP. one min ur like 'i fucken hate u seme' the next min ur like 'omg whens he coming back' like what the Fuck? he also provokes seme and looks like a shocked pikachu face when seme actually gets provoked jfc . hes so fuckinh .. i dont even wanna say anything anymore hes more annoying than seme at this point. dropping this

plot: 2 story: 1.5 art: 4 writing: 2 uke: 3 seme: 1 chemistry: 1.5 skinship: 0.5 overall: no wtf

plot: 1 story: 1 art: 4 writing: 1 uke: 3.5 seme: ?? chemistry: - skinship: - overall: man this is not good haha 1.5/5 going 1 tbh