MangaSanctuary want to read (All 1105)

MangaSanctuary is reading (All 832)

MangaSanctuary already read (All 408)

MangaSanctuary's Album ( All 16 )

MangaSanctuary's List ( All 13 )

Title Update Recommend
Beautiful Art(33) 2024-11-11 0
Cute * Lovely romance(43) 2022-11-27 0
Favorites(59) 2023-10-07 0
Love with Special Care(2) 2015-07-14 0

MangaSanctuary's topics ( All 574 )

MangaSanctuary October 15, 2024 7:59 am

Did you put yourself in mc's shoes? If you were him at the moment, what would you do? How would you behave...?
As a small pet bird, he got to play on ml's head (also other people's) ; got to make a nest with the Duke's hair, make all the mess he wants, get angry and yell at people all the way he wants, even poop on them... Act cheeky, fierce and silly... people allowed him to be because they know birds' body condition and know how spoiled can be a small pet.

Now imagine if suddenly you're not a small bird pet anymore, but got back to a human, grown form? Mc's actions and impacts won't be seen the same anymore, nor forgiven the same.
In one of the first chapters, the Duke thought to himself he's never allowed such behavior from anyone (as Peep), and the reason he's allowing is because Peep is a small beast.

This change of behavior was normal, considering his new body and situation. Everyone around him need to adapt to that change, included him and the Duke... We as readers need to also, if not we'll miss a crucial point and depreciate their new bond and this bl entirely.

I believe mc just get back to his true self, knowing his family background, so I think the only moment he allowed himself to be spoiled was when he's in the bird form.

MangaSanctuary November 29, 2023 12:27 pm

Shiki:
Back at you, my dude.
You also need a hobby if you find the time to write all this about me and I'mGayAndYouKnowIt. I told what I had to say and you're still here provoking me...?
Blocking people, then manage to call them out like you do is a bit coward and hypocrite of you. But anyways, have fun and think what you want if that can make you feel better ^_^
However please, for the Love of God, let people have different opinions than yours, that won't kill you and this will make this comment section a better place for everyone.

    I'mGayAndYouKnowIt November 29, 2023 3:50 pm

    I'd like to add that preaching about the popularity of the manhwa in an illegal platform is dumb

    Shiki, your support doesn't mean shit. The author would have been as offended by your support. I know. I have a history of reporting mangago to authors

    Unlike you, I read my favorite BL/yaoi legally. This one wasn't worth the money

    Sanctuary and I wouldn't have shoved our comments down your throats, if you and the authors didn't shove "straight" porn or your opinions down our throats

    "Closed-minded?" Don't be so open-minded that your brains fall out. It's too late, though. Your brains have fallen out already

    MangaSanctuary November 29, 2023 10:49 pm
    I'd like to add that preaching about the popularity of the manhwa in an illegal platform is dumbShiki, your support doesn't mean shit. The author would have been as offended by your support. I know. I have a hi... I'mGayAndYouKnowIt

    "I have a history of reporting mangago to authors"
    "Your brains have fallen out already"

    You still success to make me laugh despite the toxic atmosphere, thanks for that. I know I can count on you if one day my work get uploaded against my will on this site :p

    I only hope for this Shitki and their fellows to know that every complainant reader that they encourage heavily to drop CDA, means less money and less support for the author and artist they like so much.
    They should take exemple on JustCallMeApple, a person who is often in the comment section of Into the Rose Garden; she's so friendly, understanding and makes even a Yaoi like ITRG worth reading. I couldn't even stomach that manhwa due to all the r*pe and abuse, but after speaking with that avid reader, I came to question myself if I shouldn't give it another chance and finally that's what I'm gonna do (at least for the S2 and 3). If a comment section ever needs a "guardian", she's the kind of person that I'd like to find.

    I'mGayAndYouKnowIt November 29, 2023 11:24 pm
    "I have a history of reporting mangago to authors""Your brains have fallen out already"You still success to make me laugh despite the toxic atmosphere, thanks for that. I know I can count on you if one day my w... MangaSanctuary

    We need humor to cope with the toxicity. The rawness of our fear and sadness, and the aspect of social isolation, have created the perfect conditions for unprecedented humour. It's a "safety net" that cultivates resilience and courage

    I wanted to be the person that gives you the courage to continue

    It's my first time hearing about JustCallMeApple. I'd like to meet her. She sounds like a lovely person!

