Seren's Topics (58)

turning is probably my favorite webnovel ever to the point i'm leaving a mangago reply for the first time in my life... anyways https://novelingua.com/turning-chapter-067/ have fun reading!!

Thank u so much TT

i wish they uploaded bermuda as regularly as they do for turning

Yeah because some of us finally reread from the beginning! Mind you that when a new volume starts for stories, many will go back and reread the whole thing. Many of us did notice the weird stuff the first time around cause some of us might've been a bit younger and now we've grown enough to make critique.

Didn't *

Yeah, there are going to be things in fiction stories we dont like or feel that can be better, but we never know what goes on behind the scenes.

I understand why you and others would critique it, and that is your right to an opinion, however, I can understand why people are irritated with it cause this issue was brought up in the beginning. Maybe the author wrote the age gap to mirror couple they know, I do the same. We don't have to like certain parts but authors might have reasons why decide this way, I rather let them do it instead of stifling their creativity (me thinking as a writer). And it not like we can ask them since we're on an illegal site, and can't speak Japanese. I do know some mangaka do answer questions from international fans.

Honestly, their age gap is not that big, 17 to 21. I've seen the worst, especially when reading Chinese light novels. The age gap trope has always been popular. I mean look at Twilight, Inuyasha, and the like.

It's true that the "morality" of the story comes down to the author. I'm also a writer and I do agree with said points but the age gap isn't my only issue with the first volume and I mostly complain about it because, I have an ability to just as much as others have an ability to praise the work. I also have issues with how the second child is conceived, and have reasons behind why I have these complaints, whether or not they're fiction, I'm going to speak my mind.

I'm not comparing this to other works, I'm seeing it as it's own story and making critiques about it on it's own. And with those others examples in mind, I also have my own gripes about them but they're unrelated here. I'm not trying to stifle creativity, that's not what critique is about afterall. Critique is about talking about errors made and working around those errors to continue making something good. This story is far along and will not be changed to fit the reader's view of how the story should've started and that's perfectly fine, it doesn't have to. These critiques can simply be just that, a critique, which is evaluation of something from someone's perspective, and give a counter to the positive perspective of some readers. Not everyone has to enjoy something the same way and even then, not everyone has to just be silent when they love something but have complaints about small parts of it.

Agreed, you have the right to speak your mind and they also have the right to speak their mind. At the end of the day it is just our own opinion.

it's not about owning something by the uploaders. it's more like etiquette in uploading a translation

you try not to upload something being taken care of. you also try not to upload a chapter JUST after it got released let it marinate. mangakas need money as well that's why they said they'll do it at January

I do get the etiquette of not uploading after release so author can get money; but I feel like that wasn’t the focus of the drama (?) at all? It just felt like a public call out on upload which—no body needs. It’s an issue that could have been sorted in DMs and not drag everyone in this. The call out post also was worded felt very entitled imo and rude :/

Again; issue just don’t fight in uploads end of story.

I've already did mentioned the uploader who uploaded over me "IGNORING" my dm as well as my other teams dm too. It's already going to be a day now. Even the previous uploader AKUMAKIRA has already given me permission to upload even though they are soo busy to even read their DMs

Mate—one day is not a long time; 2) it’s holiday, 3) does not give u a right to upload a call out on blast and drag everyone in? What did you want out of this? A witch hunt?

I never drag everyone in.
Your point 2. Holiday, it's clearly holiday so everyone in free and are here to read.

I'm only standing up for my team because Ive never seen fan translation being uploaded when there's already official chapters uploaded.
See you have yet again misunderstood the reason of the Notice.
The previous uploader did not take permission from AKUMAKIRA the original uploader of OFFICIAL CHAPTERS.

When did I upload my notice? =Date 22 December already being 4days now. When was the officials upload date 24.
Can you see it now?
If bro wanted to upload the OFFICIALS why not contact me first and ask if they could. I would never say no to an OFFICIAL being uploaded. If he had told me advance or before hand, I would have stopped translation altogether and tell my team about a uploader who I'll upload OFFICIAL chapters.
This is the main reason why I put up a NOTICE.
No uploader would want to be uploaded over without prior Notice from the other uploader.
It's like n insult to their translation.

I’m not replying anymore after this lmao we clearly will just drag this on and I’m not here to fight with someone who cannot understand not everyone works on YOUR schedule.

Did he really cheat on his wife?

Please give us more spoilers ╥﹏╥

I’m going off novel spoilers cuz I can’t be bothered to MTL but ya he (the oldest brother) cheated on the white hair sister. He also tried justifying himself because it’s a “loveless marriage bla bla” he’s a complete pos

Sorry if any of these will be inaccurate in the future I’m going by novel spoilers I’ve read cuz I don’t MTL.

So I’ll just spoil some things I think people will wanna know

1) ML has not appear in the story yet but he will be another duke (not the blonde) and has black hair.
2) the reason for MC family divorce is because the father was unfaithful (oldest brother is actually from one of his fathers’ affair) along with the father being involved with some shady business (I think it was trafficking but I can be completely wrong on this I forgot sorry)
3) the next story arc after the white hair sister is Dennis drama with the crown prince and another reincarnator, it gets really weird and all I know is it ends with the girl getting a harem or whatever—

And ya that’s all I remember ╮(￣▽￣)╭

Hey thank you for sharing, and i don't know about others but i think that the FL needs a ML in this story cause she is doing great on her own, do you know if the white haired sister dies or is it the typical case of missdiagnosis, again thanks for sharing (≧∀≦)

I meant she doesen't need a ML

I think the sister is going to die she’s terminally ill so there’s no cure but maybe (hopefully) the manhwa will give her a better fate

Wild

is it really that unreasonable to be confused as to why or how she hasn't seen his various injuries

shes clearly putting him down by saying why woupd he be friends with someone as gloomy as him he comes home with injuries all the time theres no way he doesn't but the one time he actually has a friend she goes full on attack mode?

Ya cuz we literally see most of his injuries heal like manga logic fast? Why r we blaming a middle schooler if anyone should be responsible for not noticing his injured it’s the rest of the teacher / staff team at the school and parents. Also take this from someone with a similar age gap to m sis- we rarely see each other face much and we live in the same household. It’s honestly more possible then ya think

“Full on attack mode” did we not see her witness her brother friend being creepy as hell? She’s also clearly going through that “I’m not a kid no more” phase her calling her brother gloomy is like the most tame shit that has happen entire manga, it’s just little sib being little sibs.

its already been established that the bullies were untouchable and had stuff on all the faculty hes been getting bullied for a long time you cannot tell me she fr didn't notice especially when she knows about her brothers reputation at school for being unsociable . theres nothing wronge with being suspicious of new characters because clearly in this manga not everything is always as it seems if it shows she's actually a good sister ill def back her up but after the chapter when she was first introduced it stood out to me that the comments trusted her too much we gotta keep eachother grounded.

btw by attack mode i meant breaking into her brothers school you cannot tell me thats a full on stretch even taking the janitors uniform