nini's manga / #Tragedy(9)

now this is one of the most realistic yaoi story i've read !! really heart wrenching, it felt like a rollercoaster ride im just happy that they both ended up together and im happy for noboru too a good read !!

this was so good the rollercoaster of emotions i felt throughout the story AAAAA >< i really liked the pace and the flow od the story !! the MC wasnt annoying at all and i love how the ML overcame his trauma and became a sweet person the ending is just the absolute cutest :< i love how both the sisters got a happy ending one of the best isekai manhwas i've read !! the art is just amazing this was worth reading

ok so im having a hard time to rate this bc im torn in giving it either 4 or 5 stars, i think plot wise it was like a 4.5/4.8 bc i really like arranged marriage plots but there were just some parts that felt a bit dramatic to me since all of this was happening while theyre still 16 and 18 year olds so i just find some scenarios a bit weird and over the top for me, also there were quite a lot of crying involved which just irked me but ig some parts were adorable <3 tbh the development of sachi's feelings were quite fast for me and i didnt really feel the connection at first but as i read they become more cute and fluffy a lot of parts felt so cringey to me which actually shocked me bc i used to love these types of mangas but after reading a bunch of other genres i just felt that my palate changed i like MLs like kouichi even though at first he might sound like a jerk bc he looks like he doesn't care abt sachi but thats bc of his circumstances and he was forced to grow up like that by his grandpa which is just sad :( i felt like there could've been more to the reconciliation of him and his grandpa bc i felt like their conversation was short and i wanted them to build their relationship more but i mean im glad that the granda finally recognized his mistakes and apologized to kouichi plus he gave them a stunning wedding ceremony i actually enjoyed reading this, i wasnt really bored and i liked their dynamic <3 i really loved the timeline type of ending pls i felt emotional it was so so cute ☹️ i just love when authors those types of endings, i think it was perfect as for sachi, i felt like she was a typical MC but im glad that she wasnt as weak and dumb as the others, shes actually very capable and smart so i really liked that abt her she was also very straightforward at times, and she always initiates communication when she feels like something's up :> all the characters are likable but ngl i still feel weird abt mizuho, im confused abt her feelings ?? she always blushes around kouichi but the author didnt explicitly say if she had feelings for him ?? i wished her and the class pres got together though, theyre quite a chaotic duo ❣ the plot was fluffy but it still had some drama and conflicts in it which i liked, i love how kouichi opened up to sachi and became more clingy to her when he finally confessed his feelings now that i've written my comment i would say that i guess i want to rate this 5 stars just bc its hard to find these types of healthy and fluffy romance with arranged marriage as its main plot :> this was a good and fluffy read + the art looks absolutely adorable

ok so i've been putting off reading this bc the tags looked intimidating it had dark, tragedy, bullying, etc. and i cant really handle that much drama so i avoided this, but honestly it wasnt THAT bad like it had some parts that you'll really feel heartbroken and pained but it ended on a happy note so :D when i read it at first, it really piqued my interest bc i havent really read much abt body swapping stories and the plot is really interesting !! though after the whole story, i was left with a lot of questions and it just left me unsatisfied ?? idk how to explain it but like i wanted taemin to get back to his old body bc it didnt feel right but i mean ig both him and woojin are living lives that arent theirs which is also pretty interesting but anyway abt the real siwon i felt so bad for him like he just suddenly died and no one really cared abt him :( he was such a good brother :< and the fact that his brother and joohoon never regretted a thing just gets on my nerves (๑•̀д•́๑) like jiwook was actually like proud (?) when he told siwon (taemin) abt why real siwon committed suicide ?? hes so sick and twisted omfg :/ overall the plot was pretty interesting and unique !! i liked it but there were some parts that felt incomplete and i didnt like how woojin kept on kissing and touching him without consent :0 and also the fact that they knew who siwon was but they never really cared abt the fact that siwon committed suicide just bothers me :( also im a bit confused if taemin and woojin are keeping their identities hidden from their friends or not ?? bc they kept calling each other by their real names so i was confused bc we never saw them telling their friends abt their past etc. and they even called each other by name at the scene where jiwook confessed abt what he did :0 there were lots of unanswered questions thats why i wasnt satisfied but i mean this was the author's first work and for a first time its really good !! the plot was very unique and it made me feel a rollercoaster of emotions ~ i also love the art style ngl i didnt really understand the cd scenario like im still confused abt that part so i'll prolly reread hehe ^^ i mean i enjoyed it but i wish there was more closure and stuff but anyway this was a good read