    MangaSanctuary November 30, 2023 12:32 am
    We need humor to cope with the toxicity. The rawness of our fear and sadness, and the aspect of social isolation, have created the perfect conditions for unprecedented humour. It's a "safety net" that cultivate... I'mGayAndYouKnowIt

    You're already are, my friend. Tbh that dictatorship and censorship comment section is so depressing and gloomy that if not for your dark humor I'd left that place already.
    Yes, humor is a salvation and alleviates a lot of tension, and you seem good at that.

    You can find JustCallMeApple in the comment section of Into the Rose Garden, she's always there giving spoilers and infos to people. Yeah, she's nice and passionate about that story; I spent more time reading her spoilers than reading the actual manhwa =D
    I think authors of ITRG should give some royalties to her because she has a formidable sense of persuasion to make people read that controversial Yaoi and not drop it. She's an excellent story teller/spoiler teller ^^

MangaSanctuary's questions ( All 62 )

MangaSanctuary January 10, 2024 1:17 pm

Is there a way to contact the Mangago staff

MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 12:53 pm

Can someone give me the link of toonk*r website since I can't connect to ne*toki anymore.
Also, if you've seen Risky Vice, the raws, were the dicks censored in the original panels?

    NellyBelly December 26, 2023 1:39 pm

    Check my page in my bio I have the website for took*r and ne*toki. I never read Risky Vice, but you can see for yourself on that site. I can't copy links because my phone's retarded and I broke my laptop.

    MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 1:47 pm
    Check my page in my bio I have the website for took*r and ne*toki. I never read Risky Vice, but you can see for yourself on that site. I can't copy links because my phone's retarded and I broke my laptop. NellyBelly

    Thank you so much. The Newtoki link doesn't work and infortunately it was the only not plagued with porn ads :/
    If ever you look at Risky Vice on this site, can you tell me? On Toonkor there's only one chapter so I can't check. The smuts start at chap2...

    meowette December 26, 2023 1:48 pm

    https://toonkor319.com/%EC%9B%B9%ED%88%B0
    i recommend you keep the tab for toonkor open cause they regularly change the link <33

    meowette December 26, 2023 1:49 pm
    https://toonkor319.com/%EC%9B%B9%ED%88%B0i recommend you keep the tab for toonkor open cause they regularly change the link <33 meowette

    was i supposed to censor the name? i forgot

    MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 1:50 pm
    https://newtoki319.com/https://toonkor319.com/%EC%9B%B9%ED%88%B0 yuko

    Infortunately it doesn't work anymore, none other links work

    MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 1:52 pm
    was i supposed to censor the name? i forgot meowette

    Thank you. I don't know either, but I don't think it's a problem if it's in the replies. As precaution I censor the question.

    NellyBelly December 26, 2023 2:11 pm
    Thank you so much. The Newtoki link doesn't work and infortunately it was the only not plagued with porn ads :/If ever you look at Risky Vice on this site, can you tell me? On Toonkor there's only one chapter s... MangaSanctuary

    I checked on here and it only has 3 chapters, Idk if that's what you were asking for. If you're trying to find more chapters I don't think it's on any free site and you'll have to buy on the official site for more chapters

    MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 2:14 pm
    I checked on here and it only has 3 chapters, Idk if that's what you were asking for. If you're trying to find more chapters I don't think it's on any free site and you'll have to buy on the official site for m... NellyBelly

    No, that's not it.
    Since I can't access to Newtoki site anymore, I asked you for helping me to check THE RAWS, if they were censored or decensored

    MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 2:14 pm
    I checked on here and it only has 3 chapters, Idk if that's what you were asking for. If you're trying to find more chapters I don't think it's on any free site and you'll have to buy on the official site for m... NellyBelly

    Merci pour ton aide !

