Hana Ni Kuchizuke
This is hilariously unromanticized and I think I love it. Only 4* because it's not 'timeless classic' level.
Kimi ni Koisuru Hazu ga Nai
The earlier chapters are the funniest with Kitaoji and Chikage accidentally one-upping each other as male leads in a shoujo.
Dekiai Nante Mitomemasen!
Uhhh this ended so abruptly? It's what I wanted from the story (more domestic life) and even has a new side couple I'd love to read about, but it feels incomplete... There's another sequel, but it hasn't been translated yet. Hokuto's immaturity is especially cute here.
Koi Saku Potager
Very cute but feels like it doesn't quite go anywhere.
Konomi ja Naka to
I haven't finished this yet but it is undeniably S-teir they love each other SO MUCH, from how affectionate they are to how the sex is drawn... I've never seen a BL manga so utterly divorced from all those tired tropes and formulas. I love it so much. And now that I'm finished, the rating stands. So good!
Family Simulation!!
Pretty standard stuff, cute and wholesome without (much) gay panic.
Retsujo Love Cross
The couple and story are actually quite good, but the stalker conflict isn't fun so I probably would't enjoy rereading as much.
Himitsu no Love Sensation
Meh, so much comedy without much emotional heart. Not none, but not a lot. The characters are so willfully ignorant and then they just conveniently goes with the flow.
Omaede Dame Nara Moudameda