Melancholy April 12, 2021 12:11 am

Here's my Take on why the Dad Killed the ML, Parent (more specifically just his father) because for me, it was pretty obvious the he actually stabbed his dad...

1st guess... The mothers ML probably died 1st, because of all the commotion, and the Dad of the ML probably asked his dear friend (The MC Dad) to take his life, bacuase neither way he was gonna die, but he wanted to die in his hands (You know how some people in stories want to die in the hands of thier love once [Which I actually find pretty cruel] , Its something like that), but also at the right time the ML came out.

2nd guess... The ML Dad Probably betrayed the MC dad(for some reason), accidentally killing his wife at the procces, and out of guilt wanted his friend to kill him personally, and that's also the reason why Our MC Dad never bothers to explain as to what happened to the ML to nit cause him more pain.

3rd guess.. basically just a fusion of 1st and 2nd, he wasn't the one who killed his wife, his wife just die from the commotion but he did betray the MC Dad.

You know... typical plot twist sht...

Melancholy April 11, 2021 11:38 pm

Please I'm so happy everyone's response in this chapter was positive, most/some people in the novel were literally hating on maxi because of her lack of control of the situation... Like aren't one of the biggest reason why we all reading this was to see the growth of maxi? Ya'll expect her to suddenly forget about the abuse she recieve in her so called "Home" 3 months (or probably less) ago??? Please stick with your shounen Jump, your clearly in a different genre. They seriously annoyed the hell outta me...(╯°Д °)╯╧╧

Melancholy April 7, 2021 2:52 am

So that's why, I was always curious on how the fck does maxi doesn't any sign of abuse (such as bruises, wounds, or etc) in her body, well I did guess there was a healer, but none have confirmed my curiosity untill now, (tho for some sort of reason The novel didn't mention this [or maybe it did and I wasn't just paying that much attention/can't remember at that part] )

Ps: does anyone want a spoiler, cuz maybe I can give one since I'm quite ahead, just if you want to since I also known that feeling, curiosity I mean...

    xxxx123 April 7, 2021 2:57 am

    spoilers pls

    Melancholy April 7, 2021 4:58 am
    spoilers pls xxxx123

    So 1st spoiler (whats gonna happen after this chapter)... the person that's coming really isn't maxi father rather it's a runaway lord (or noble) that's visiting (or more specifically forcing thier way in

    Melancholy April 7, 2021 5:01 am
    spoilers pls xxxx123

    Ohhh yeah, cute fact just incased you didn't know, The manhwa/novel title is under the oak tree because maxi and riftan 1st ever met "Under The Oak Tree" ...

    Melancholy April 7, 2021 5:08 am
    So 1st spoiler (whats gonna happen after this chapter)... the person that's coming really isn't maxi father rather it's a runaway lord (or noble) that's visiting (or more specifically forcing thier way in Melancholy

    For some sort of reason it didn't tell all the thisng I said so I'll just type it again...

    So 1st spoiler (whats gonna happen after this chapter)... the person that's coming really isn't maxi father rather it's a runaway lord (or noble) that's visiting (or more specifically forcing thier way in) and maxi will be handling them, or atleast will try to handle them... get this will be seeing riftan in 2-3 chapters (probably) he will be artivung in the right moment, yes will be seeing him soon because our boy despite supposedly arriving 3-4 days before that ended up arriving earlier since he rushed his return.... "One bruiese, One head" rigtan basically saif when he saw maci got hurt because of all the commotion... he was ready to start a war for her...

    Melancholy April 7, 2021 5:10 am
    spoilers pls xxxx123

    Spoiler 2... as Ruth said maxi has an affinity for mana, so ruth will be teaching her magic (Idk if I remember this correctly, about rith teaching maxi magic thay is, but ine things for sure maxi will be learning magic just not sure if its from ruth)

    Melancholy April 7, 2021 5:12 am
    spoilers pls xxxx123

    Spoiler 3... based on the spoilers I've read bothe rosetta and Maxi were both abused, which is believable since maxi did keep mentioning that rosetta gets more attention then her, but he neveronce mentioned rosetta ever mistreating her.

