peaches's manga / #4/5(208)

plot: 3 story: 3 art: 4 writing: 3 uke: 4-4.5 seme: 4 chemistry: 4 skinship: 2 overall: uke is adorable !!!!! i was debating on whether i should rate this 5 stars or nah just bc the ending was cute lol

12/11/22 ch 7 plot: 3 story: 3.5 art: 4.5 writing: 4 uke: 5 seme: 3.5 chemistry: 4.5 skinship: 2 overall: there were things i liked and didnt like i'll start with likes: i loooved the monologues and scenes of their povs esp when they thought it's an unrequited love !!! THE. FEELS. so nice !! the art really did its thing here. also like how nice uke's parents are stuff i didnt like that influenced this being 4 stars rating only despite being a good read: there was an assault here, not the full blown one but still an assault nonetheless that was rather taken lightly? that assailant mf shouldve had karma bite him in the ass on the book but i digress. also (/s:) the part where seme outed uke in front of his friends... i mean seme being confident abt his sexuality being out is alright like good for him but he shouldve consulted with uke first... that part couldve easily gone sideways omg i rly thought uke was gonna snap at him for that reason lol anw all in all good read !!

12/I2/22 ch 6 plot: 3 story: 3 art: 4 writing: 2.5-3 uke: 4.5 seme: 3.5-4 chemistry: 3.5 skinship: 1.5 overall: no way the comments were all like (/s:) "he chose the second lead!!!" and im out here like hes not a second lead tho???? did yall go raw in reading this? did yall not read the summary???? it didnt match the first guy that was introduced lmao anw it lacked on some parts and it was an average almost, but i liked the implication of a love triangle with two of the people involved having an unrequited love. if this was longer and probably focused on that more i just know this would have the potential to WRECK ME lmao side note, wanna call out the unrealistic part here tho- (/s:) all of them and their dilemma with their promises back in middle school like , lets be fr for a sec and sure this might just be me , but if i were them, i simply wouldve forgotten it lol i mean cmon life is gonna happen after middle school and a more difficult one at that so trying to recall a promise like that when i was a kid wouldve been so hard i got real stuff to think ABOUT ! like lmao

12/15/22 ch 5.5 plot: 3 story: 3 art: 5 writing: 2.5-3 uke: 5 seme: 4 chemistry: 2.5 skinship: 0.5 overall: simple but she still delivered nonetheless ! nothing else to commend but the art it's so chefs kiss key plot points: coffee shop owner uke and office guy/project manager seme who has to get rid of the establishments on uke's area due to his job lol rivals to lovers trope!

12/15/22 ch 6 4 stars god i loooove soft ukes sm they make the world and my vision go round cuz their adorableness makes me DIZZY . this is a good short read the buildup of their relationship seemed pretty steady and not super rushed compared to other short stories and i really liked that. art is immaculate. but what really made me feel off is seme .. dont get me wrong hes a decent dude i like that he has not done a single thing to hurt or harm uke in any way shape or form , but , his personality is just bland-ish.. chemistry is high only bc uke made it work he carried that shit he is THE MAN in the relationship lmao but anyway everything is aight ,solid 4/5 key plot points: dentist uke and son of chairman seme had so many encounters you'd think fate herself had something to do with it lol they met they mingled they matched edit 03/27/24 ch vol 2 ch 5.5: reread it from the beginning up to the vol 2 update

12/27/22 ch 7 3.5 stars art is great (as expected from this author), uke's naivety can be really frustrating sometimes, seme is a piece of work, plot was aight, story had an ok flow, chemistry was really off for me at first bc this author has this unique hobby of making some of their semes have their entire personalities dedicated to being good looking and popular only which is annoying thus making it hard for me to see whether they really like uke and if im being gaslighted into seeing good chemistry bc of how good the skinship was. anyway someone said this is ongoing so i look forward to seeing how this meh relationship will progress 3.5/5 key plot points: seme with the personality of a wet cement comforted the insanely naive uke when he was in high school and that single encounter made him decide to follow seme to uni damn (he's obv a feeler not a thinker in this scenario) then they just ..idk , got together there blah - edit 01/19/25 ch 7.5: ok somebody lied and said this was ongoing when i finished reading its 7 chapters lmao

