it's one thing to just not like the art style or think it's ugly, which i honestly do, but they look like actual children the way it's drawn. from the comments i can assume they recently had sex and that's just... uncomfortable with how they look. I made it through two chapters before I put it down. The eyes are just too damn much.
idk, something about the way it's drawn has thrown me off since chapter one and i just cant read it anymore. All the characters are drawn super sharp and harsh, and the ones that are supposed to be beautiful are just ugly to me. Her family, Tev, even Sylvia. And the way their teeth are drawn so sharply in every image, it always looks like they have fangs or something idk. The art is just... ugly to me. On top of that, I really just don't like the FL. I know I'm supposed to pity her past self and resent the ones who made her feel that way but tbh i just don't. The story just hasn't done enough to really flesh her out or her supposed tragic backstory. It TELLS me I should pity her, but doesn't really show me why. For all that "happened to her", she was a hundred times worse. The past Sylvia was literally just a whiny, vindictive little bitch. With a lot of FLs in the isekai trope, you get a FL who understands that their past shitty behavior was the reason for the shit that happened to them. Sylvia just blames everyone here except herself and takes no accountability for her awful personality, which honestly doesn't feel that different even with "new" Sylvia. Since she's still blaming everyone but herself, she still feels like the bratty Sylvia, and honestly she's just disgustingly rude to everyone for no reason. As far as her dad and brother are concerned, all they've known until now is the awful Sylvia, so why should they be expecting anything else?? She "went off" on her father the day after the old Sylvia broke her sisters arm?? Like girl shut the fuck up?? Sylvia was a nasty brat, how do they know you've suddenly taken over her body? Same with the brother like?? And I just... don't care that they were "mean" to past Sylvia and supposedly that's enough to explain her naturally shitty behavior - the old Sylvia was jealous and vindictive from the start, and her own nasty personality is what made her "ugly" and caused her to gain weight and act even worse. I just don't blame her environment. I think the original Sylvia was a vindictive little brat and, as the story hasn't actually SHOWN me a reason to pity her rather than just telling me I should, I'm going to keep that opinion. Honestly, it's just not my cup of tea and not my idea of a strong FL.
You can't say that the art is ugly when no one's told you to critique their work. It's their art and you're not the one to judge someonelse hard work, since your reading it in an illegal site. If you don't like it, just drop it.
I can say anything is ugly that I'd like to. It's simply called an opinion. This is my review of the story and of the art style. We leave comments so that other people can read them and decide for themselves whether to read a story, or to find other people who had the same thoughts as them. Not all of those thoughts will be positive. If you can't handle that, perhaps YOU should just leave the site. It's just one person's thoughts who read the story. If it bothers you that badly, you should probably get out more. You told me if I don't like it just drop it? Well if you don't like my comment then just scroll past it.
Yeah i'm aware that's an opinion, but you're opinion is kinda offensive. You can state your opinion without saying offensive words such as an ugly art. Every artist has their own art style, and yeah i know that the art style isn't your style. You can just say that you're not into their art style, not the art is ugly, that's what you called art style. And yeah you can't complain about their art style since you're just reading it in an illegal site.
What would you feel if someone told you that your art is ugly and that person who told you that was reading it in an illegal site? What would you feel?