    Melancholy April 7, 2021 5:14 am
    spoilers pls xxxx123

    Spoiler 4... or more likely a fun/cute fact

    "Riftan mention a popular story about a young man who trespass on Max's mansion/castle in attempt to ease his curiosity about her. He never mention that it was him but i am pretty much sure that it was Riftan himself and he got love at first sight or fell in love with her by this event."

    -From the comment section of the novel..

    Melancholy April 7, 2021 5:16 am
    spoilers pls xxxx123

    Bare with my English and Spelling, I was in arush typing them and didn't get the time to double check it..

    kenken April 7, 2021 8:14 am

    Hello! can you tell me where you read the novel?
    I'm not really good in English so I might be surprised by reading an English novel but I really want to learn, and I'm really invested in this story, so I think I might be able to enjoy reading the novel even if I have to squeeze my brain ε=ε=(ノ≧∇≦)ノ

    Kana° April 7, 2021 9:24 am

    If you notice in early chapter, when her father abused her with his stick(I think), there's an old man immediately heal her.
    Her father we'll prepare I guess bruh ( ̄へ ̄)

Melancholy March 19, 2021 2:30 am

I thought the father was an abusive husband and dad, but his actually pretty decent and cares for his family...

    Melancholy March 19, 2021 2:38 am

    like I won't say his the best dad, but his decent, I mean compared to other charters I've encounter in the past who had the title of a "father" but wasn't one, he on the other hand actually gives sht bout his family, ready to throw away his pride for his family, like he actually cares and not just some BS father/husdand.

Melancholy March 17, 2021 9:20 am

I mean come on!
The Grandpa Guilt triped ijin, Yuna blamed ijin as "A possible threat" (which I understand since the girl needs to be cautious because of her status so I don't hate her but it still left a bad taste in my mouth),that aunt was a total B***h... So far Yunas father was the only I like from thier family, and his dead... Wow!

    Cythia Cortez March 17, 2021 9:51 am

    Good people have it hard on earth so they go to heaven.

Melancholy February 20, 2021 5:12 pm

I actually have a theory about all this... so the theory is

I feel like her father was one of the person who came back to the past... remember they said thier was a 3rd person? But they can't remember who? Her father in some of the 1st chapters had some constant memories/dream of the future... and it actually would make sense why kiera was also choosen to be the 3rd person to go back to the past even tho the she was never acquainted with the mage... especially by the fact stand that they say the "other person" chooses who's memories get restored/stay/preserved... which kiera responded as "Are you ok? Cuz I don't remember using such a spell." ... so his father could have choosen kiera to preserve her memories and him to forget...


Ps: How the hell was my brain able to make this???

    Melancholy February 20, 2021 5:13 pm

    THIS IS JUST A THEORY THO!

    Shenelle February 20, 2021 5:33 pm

    yes he did. it was actually mentioned in some spoilers

    Rika347 February 20, 2021 5:34 pm

    May contain spoilers in the explanation lol:

    Yeah I think that theory is close, cuz if I remember some things I read and things from the start of the chapter, like her dad realize pd(in the first timeline) he fucked up and that (spoiler) cosette or whatever is a demon/devil whose here to ruin the kingdom and so that’s why he(the dad) goes back with the wizard/mage whatever to fix things which leads to that theory.

    Melancholy February 20, 2021 5:44 pm
    yes he did. it was actually mentioned in some spoilers Shenelle

    Wait what really???!

    Melancholy February 20, 2021 5:47 pm
    May contain spoilers in the explanation lol:Yeah I think that theory is close, cuz if I remember some things I read and things from the start of the chapter, like her dad realize pd(in the first timeline) he fu... Rika347

    Ok I knew the crosette spoiler that in fact the real crosette is already dead and that person is a demon using her body... but I'm just really shock on how the theory that I came up with was actually right... I suddenly feel smart Lol HAHHAHAHAHHA

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.