12/30/22 ch 50 4.5 stars really really so close to a 5. might actually be at the end of this book because if there's a word i could use to describe it it would be consistent. and if it remains consistent until the end this will be an easy 5 stars. plot and story clicks and every single question i have whether a trivial one or not always gets answered. basically it has little to no plot holes whatsoever in my opinion. and the story has a good smooth flow, steady and natural buildup of romance, some character developments, POLISHED(!!) writing ..like... it's good ur honor. and dont even get me started with the ART! it ties well with the writing with the way it's supposed to express the emotions aligned with it...i could sing symphonies about this really. also all characters are well-written!! i had a love-hate relationship with seme at first bc he can rly be a huge dick at the beginning with how tactless and insensitive he can be with the insults n such but damn did he eventually do a 180. love that for him and uke. uke i dont have any beef with like hes experienced a lot of hardships already and any other reservations he may have towards seme (or defense mechanisms on anything for that matter) is justified. literally would fight to the death for that cinnamon roll. although i hope he would cut down on the drinking a bit. just want him to be healthy and live longer lol anyway shes a strong 4.5/5!!! looking forward to reading more of this and hopefully it remains consistent until the end<3 pointers: chef mc who's in love with his childhood best friend who's getting married to a girl the ml has been in love with edit 08/04/23 ch 81: the last chapter

01/09/23 ch 40 plot: 4 story: 4 art: 5 writing: 3.5-4 uke: 4.5 seme: 4-4.5 chemistry: 4.5 skinship: 3.5 overall: oh this is a good read. kept me entertained and eager to read more. i do read reincarnation tropes but always had my expectations at a minimum bc they dont always deliver lol but with this one i especially liked the character development of our mc uke. might be unrealistic at first bc like what miss belle said in beauty and the beast live action, "people don't change that much" and miss ma'am is right, it's impossible to completely change overnight esp if youve had the same character for years. but this book really managed to make me root for the mc so everything good that happens to him makes me feel satisfied. doesnt matter whether his overnight 180 degree turn is believable or not lmao. the romance buildup was GEWDDDD. like, healthy good. with good enough reasons to happen kinda good. like satisfying and not rushed kinda good. rooting for them actually. 4/5 pointers: reincarnated actor uke who is determined on changing his horrible future. rich seme. couple of crimes here and there. nice side characters on the mc side edit 05/30/23 ch 60: it ended!! i feel like it was a bit cut short but it was still a good read overall 01/04/24 ch 79: it truly ended :/

02/18/23 ch 27 plot: 3 story: 3 art: 5 writing: 2.5-3 uke: 5 seme: 1 chemistry: 1 skinship: 0.5 overall: uke is the loml. he deserves everything in this world. seme can suck my dick. the translators (bitches from Lunaria Scans) on the first few chapters can suck my dick too :) their unnecessary bitching on their silly little translation notes make it so evident how they're living inside a very privileged bubble. they really think they're on moral high ground and that they're entitled to say whatever the fuck they want since they do the scanlations. and thank god majority of the readers thought the same. mfs dropped the story and was now picked up by a far better more HUMANE person. ANYWAY, story is okay so far and art is great. seme can choke. i wish nothing but bad things for him. i wish the same for that godforsaken scanlation team. pointers: poor orphan uke that looks an awful lot like seme's ex was offered a job at seme's mansion by seme's bro (just cuz ig) so uke went with his baby bro. seme started having lustful dreams abt uke and that attraction gradually manifested in real life and things developed from there lol

04/20/23 ch 1 4 stars ive always always ALWAYS adored this author's works i literally wanna inject every single one of them into my bloodstream thats how serious it is . looking forward to reading this!!! and mentally preparing myself for the disappointment of only having to read until 6 chapters . although hopefully it will be extended!!!! got my fingers n legs crossed for this !!! strong 4/5 pointers: mc who's had an unrequited love for his childhood friend for years, and childhood friend's younger brother who's always been in love with mc !!!! god i love drama - edit 02/28/25 ch 6.5: it ended :(