narutolvr's manga / #dumb MC(3)

Doubt

Complete | Izumi Kaneyoshi | 2007 released
2015-10-20 02:24 marked

Tags say it all: girl who was teased in middle school goes out of her way to be beautiful in high school and falls for the first asshole she meets. She then spends the rest of the manga chasing after him, shrugging off him cheating on her, disrespecting her, and generally treating her like crap. And the one moment she actually stands up for herself, tells him that he's not worth it, and you start to feel there's hope for her after all...nope. It's gone. The story immediately goes back to him doing whatever he wants and her chasing after him like a sick puppy. What a great message for girls: if he's rich and handsome, it doesn't matter how awful he is; one day you'll change him! Next time, I hope the author can write about a girl who not only improves her appearance, but her sense of pride and self-worth as well.

Honey Bunny

Complete | Ikuemi Ryo | 2000 released

Didn't like it. The guy was an asshole in the beginning and an asshole at the end and the girl selfishly chased after him like an idiot. And I'm certainly not taking his side, but if someone explicitly tells you to leave them alone and that you're a bother, selfishly trying to force your feelings onto them isn't love; it's an unhealthy obsession. I just couldn't find anything to like about this manga, unfortunately.

Benkyou Shinasai! (nakahara Aya)

Complete | Nakahara Aya | 1997 released
2015-09-16 06:42 marked

Hmm...how do I say this? This was just silly, and not in a good way. It's like it tried too hard to be so stupid it's funny but ended up just being really stupid instead? The main character was dumb to the nth degree, not just "I don't study well" dumb but "I'll confess 100x to a guy who says I'm a bother, apologize about it, and repeat" dumb. And the main guy (really all the male leads in this manga) was so wishy washy it was annoying. It's like they were waiting for the girl to make the first move, otherwise they would never have done anything. The other pairings happened in a heartbeat, as if they completely forgot their feelings for someone else once some random person came out of the woodwork (with a shoddy backstory) and said I like you. All in all, it just seemed poorly thought out. The side story wasn't that bad, wish it were in a different manga so I could have enjoyed it properly.