July's manga / #Historical(88)

Feng Yu Jiu Tian

Ongoing | feng nong,WANG Yi | 2010 released
2021-05-06 01:36 marked

It's ok, but the characters are extremely unlikeable. The male lead who isekai'd into this world is a stupid tsundere who is incompetent, and the male love interest is a manipulative asshole. There's no smut scenes so far, but plot development is achingly slow. Art is ok, but hard to tell what is happening sometimes. Looks like this has been dropped. Since the last chapter is Chapter 12, it's finished. Thank goodness, since it was really starting to suck, and it's good that it got cancelled when it did. Only the art was decent. The story made no sense, and characters started appearing out of nnowhere in the last few chapters

Hua Hua You Long

Ongoing | Xing Bao Er,Ai Li Ka | 2011 released
2021-05-29 01:43 marked

The art is really good in this manhua, it's pretty graphic in various aspects, so it's not right for everyone. There's a lot of rape and blood, etc, which will turn most people off. I like dark things like this though, so it doesn't bother me. It's too bad this has been dropped, better off reading the novel. Marking as completed since there won't be any new chapters.

Black Sun

Ongoing | ogasawara uki | 2007 released
2020-09-05 04:57 marked

Classic Stockholm Syndrome with BL and lots of smut. It was decent, I enjoyed the uncensored parts. However, the plot was all over the place and none of the characters were likeable, nor did they have any depth to them. It was a ok read, but I wouldn't read it again. Nothing new to the genre, and it's not extreme or unsettling enough to warrant extra thought on it.

War Dao Sanctification

Ongoing | Luo chen,Ma baofang | 2019 released
2020-09-07 22:08 marked

The art is beautiful, but the translation does not do the story justice. Nothing so far makes any sense, and it's a waste of the the art. The manhua looks like a Chinese comic book, with the thick lines and bold colors. The story has no substance, and is meaningless. What a pity. The male lead is not properly introduced, and we know nothing about his motivations or ambitions, it's just a lot of empty talking. It seems like he had a redo of his old life, but sometimes he himself forgets about everything in his old life, when he should remember to successfully redo this life. Also, it's weird that he's so clueless about important things that he should have remembered if he already live through all of this before. There's nothing worth reading here at the moment, but maybe it will improve in the future?

The Banished Villainess! Living the Leisurely Life of a Nun Making Revolutionary Church Food

Ongoing | Tsumuji yoshimura | 2000 released
2020-09-21 13:10 marked

Female lead is reincarnated into a villainess, who is quickly banished to live as a nun, but she enjoys her new carefree life. Instead of despairing, she starts to cook modern Japanese food for the villagers. All is well until key characters from her villainess life reappear in the monastery she is living in, making her life more complicated once again. It's pretty decent, although weird and nonsensical at times. None of the characters are too stand-out though, so it's mostly forgettable. There isn't much of a plot going on, either.

A Kind Goblin's Bird

Complete | 에이비,8cat | 2019 released
2021-05-07 19:23 marked

Webtoon where a girl who's abused by her parents gets discovered by a man in a goblin mask. Art is quite good, but I am not too fond of the plot right now. It doesn't make sense why the prince would take interest in her, and help her out of her current situation. We'll have to see if it gets better, but I feel like the art is wasted on this bad story so far. Update: Lore is utter nonsense about twins and goblins, sort of like changelings but slightly different. Each chapter is a waste of time to read. Just the two main characters being sickly lovey-dovey to each other, and nothing else happening. Update #2: Well, that escalated quickly in the end. Made no sense, and characters didn't earn their happy ending.

Sultan’s Love

Complete | 춈춈,꽁 | 2019 released
2021-06-08 03:07 marked

The art is really good, and the paneling as well. I'm not getting a good feel of the characters right now, so I will adjust ratings as needed when more chapters are released. I like the ruthlessness of the sultan and I hope it's not just some cheap trick to make him seem mean for no reason, while he's nice to the female lead in a fake forced contrast. Will keep my eyes posted for more. Update: The female lead is an idiot, and the male love interest sultan guy is always saving her. Leaves a bad taste in my mouth. And it's creepy that he is in love with his father's concubine, even if they didn't sleep together. It's also the whole reason why he rebelled and killed all his siblings in the first place too. Really? Love over everything? It's just so cliche. They don't even really love each other...That's just what they want readers to feel, but I'm not fooled. Not much happens, they have some more sex, then she magically became more assertive, and boom, the end. Meh.

Broken Boy

Complete | Doya , DUNDUN , Rieul | 2019 released
2020-10-08 00:50 marked

Art is quite good, it gives a 1900's feel. Premise is male lead is in a complicated family where he's abused by his father, and he wants to bring him down by becoming a male prostitute. The man who solicits him has a grudge against the male lead's older half brother, so they join forces and have lots of sex. Convoluted plot shenanigans abound. The best part is the art, but I'm not too fond of the other stuff. It's just not compelling to read, since it's hard to sympathize with these characters.

Gintama dj - Mienai Kusari

Complete | Paraiso,Harada | 2013 released
2020-10-09 20:17 marked

Very dark and delicious, it shows the mental breakdown of a strong-minded character in a convincing way. Mind break is great when done right, and this is one of those rare times. It's pretty disturbing, so it won't be everyone's cup of tea.

31st Consort

Ongoing | tsubasa nanaki,nanaio yamashita | 2019 released
2020-10-10 19:54 marked

It started off promising, but just lags in the recent chapters. I find the idea of having 31 consorts really stupid, since it's not like they will all be prominent characters. Just come up with a couple and have them compete so we'll get to know them better. I really hate it when authors make up a huge number for the sake of huge numbers and put no thought towards execution. As I suspected, only about three consorts are important, other than the main character consort candidate. She's like a bright, cheery, nothing-will-get-her-down type character, and it was ok at first, but now it's boring since she hasn't really been challenged. Everything comes too easily to her and it's not fun to read about. The king almost immediately falls in love with her, and she with him. Sigh.