    NellyBelly December 26, 2023 2:19 pm
    No, that's not it.Since I can't access to Newtoki site anymore, I asked you for helping me to check THE RAWS, if they were censored or decensored MangaSanctuary

    I checked newtoki and it was censored

    MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 2:25 pm
    I checked newtoki and it was censored NellyBelly

    HOOOO...!!
    Then, did you see the uncensored ones here on Mangago?
    That means the decensored were done wy someone of the scan team :)

    MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 2:25 pm
    I checked newtoki and it was censored NellyBelly

    Arigato domo again

    NellyBelly December 26, 2023 2:39 pm
    HOOOO...!!Then, did you see the uncensored ones here on Mangago?That means the decensored were done wy someone of the scan team :) MangaSanctuary

    Ohh, I just checked. Yeah, usually some scan teams uncensored it. Also, no problem

    MangaSanctuary December 26, 2023 2:49 pm
    Ohh, I just checked. Yeah, usually some scan teams uncensored it. Also, no problem NellyBelly

    (๑•ㅂ•)و✧ (●'◡'●)ノ

MangaSanctuary's message board ( All 3 )

sogoo February 28, 2020 2:56 pm

Hiii r u still translating sakurada senpai?

MangaSanctuary February 28, 2020 3:13 pm

Hi,
No, since we couldn't find a translator. I proposed myself to redraw the dicks at that time, and I dropped because no one would give me a reply. But the last translated chapters are out, did you see them? It shows the dick were redrawn nicely, so I think there are already people who actually translate Sakuraga Senpai.
Why do you want to help?

sogoo February 29, 2020 3:51 am
Hi,No, since we couldn't find a translator. I proposed myself to redraw the dicks at that time, and I dropped because no one would give me a reply. But the last translated chapters are out, did you see them? It... MangaSanctuary

Where are they out on, I don't see them on mangago?

MangaSanctuary February 29, 2020 11:10 am
Where are they out on, I don't see them on mangago? sogoo

As I went yesterday to read the comments, it looks like the latest updates (2-3) were taken down from Mangago since these were not supposed to be shared with the public.
So, again we're only left with the first chapter :/
I'm willing to help if you can do the translation or find someone to help translate.

sogoo March 2, 2020 11:30 am
As I went yesterday to read the comments, it looks like the latest updates (2-3) were taken down from Mangago since these were not supposed to be shared with the public.So, again we're only left with the first ... MangaSanctuary

I can translate but may not be that accurate. Any other platform where i can contact u? (discord or sth)

MangaSanctuary March 3, 2020 10:46 pm
I can translate but may not be that accurate. Any other platform where i can contact u? (discord or sth) sogoo

I don't have a discord and avoid sites like FB.
Can we communicate here?

It it's not that accurate, then maybe wait to find another person, a translator, to help?
I can only do the uncensore thing.

Tmsmyaoi January 29, 2020 10:43 pm

I tried to email you but I could not. I had read your comments with another reader. I hope you will understand what I am talking about..... I wished I said something earlier. There were assumptions (not from you) but I think you two were on different planes of thinking.. I don’t find you a toxic person and that conversation should had happened differently. Even on the same topic, it seemed to be two different conversations. I wanted you know to know I did understand you and do not think you are toxic.

MangaSanctuary January 29, 2020 10:51 pm

Hi,
on which topic did you read it, and which manhwa? Dispar, POTN...?

Tmsmyaoi January 29, 2020 10:55 pm
Hi,on which topic did you read it, and which manhwa? Dispar, POTN...? MangaSanctuary

I wished I could email you.. It is because a new account? What is POTN? The first one you mention to which you are blocked now by them..... -.-;
I read that a few times and I don’t think you were attacking them at anytime. I can understand if they felt that way. But I did not feel you were attacking them.

MangaSanctuary January 29, 2020 11:24 pm
I wished I could email you.. It is because a new account? What is POTN? The first one you mention to which you are blocked now by them..... -.-; I read that a few times and I don’t think you were atta... Tmsmyaoi

You see well, thank you for your concern and your kindness.

I really did not attacking them, but I think Azalago would feel attacked anyway if ever someone disagreed with her on her thread. She must feel disguted about what happened to the first uploader (the bullying etc) and think that whoever post bad comment will also do harm to/bully the uploader/translator.