No, it's not lol. I actually was fairly nice about it. I tried to explain WHY I didn't like the art and what about it I found unappealing and why it didn't vibe with me. You don't have to like my opinion, or agree with it, but all I did was use one regular adjective to describe the art and you're in my replies telling me what I can and can't do? Again, that's the purpose of comments is to express our feelings and thoughts about the story. They will not all be positive. I do not have to sugarcoat a negative review just so sensitive people like you don't get offended by a single word. I can promise you that this artist has thicker skin than you do and understands that not everyone will like what they do. As an author and artist myself, I get that what I make isn't going to impress everyone. It's okay for someone to express their opinion in a comment section. I'm not going out of my way to harass this artist or drag their work wherever I can - I reviewed it, and for some reason that's set you off. It doesn't matter what site this is on lol? There's still a comment section for the purpose of expressing our opinions? You don't have to pretend to like something you don't just to comment here, Nick. And I'm not going to start just because you're ~bothered.~
Honey, you shouldn't have to sugarcoat your opinions and pretend that you like it. What i'm trying to say is be careful of what words you'll use, coz you don't know if that person is thick skinned or not. You haven't even met them so how can you be sure that they're thick skinned? You can state your opinion without harsh words right? You can point what's the defect on it without saying such words. And as you said that you're an author and an artist, so you should know the feeling. And also i asked you a question, why did you drop your statement without answering my question? It's kinda rude to me lol. And also it does matter the site lol, if you're not paying for their artwork you're not the one to say such words.
Btw thank you for wasting your time having an argument with me lol, you help me alot for my upcoming debate wink* love lots
I made it perfectly clear how I felt about your question, "honey," I'm sorry the context clues went a bit over your head. I wouldn't care if someone had a negative opinion about my works because that's life. I'm not going to feel any particular way - it happens. Not every opinion or reaction in this world is going to be sugar-coated and perfectly tailored so you never have to hear a harsh thing, Nick. We don't live in bubbles or safe spaces where just because YOU tell ME that something I say is too harsh, that I have to agree with or listen to you. It's my opinion, and I'll continue to have it. I said the word UGLY. I said nothing so offensive for you to STILL BE IN MY REPLIES telling me what I can and can't do in a comment section of a manwha. Good lord, you must be absolutely useless in the real world if a single word on this site bothered you so much. You're gonna be okay, Nick. The illustrator is gonna be okay, Nick. The world isn't ending, Nick. And for the last time, the site literally doesn't matter. People are here to read and discuss their opinions and that's why there's a comment section. Just because you don't LIKE my opinion or how I stated it doesn't mean I can't have it. Now please, go bother someone else on this site. If you look closely, there's plenty more with opinions like mine for you to pick from.
since you say this is a review, i think it's better to deliver it to the author or in the official site, who knows ur opinion can help the author especially ur opinion sounds like critics.
btw this is a suggestion, no need to reply me long like the way u reply other's comment cus i won't read a long argument lol.
and there's no need for you to reply to me again at all xoxo
They literally just walked up to him in a training yard full of men and ladies watching them and were like hey, you're getting married, you're sixteen, it's time, oh and she'll be here soon. Lmao what in the wattpad is this? I know it's tempting to get to the FL & ML meeting but damn, world building is crucial if you don't want your story to come off as dumb and unbelievable as... well, as this. Lmao they really just rolled up in front of god and everyone and dropped major ass information about the future of the empire in front of a bunch of kids. Ridiculous.
Idk if I should spoil u or nah but the story is not really dumb it's more like a, detective type atm as both of them are solving stuff and there's really no a lot of romance involve so
There is not a lot romace yet ╮(￣▽￣)╭
Its actually pretty good. I thought the same but I kept reading and it doesn't have much romance so far just detective stuff it's pretty good ngl.
Yea! And MC is strong too
Well, regardless of what genre it is, the maturity level of both the writing and the storyline was obvious in that one scenario. If I'm reading a fantasy plot about emperors and kingdoms etc, I'm expecting the plot to take itself seriously. They just strolled into a courtyard full of teenagers and were like yo man, you're getting married. lol that's just... all I need to know about every other situation in this story. I'm sure this story appeals to plenty of people. It's just not the sort of story that appeals to me.
