Faust
Why is this rated so low?! Anybody that rates this below a 5/5 disgusts me. EDIT: This was before I refined my palette so to speak so I can't vouch for this still being true now.
Peach Love
It wasn't good in the sense I usually think of when looking at BL, but that isn't a bad thing. It has an actual plot going on and while the relationship is important it's not at the centre all the time. By the end things got pretty deep. I didn't think I'd enjoy this kind of style as much as I did.
My Starry Sky
I dug the angst because I'm a whore for that stuff but I lost interest after season 1. The ending was nice although I wish there was a little more so it didn't feel so sudden.
Never Understand
It was really good, so it's not like I have any complaints. Something just didn't strike with me here the way it did with my favourite BL's. I didn't think I'd like it at all because the main characters so ugly and while I'll admit it's a bit of a turn off if you're like me, I can safely say you get used to it. The story is still worth experiencing either way.
An Uncomfortable Truth
Really good but so sad I can't keep reading... I was not prepared for the wild ride I was in for.
Nevermore
More plot heavy than your usual BL, and I must say it's a breath of fresh air. I'm tired of the "I'm not gay, nobody can know I'm gay" story. If you're like me and don't want to read porn it's pretty easy to skip. Also no light sabers instead of dicks! Just some careful camerawork.
Silent Color
It was very interesting but in the end nothing feels resolved at all. Couldn't they at least explain someting in an afterword?
Why are you doing this, my Duke!? Webtoon
They're certainly not stingy with the fanservice and I live for it. The romance progresses naturally (despite what it sounds like). I've never been a fan of drama that all stems from stupid arguments the couple have, so I'm glad that common element of shoujo was replaced with an actual plot. EDIT: Ending is lowkey disappointing. I don't think all that had to be shoehorned in there. Or if it was, giving it more time to simmer would be nice. If we're lucky the side stories can fix that. EDIT 2: My internet died and I didn't get to post this edit before. The gist of it is that because of how the plot and ending work a lot of the progress we've had is now effectively meaningless, and the side stories might as well be a soft reboot where we're trying to get back to where we were at before, just more boring when you account for the parts that have changed. They really done fucked up. EDIT 3: It's pretty garbage after the asspull "ending" thing with 30 more sloppy fix-it chapters.
Sincerely: i Became a Duke’s Maid
For a long while there I was unsure but ended up enjoying it. Also this isn't pedo, they're only four years apart and our man gets a growth spurt.
Moritat