its pretty good !! i liked the plot <3 do i think that what natsuki did was wrong, absolutely. but out of all the rape stuff that i read, natsuki's was the one that i understand ig ?? like not in the sense of excusing his actions but what im saying is that i understand where he was coming from and why he did that, but i still wont condone him for what he did !!! i also felt like the pacing was kind of fast but im glad that it all worked out in the end it wasnt that angsty which i liked bc i cant handle too much angst overall i liked it <3 the plot felt kind of new to me since i dont think i've ever read something like this so it might be a first :D the development of their relationship felt fast but it went pretty smooth :) im glad that natsuki got closure with his dad ㅠㅠ im glad that hes slowly accepting his father's death and is starting to let go of his trauma (?) bit by bit i really love the last panel, it had a lot of emotions in it ^^ i admired yuni's determination, he never gave up on natsuki and he forgave him for what he did before :> im very happy for them i wanted to see more of them but im pretty satisfied with the ending <3 the art looks pretty too good read !!

this is so good !!! literally bawled my eyes out, esp listening to the songs while reading omfg this shit hurt ㅠㅠ if im being honest there wasnt any complicated twists in the plot but i loved it ngl i was taken aback at what suchae did at the beginning bc that was dubcon and idk what he was thinking but ig thats how they relationship started the pacing's fast but it felt natural to me, i felt their love for each other since they only have the both of them <3 the story had some plot holes like we didnt get the full picture of what happened with the murder (1988 dismemberment), we didnt get a clear look at suchae's family situation, we didnt get to see what happened to k and if there was other ppl involved in the murder, etc. but i still felt satisfied with the ending !! im really glad the author gave us a happy ending ㅠㅠ im glad that they found each other once again and are living a happy life together :( i think the part that hurt the most was with the grandma idk why but it hurt a lot ╥﹏╥ i love how the author portrayed the fucked up justice system, it was very accurate !! the funny thing is that i support the good cop but at the same time i didnt want gusam to be caught so i had mixed feelings the plot was very realistic, other author's would've made a way so that the MC and ML wouldn't get caught or write some reasons as to why they didnt commit the murder, but here we saw that they clearly did a crime which they cannot escape so i think the ending was very fitting if they really wanted to be together :( i mean technically it was self defense but of course the police wont eat that shit so (￣へ ￣) overall i love this story, it made me feel a ton of stuff ~ it kept me hooked while reading and i really felt the couple's connection !! the desperation and emotion in every chapter is amazing we didnt get to see much of gusam's personality since he was too traumatized and disheveled but i think hes a caring and sweet person esp when we got to see them at the end :D he seems like a very reliable guy !! as for suchae, hes a sweetheart ^^ i love him <3 he has a very bright and optimistic personality hes very thoughtful and kind, hes precious ❣ i love their dynamic, i wish we got to see more of their relationship in the modern times but im happy with what we got i was actually avoiding reading this bc i dont read that much angst, my heart cant take stuff like this but this is a masterpiece !! a must read :) this shows you what a desperately inlove person would do for their partner :> i love the grandma, shes an absolute angel i hope that they could also see her in the modern times :( really loved this read :D it was hell of a ride it leaves you with the question of what actually happened on September 17, 1988 ?? im glad i got to read this amazing story the art looks amazing too suchae and gusam in the modern world look stunning such a worth read !!

its been a while since i've put down reviews but this was a masterpiece !! ik it was rocky, painful, and had annoying characters but i must stay the story was full of emotions and i just love how unique it is though it also reminded me of banana fish which is just pain :'DD kyle and sean's relationship seemed like sean used kyle as vinny's substitute ?? but i feel like he also had genuine feelings for him :')) i felt bad for kyle but not really lol bc he looked like he wasn't that much affected by sean and even straight up did it with another man after throwing a tantrum anyway the only character i love is sean though we must admit him doing it with kyle is a bit :/ idk though bc kyle just seems like a little kid but sean was kind and i felt bad esp how he was despised by the one he truly loves :(( i understand that vinny had trauma and whatnot but girl u don't need to kill and traumatize other people just bc of your trauma ???? bestie needs therapy :'> but i'm glad he accepted kyle towards the end and he even named his son after sean :)) i would also like to point out how mature and likeable sandy is ^^ she's one of those best girl characters bc she understood kyle and changed vinny ig ?? i mean i just want to give sandy some credit for not being a part of the annoying character clan :DD overall i think the plot was very interesting and quite unique ^^ i must admit it was a bit annoying and frustrating but it still deserves a higher rating !! there was also some character development so~ i think the selling point for me was the ending bc i'm glad that vinny changed for the better and i love how he still treasures sean even after knowing sean's true feelings for him :)) the art style is gorgeous !! love the classics this was a great read !!