peaches's manga / #4/5(208)

plot: 3-3.5 story: 2.5 art: 4.5 writing: 2.5 uke: 4 seme: 3-4 chemistry: 4 skinship: 1.5 overall: love the art and all the ukes uwu uwu 3.5/5

plot: 3 story: 2.5-3 art: 5 writing: 2.5 uke: 4 seme: 3.5-4 chemistry: 3.5 skinship: 2.5 overall: the art is chefs kiss it's just so.... [kissing noises intensifies]. it lacks a bit on some areas on the plot and the story still needs a bit work but i dont really think the author was going for something any deeper than this maybe they just want a light story and that's okay. theyre known for having fun and cute light stories anyway so i took that into consideration very well when scoring it 3.5/5

plot: 4 story: 3.5-4 art: 5 writing: 3-4 uke: 4-4.5 seme: 3.5 chemistry: 4.5-5 skinship: 2 overall: aaaaaaaa i actually rly rly like it ?!?!?!! minus the violence but dang is this entertaining as shit i adore uke and his chemistry with the (potential) seme is insane. i say potential cuz it's a slow burn and im not 100% sure hes the seme im not even sure this has romance in it but my gut is telling me it has. cant wait for more chapters !!!

plot: 3.5 story: 3 art: 5 writing: 3.5 uke: 5 seme: 4 chemistry: 4.5 skinship: 3.5-4 overall: aaaaa this was cute. it was so wholesome 4.5/5

overall: extra chapter of Shiba-kun to Shepherd-san on which i gave 4.5 stars

plot: 4 story: 3.5 art: 5 writing: 4 uke: 5 seme: 3 chemistry: 2 skinship: 0 overall: mooooore i need mooooooooore. incestuous relationships can go to hell and this story could've been 4 stars despite only having one chapter had it not hinted any incest shit but theres nothing i can do abt it lmfao the writing is nice it got me thinking it's on the simpler side at first but then the end of the first chapter hit me and im HERE for it. i like that it suddenly got dark that was a nice touch and now it got me wanting for more. i hope this gets picked up soon bc i want mooooooore

plot: 3 story: 3 art: 5 writing: 4 uke: 4.5 seme: 4.5 chemistry: 4 skinship: 2 overall: i made a mistake of listening to i cant make you love me by samoht while reading chapter 5 and lemme tell u- it made the confrontation scene extra emotional for me thank god it ended nicely or i might not have the courage to continue this day being mentally and emotionally stable that was very amateur of me i will try not to make the same mistake again

plot: 3 story: 2.5 art: 5 writing: 3 uke: 3.5-4 seme: 4 chemistry: 3.5-4 skinship: 1 overall: i like it. how many times do i have to repeat myself that im not fond of student x teacher relationships but on this situation i took consideration of seme's age hes supposedly 18 now since the premise was for him to graduate ? ish ? anyway it's alright. wish there were a few more extra chapters but all in all shes a 3.5/5

plot: 4 story: 4 art: 5 !!! writing: 3-4 uke: 5 seme: 5 chemistry: 5 skinship: 5 overall: THE ART IS HOLY I LITERALLY WORSHIP IT IT'S JUST SO CHEFS KISS !!! shes gorgeous fr fr the characters are great i love both the uke and the seme and wish nothing more but happiness for them !!! the plot is nice and the flow of the story is good too amd donT EVEN GET ME STARTED WITH THE SKINSHIP ??!?!!? truly chefs kiss*"&#*(/*;: also side note i think there were some problems with the translation as it went on bc the writing started to get a bit confusing and disappointing if im being honest bc had it been a bit better or at least with the same level as the first chapter i wouldve made this 5 stars in an instant but!! other than that i love this i cant wait for more chapters 4.5/5 edit 02/19/22 ch 12: wtf is this bullshit

plot: 3 story: 2.5-3 art: 4 writing: 3 uke: 4-4.5 seme: 4.5 chemistry: 4 skinship: 2 overall: adorable uke :( nice seme :( happy that they got together and had a happy ending :)