Dog's Love Way
I got annoyed at the shitty writing. Light H with some plot, honestly it would've been better with no story. Second ML is a pitiful mat, the antagonist is a rapist that the author tries to redeem, and the misunderstandings between the MCs are suuuuper forced.
Puppy Love
Relies too much on miscommunication to move the plot for me. I also wasn't a fan of how overly indecisive the MC was, like it's fine to struggle to make a choice but let's not pretend like the options themselves aren't super fucking obvious. Either you like someone and want to be with them or you don't, choose and act on it instead of leading people on or hurting them. Even if outside factors are the reason, accept it, explain it, and get over or do something about it.
More than a Play Bite