noah's manga / #Showbizzz(41)

81 It’s a well written story. Hate how Sihyeon was suffering all this time and literally no one, not even the members, knew or helped him. Now that he’s a different person, they want to act like he’s their best friend? I don’t mind harem routes but in this case, Sihyeon should end up with Haejin who knows who he really is.

Smut scenes are fine but the assault/SA scenes and mean seme along with the whole debt thing takes away from the art and the atmosphere. Pretty bad. Not exactly a romance.

64. Guy in someone else’s body has to debut or he’ll die. Idol Survival Show. Pretty good.

s 2 ch 5

6. I was excited because this was about idols and reincarnation but it’s pretty disappointing. I don’t like that MC reincarnated into the life of someone who gets opportunities handed to them—it feels boring and unfair to read even though idol agencies irl are like that. I prefer an MC that works hard and struggles to get to where they are because they’re more fun to read and like. Not things the way they are. The only conflict MC has in this life is his soul guide and that’s pure BS. This was a disappointing read.

Ch. 10, it’s pretty boring. The art isn’t good enough to keep you reading a 130 chapters of this.

63. It’s cringe at times.

Idol x Manager

Art changes in S2, but I don’t mind since it’s slightly better. But this story is not very well written. MC and all the other characters feel stiff and lifeless. MC was a dance major who got roped into an idol show and he has to prevent it. But the conflict wasn’t that drawn out. He decided to be an idol pretty quick. Romance is so dull. It’s way below mid.

19. Actually pretty good. Incredible art. Plot is good and highlights actual idol issues