Actually… the webtoon and the novel of silent lover is actually good. It’s just that the translators for this manhwa keeps changing, making the translations inconsistent, and sometimes the translations are wrong or out of touch; not properly conveying the characters words. This cause the readers to get lost of the story.
I suggest you guys read the novel… and compare it to the manhwa after, bec the novel was actually good.
Where can I read the novel?
Thank you so much
I’m really curious as to what happened between Piwon and Juha. Why he said in the past that he’s his treasure and suddenly turned 180, and treating him like trash. I’m guessing, just a guess... Juha was like that fish beautiful but empty, and when Piwon do all that hideous act on him that’s when he sees a desperate and helpless Juha. I mean the guy doesn’t obviously need those pearls (throwing them out the toilet), I think it’s just an excuse to see Juha helpless in those moments, like he can give such emotions after all.
I really want to know his backstory, like this guy obviously likes Juha, but where did it all go wrong. Lol. Season 2 please!!!
This continues to Juha crying and begging Piwoon. Then Doosik was tied and beaten.
They’re testing out that stuff for the sex column right? Seungchan was jealous bec Hyesung was aroused by the vibrator (That’s like saying his dick wasn’t good enough) and was like, “I guess you don’t care what goes inside of you.” So Hyesung got pissed and said, “I’m not in the mood to do it.” They’re a COUPLE so what rape are you talking about? You guys are just being too sensitive.
you can still rape your partner, he repeatedly told him to stop but guess what : he didn’t listen and kept going
doesn’t matter if they’re a couple retard, you can still rape your partner. wow i hope you never get into a relationship.
No I’m in a relationship, and you’re too sensitive in things like this, CLEARLY you’re a single retarded person. What would you know about couples having fun in bed, If this was real life obviously it was rape when he said stop and no, but then tell me what yaoi didn’t you read the uke not saying stop or no? Don’t mix this with your single miserable life...you unenlightened serf.
Seungchan said if he wanted to try it, Hyesung agreed, and there was consent. He said stop and you’re right, but then again he said to put it in. Why would a rape victim said to put it in? I will reiterate this, they’re just a couple having fun; you’re just overthinking this.
trust, i’m more experienced than you’ll ever be. just because it happens a lot doesn’t mean it’s not rape you fucking cretin. you’re probably like 12 yo which doesn’t make sense bc you literally have the brain of a neanderthal.
They’re both couples and there was consent in the beginning. You’re just biased in interpreting “rape” in ways that are consistent with your preference. That means that you ultimately come to believe that your judgment that Hyesung was raped supports the position that you already wanted to believe was true. Well I guess... people blur the line between moral and factual judgments. Haha fight me. =p
Forgetting everything. Sorry to butt in. But it is a level of rape. Since the Uke was 100% percent against doing something dating doesn't justify these stuff.
Also, in sex if one of the people didn't wanted to do something (even if they agreed to sex) doing something against their will is sex. If one wanted to stop the entire thing and forcing him to continue it's considered rape. Regardless if they're friends, sex buddies, dating, married, etc
If there's no consent or if consent stopped somewhere in the middle what's after is rape.
I don't blame you though, in 2018 a survey was collected on university students in the US to see if they knew what consent was is.... And more than 50% provided answers that was against consent and by law is punishable.
...
Also, to be clear this is BL comic... The sex is unrealistic. If someone did these things to their partner they could probably hurt them... Really bad. Bottoming fucking hurts if the top forced himself on you. Dick sucking can literally chock you or make you puke if the partner forced the other to suck him and didn't give him time to adjust.
Even women, like the saying goes don't fuck a woman when she's dry and use lube. The same goes with a man. It requires us more preparation for sex so having a top who does these things outside of a play or fantasy is extremely dangerous....and to be honest a little bit traumatizing.
Back to the bl... The Uke wad literally forced on sex in the past and the seme was one of the best characters because even though he was a beast in bed... Nothing was done against the uke consent. But the side stories.... Hands down its the author just wanting a hot forceful sex not related to the plot.
just because there was consent in the beginning doesn’t mean he consented it the whole time. he told him to stop multiple times and even tired to get away. you seriously make me sick !
agreed, but everyone has different boundaries. although i didnt necessarily like it, we don't know if they've discussed this before, but yeah it was kinda uncomfy either way
Lol, so you’re suddenly a rape expert.
There are two types for rape in BL. There's the nonconsensual and there's the criminal sexual assult. A lot of nonconsensual scenes in BL would be considered forced.
