axima's manga / #student x student(29)

It's good. Kisaragi is an outstanding ML. He's got the Usui "I'm good at anything I do", cute like a cat but cool when he needs to be, little bit flirty without getting creepy or excessive. Neither of them spend too long in denial. Short but sweet little read, as with less lengthy reads though, there isn't enough time to get in to anything big.

It's underwhelmingly ok. The art is decent, but design is a bit plain. The story doesn't do anything that interesting. It's basic and predictable. The reason why I still gave it a 3 is that it can be genuinely cute and knows what it's doing. There aren't any clear flaws other than it's inability to stand out.

The porn tended to feel random and tacked on but they do actually use it for something with the plot eventually which is aleady way better than what you usually get. The story is fairly interesting, they really get all the use they can out of the lie count system instead of letting it fade in to the background as soon as they start dating. Considering how short it is I'm surprised they started dating in like chapter 2 but it works well that way. The ML is super cute I just wanna hug and protecc when I see him

Really not much. The progression of MC's feelings doesn't make much sense it feels pretty random. The thing with the brother never really gets tied up which bothers me, he was basically harassing ML and you don't even confront him about it? The mind reading doesn't end up being used for a lot even though it's there. The last chapter is all about sex and frankly just unecessary, It's not interesting, adds nothing of note to the story other than just being weird, and the actual sex scene probably isn't even long enough for people to get off on it?

really cute. Don't like the other friends much. Art is amazing.

I really wanted to like it and it wasn't awful but... With only a couple chapters the fast pace is to be expected but I really feel like the sex scenes were wasting precious pages that could have set things up more. It's like fam you just confessed ch 1 and now you're rawdogging in the school hallway pls. The art is really good though. The general idea of the story wasn't bad even if the execution was a little clumsy. I will say I'm tired of the trope where the supernatural powers go away at the end, ain't no way an irl person would just be like "wow these powers suck I can just talk to people, take em away god!"

My personal enjoyment is a 3 but objectively it could be higher. It's just quite heavy in a way I don't know how to approach. There isn't really much romance it's more about surviving trauma I guess?

Ngl it's pretty bad. The story doesn't make that much sense and they've got no chemistry. You're just never given a reason to care. The bad luck curse or whatever is literally never explained and presumably doesn't go away. Tagged shounen ai but the side stories are 18+.

3 might be a little harsh but idk the conflict in the latter half felt rushed. The idea is good though and their personalities are cute. Only the extra contains smut.