But that doesn't define the whole story just because you read one scenario and yes it's very stupid to start off with "oi your getting married" But that doesn't mean it will lead to them gettin married immediately, anyways I'm just saying that story is not dumb and that's all but that doesn't mean you have to read it we all have our preference so ╮(￣▽￣)╭
I just can't read stories with FLs like this. She has two personality traits - crying and being dumb. That's literally all she does. She cries from the first chapter about every single thing. Just looking at the ML is enough to make her cry. She hardly speaks and when she does she's just begging him to stay with her. She has all the personality of a wet cabbage. There's literally a scene where she's sobbing bc they're riding a horse and he's going really fast and she's "s-so s-scared." It's vomit worthy how useless she's been this entire story but I'm supposed to believe he's actually intrigued by her?? I'm sure if I read to the end it'll wind up being explained by some preordained work of God that he was destined to love her blah blah blah. The plot armor of all FLs with no personality. On top of that, she's actively stupid. The only things she told herself not to do, she did. Repeatedly getting close to him, drawing him in, and then when he finally confesses to her, lo and behold it's time to cry again and reject him because she doesn't want to hurt him more in the future lmao. She all but throws herself at this man, then when he goes to kiss her she's a trembling, crying, useless lump... girl, idk what your endgame story here is but you came from the modern world at one point, why are you acting like this over a kiss? It's so unbelievably cringeworthy how she acts at every tiny touch. Forty chapters and barely anything has even happened besides her crying and then they rode a horse together in a competition. That's it. I'm not even mad that the ML here is actually gross and does shit like poisoning and killing his horse while they're riding just to throw them off and injure them so he can have her attention. It's unattractive and slimy, but he's supposed to be the villain so whatever I guess. Honestly, yall gotta set better standards for the stuff on here you call amazing storytelling. This FL is literally a piece of cardboard that cries and the ML is abusively obsessive over her past the point of villainy being an excuse. The author really needs to learn how to give her characters actual personality traits before she tells a story again. Oh, and the art is honestly just ugly. I tried to find it offbeat and pretty. But really, the art makes everyone look ugly.
Are you okay ? Did something happen to you?
I'm not sarcastic, I'm just a little worried about you
(⊙…⊙ )
Only this terrible story but thanks for being so sincere and checking on me
I agree with the FL having a personality of a wet cabbage lol
Even her sister has more personality than she has
But the story is kinda good tho if you overlook her boring ass personality
I liked the 2nd season than the 1st season since it's not only about the FL crying, and has an actual story line that it follows rather than 'I love this character and I wanna save him' type of shit
At 93 chapters it's shorter than most other completed stories in this genre, so it was sort of a given that it wouldn't have as detailed or drawn out of a plot, and that the romance would happen quicker. It does feel a bit rushed because of this, but within it's own story it makes sense. Like I said, it's not as detailed as other stories - it's really a bare bones plot that's fairly predictable to follow. There's a very simple problem, and a very simple, uncomplicated solution and conclusion. Don't expect any amazing twists or turns here, it's fairly formulaic. It also reads extremely G rated, so again if you're looking for any sort of amazing maturity, be it emotional or physical, you're not going to find it here. All of the characters, especially the two leads, come off young and silly rather than mature or complex. The MC is loud and abrasive, always turning beet red for no reason and pointing and yelling when she's embarassed, and the male lead is pretty much the same. He has a few more deeper moments than she does, but still not enough to convince me either one of them were really Emperor and Empress material. Overall, it's a cute, short read if you're bored like I was waiting for other, better stories to update.
Just imagine, this intricate and mature plot is what The Abandoned Empress could have been. Finally, a Tia to make up for that god awful excuse of a heroine. I have zero bad things to say about this story, and that's including the story spoilers I've read up through the ending. The plot just gets better and better, and there's no doubt the webcomic will capture everything perfectly. The first life here is interesting, our heroine started getting shit done day one in her second life, she might not be a fighter like some heroines in this trope but she gets more done than most of them combined. The love interest is ***chefs kiss***. Supporting cast is interesting, all of the various plot lines are intriguing, and I won't post spoilers but this shit gets i n t e n s e asf and dark as hell in some parts. 10/10. I put this in my personal top three after Suddenly Became A Princess One Day and before Seduce the Villain's Father.
