cmdrbanger's manga / #Magic(3)

Kanata Kara

Complete | HIKAWA Kyouko | 1991 released

Well that was really sweet! I wondered how and why it was so important to mention that Noriko's father was a novelist - and it all circled back around in the end. The whole thing was Noriko's diary, so the unique aspect of her internal monologue summarizing events as they traveled made perfect sense. The ending was a little corny and simplistic, but it was what the whole story had been building to, in a way. A little disappointed Izark didn't have a "good" sky demon transformation, but I guess that would've been counter to the whole "evil transforms you into a monster" theme. I'm glad for the epilogue! Also a little cheesy, but the open ended foreshadowing that one day Noriko and Izark might/will be able to visit Japan together is extra sweet.

Mahoutsukai wa furete tokeru

Complete | hoshikura zozo | 2019 released

Well that was super sweet! I've never seen an uke kiss the seme so sweetly as Liz did in the last chapter! The setup is thoughtful but I wish there was more to the magic and school life, like a longer series would have. (a sign to read Witch Hat lol) Only reason I'm marking it 4/5.

Dotei Yankee Magicus

Complete | Haruta | 2000 released

I wish I could rate this higher and lower, as in I wish they were two different stories. The plot-contrived noncon is a dramatic element handled pretty well, but it's increasingly unpleasant to read, especially at the end when the other mage (who also has an incest subplot!!) tricks the MC into a gangbang. Ew, no. Contrast this with the MC and his best friend navigating the new boundaries of their friendship and falling in love, and the culmination of switching so the mage can lose his virginity (the 'proper' way, I guess