A relationship can start from nonconsensual rape, if the other person is just pretending to be resistant or they end up liking it.
And then there’s the 'actual' criminal sexual assault. This is obviously nonsense because nonconsensual acts are still nonconsensual even if the other person is attractive or a love interest.
That’s why the most important part in BL sex scene is consent.
You said: “just because there was consent in the beginning doesn’t mean he consented it the whole time.”
In rape, Physical resistance is not required on the part of the victim to demonstrate lack of consent.
Excuse me but...you make me sick for putting words into your mouth that you don’t even understand.
You are right about consent but,
The old definition of rape: “Forcible rape” had been defined as “the carnal knowledge of a female, forcibly and against her will.”
This definition, is unchanged since 1927, was outdated and narrow. It only included forcible male penile penetration of a female vagina.
The new definition is: “The penetration, no matter how slight, of the vagina or anus with any body part or object, or oral penetration by a sex organ of another person, without the consent of the victim.”
This definition also includes instances in which the victim is unable to give consent because of temporary or permanent mental or physical incapacity.
Furthermore, because many rapes are facilitated by drugs or alcohol, the new definition recognizes that a victim can be incapacitated and thus unable to consent because of ingestion of drugs or alcohol.
The ability of the victim to give consent must be determined in accordance with individual state statutes.
Physical resistance is not required on the part of the victim to demonstrate lack of consent.
Back to the manga...
People are just opening a whole can of worms in the side story of this manga. They end up believing what they want to believe. They’re just a couple having fun in bed, suddenly a lot of rape experts are appearing.
There was literally consent in the beginning. They’re a couple. If you felt uncomfortable then that’s you. Let me give you an example, if I broke up with my boyfriend and hated him, and filed a rape case will he be jailed? The answer is NO, that is unviable to the statutes of rape bec we’re a couple. If my boyfriend forced me sexually without consent he can be charged of SEXUAL ABUSE, not “RAPE”. Bec if that happens a lot of people will be charged of rape my ghad, they could be pretending to be resistant and not liking it. That’s why CONSENT is important in the beginning, Bec physical resistance is not required on the part of the victim to demonstrate lack of consent, and Let me reiterate this again, You’re just biased in interpreting “rape” in ways that are consistent with your preference. When in fact in the manga it wasn’t rape, it could be sexual abuse; but not rape.
what the fuck are you talking about
I’m sorry that you can’t comprehend, and please wash your filthy mouth with soap.
They will end up to be as....
Fuck buddies. Lol. Idk how they will play it in the webtoon, but that’s what happened in the novel.
so they will not end being boyfriends at all?????
Damn that’s a turn I thought this would be more wholesome lol
They will eventually end up dating and finally see that movie together. But both will be hesitant to confess their feelings, since jaeyoung will be graduating soon and going abroad.
It won’t be for long. When they start doing that game together...hahahaha... things will go on the hotter side.
OMG cant wait for this to become yaoi , i hope it become one
do u know where to read the novel?
With how things right now, can't even imagine them being fuck buddies. Like he even panicked for having a boner lol. Hopefully webtoon will be more wholesome and on the fluffy side.
Whoa? But it is shonen ai so maybe just a panel where they are naked or what? Lol. Btw, where did you read the novel? Can you please share it with us?
Probably yaoi, but not hardcore Idk they looks so precious for me. If things escalated like that hopefully fully, it's not too hardcore to brisk their innocence image in my head. Like the uke is too precious to be just a fuck buddy
It’s even funnier when he downloaded a BDSM porn for reference on how male to male sex is done, and he thinks it’s really done that way. Sangwoo is really cute... haha. But, ahem... Jaeyoung will teach him how it’s properly done.
Sangwoo is innocent, but Jaeyoung is not, he’s Bi and he sleeps with boys and girls. Sangwoo will become frustrating later for me when they started dating, like he always make Jaeyoung feel like they’ll eventually break up, and that he’s bound to find another girl in the future. And Jaeyoung will also make a lot of compromise for Sangwoo. Don’t worry there is stilla lot of fluffy moments tho.
To read the novel go to ridibooks.com and search “시맨틱 에러” btw since this is rated 19, the website will ask for valid ID to confirm your age before you can read the novel.
Is it translated?
No, it’s in korean.
Yeah Sangwoo is so innocent , Jaeyoung is already given that he's playboy. Okay, hopefully this will be wholesome. I'm hooked up with the uke's nonchalant attitude . Thanks btw .
That last panel!!! I want to pee…
i want to what?!
I want to pee