This has got to be the most refreshing reincarnation story I've picked up in ages. I can't count the number of times I've had to drop the phone from laughing so hard my stomach hurt, and yet even with how absolutely ridiculous and funny it can be, it still takes itself seriously and has an incredibly interesting storyline with hidden depth. I just can't decide my favorite aspect - Melissa's meme faces, her routinely going "What the f u c k?", the "male leads" discovering their hidden dominatrix kink every time Melissa beats their fucking ass and makes them grovel, Yuri being so mfn fed up w/this shit ass story she's stuck in, Yona and her bling, or Nine looking at Melissa like O.O and indulging in his newly acquired kink for head pats and Big Thick Bitches that routinely whoop wholesale ass. 10/10 story, I can't think of a single bad thing to say about this fourth wall breaking masterpiece.
I gave it my best shot. There are so few completed stories in the "fall into another world" or "reincarnation" tropes that when I saw a completed story with good reviews, I jumped on it. How this got those good reviews is just beyond me. This story reads like the cheesiest Wattpad novel I could imagine. Every line and interaction is cringe worthy, the MC is an absolute child, the love interest is grossly immature as well, the "villainess" is just as bad. It's impossible to take anything seriously due to the atrocious dialouge and lack of depth. There are other more developed stories in this trope with mature characters and storyline to spend your time on. This one just ain't it.
Can you suggest some good reincarnation stories with good plots...like really good plots please
Absolutely! Of course, most of them aren't completed. Almost all of the best ones are still ongoing. The only completed one that I personally loved was The Reason Raeliana Ended Up At the Duke's Mansion. But here's all my favorite ongoing ones - the best one is definitely Suddenly Became A Princess One Day, then The Villainess Lives Twice, Seduce the Villains Father, & Beware of the Villainess! Now, here's a few that I personally didn't vibe with for various reasons, but are actually very popular with other people so you may enjoy them. The Abandoned Empress (complete), Doctor Elise (complete), As You Wish Princess (complete), I Became the Ugly Lady, The Black Haired Princess, & Empress of Another World.
Oh, and this isn't an isekai recommendation, but it's my current number 2 favorite manwha and it's fantasy romance so you might still like it! It's called Under the Oak Tree.
Same. I think it's the fact that most who read this are teenagers. I've been in that phase and anything cheesy sounds romantic but now I'm older, I realized how problematic and cringe worthy my fave books were hahaha
Thank you
i think the beginning of the story is REALLY cheesy but close to like 40 chapters in I believe the story becomes less cheesy. I especially like chapters 100+ and up now those were good.
Thanks a ton....
i tried soo hard to get into this story bc the plot was so interesting, and it's one of the very few reincarnation comics that are complete (looking at you, Suddenly Became A Princess One Day ) but unlike that masterpiece, this story couldn't hold a candle. For such an intense and mature beginning plot to the story, it almost immediately fell off and became flat, boring, and plain dumb. Every interaction, motivation, and scenario in this story felt childishly simple and G rated. There was no depth to anything, situations are minimal in their intricacy and complexity, character interaction is painfully cheesy and one dimensional, and the heroine, who should feel at least slightly mature as she's a grown woman in a young girls body, falls flatter than anybody. So just because she smiles in this time and speaks a little more, suddenly people are falling at her feet and she's off on some absolutely out of nowhere plot to be a... knight? God this story was painfully simple to be dragged out for 145 chapters. I'm not even mad she ended up with Ruve - it was dumb for anyone to ever assume otherwise tbh, this story was cliche asf from the first three chapters. I'm just disappointed that after such a dark and mature past life together, that could have led to some truly intense storytelling and real character growth together as a couple, that it was turned into such a childish fantasy of a story. Guess we're back to waiting for SBAPOD, this was nothing but a cheap knockoff.
"from the author of Orange Marmalade-" DONT MIND IF I FUCKIN DO