Sekaiichi Hatsukoi
Sono Koi ni wa Wake ga Aru
UPDATE: From 3 stars to 4 after reading this the second time around. Just really liked the story after really reading it carefully unlike the first time. The two are really adorable and even though the Seme can be real stoic and emotionless, I love how he has his moments. It makes them more meaningful.
Junjou Romantica
ANOTHER YAOI CLASSIC. It's one of those mangas that start off wobbly and then it begins to STEADILY DROWN YOU WITH ITS SWEETNESS!!! And every time I read this, my heart just becomes so light and so heavy and you're left feeling whole and complete.
Nar Kiss
Gouin Sakka To Makeinu No Hatsukoi
Holy shit, I finally fucking found this again motherfuckers. I thought I lost it forever to the Yaoi sea but no. I found it once more. T^T This is so freaking great, it got updated too wtf so nice. UPDATE: Holy crap, this is going to have a sequel. YASSSSSSSSSS.
Honto Yajuu
This is probably one of the healthiest yaoi couples I've ever had the fortune of seeing. Everything is so filled with enthusiastic consent. The Uke doesn't go, "No more." or "Stop it.." throughout the whole intimate times while the Seme just ignores it and just continues. NO. THIS UKE LOVES IT AND I LOVE THAT HE LOVES IT. And the building of the relationship is so fucking good. They're such adorable cinnamon rolls. These babies... You gotta luv them so much... (UPDATE: This thing is seriously in my Top 3 out of practically 600 yaoi mangas out there. It'll always have this special place in my fangirl heart.)
Kunpuu Tango