Infortunately there's no way to make them understand that they can't forbid people to share bad opinions/reviews, and in the end I was tired and didn't even care anymore. They must've felt bothered that I called them paranoid, lol.
If more chapters are being uploaded, there will be necessarily negative comments, and she can't always forbid these or shut readers from expressing their honest opinions.

POTN is for Painter of the Night. It's an intriguing story, I recommand it if you didn't read it yet :)

FanFanTulipe September 12, 2019 6:45 pm

Salut! Comment vas-tu ? J’ei était un peu occupé- la vie en général- et je ne savais pas comment répondre à ton e-mail, il y avait 2 options - delete or spam

MangaSanctuary September 14, 2019 12:27 am

Bonsoir, eh bien on fait aller :) J'espère que tu vas bien aussi.
Ne t'inquiète pas, on a aussi nos occupations à côté.
J'avoue que pour le mail, je n'ai jamais encore eu à faire à ce genre de souci :sur, et j'ai déjà correspondu avec des personnes ici. J'espère que ça pourra se résoudre. En attendant on peu bien discuter ici si tu veux :)

FanFanTulipe September 14, 2019 8:33 pm
Bonsoir, eh bien on fait aller :) J'espère que tu vas bien aussi.Ne t'inquiète pas, on a aussi nos occupations à côté.J'avoue que pour le mail, je n'ai jamais encore eu à faire à ce genre de souci :sur, ... MangaSanctuary

Salut, ça va? Enfin samedi soir Je suis un peu déçu pas les updates

FanFanTulipe September 15, 2019 6:56 am

Salut! Mon message a dû être coupé parce que j’ai écrit un peu plus que une phrase, bizarre. Dimanche matin, petit déjeuner au lit , la vie est belle. As tu déjà lu « At the end of the route »? Belle histoire, shounen, dommage

MangaSanctuary September 16, 2019 10:26 am
Salut! Mon message a dû être coupé parce que j’ai écrit un peu plus que une phrase, bizarre. Dimanche matin, petit déjeuner au lit , la vie est belle. As tu déjà lu « At the end of the route »? Bel... FanFanTulipe

Salut ! Ha oui, dimanche est une journée sacrée au lit, avec boisson et gâteaux et mangas, yaoi ! ^^ Je suis comme ça aussi. ça devient vraiment une drogue, ce truc haha.
Oui, je l'ai lu, j'ai bien aimé. Mais dommage, c'est un peu trop gentillet au niveau c*l, vu que c'est Shonen-Ai :/
Oui, hélas, ça ne va pas assez vite comme on le veut, pour les updates. Mais nos artistes et scan groupes font comme ils le peuvent aussi, je pense ^^'
C'est quoi ton Yaoi/manga préféré du moment ?

Moi, c'est Painter of the Night

MangaSanctuary September 17, 2019 12:13 pm

On cherche quelqu'un pour traduire le reste des chapitres de Sakurada Senpaï (Yaoi), car on n'a personne pour le moment. Donc si tu connais quelqu'un... ^^

FanFanTulipe September 17, 2019 4:48 pm
Salut ! Ha oui, dimanche est une journée sacrée au lit, avec boisson et gâteaux et mangas, yaoi ! ^^ Je suis comme ça aussi. ça devient vraiment une drogue, ce truc haha.Oui, je l'ai lu, j'ai bien aimé. M... MangaSanctuary

Salut! Pour le moment c’est Here u r parce que j’adore le personnage d’Uncle Pan et j’aimerais bien qu’il devient un couple avec le redhead sinon Dear Door.

FanFanTulipe September 17, 2019 4:58 pm
Salut! Pour le moment c’est Here u r parce que j’adore le personnage d’Uncle Pan et j’aimerais bien qu’il devient un couple avec le redhead sinon Dear Door. FanFanTulipe

Qu’il soit en couple...oups

MangaSanctuary September 24, 2019 10:04 pm
Salut! Pour le moment c’est Here u r parce que j’adore le personnage d’Uncle Pan et j’aimerais bien qu’il devient un couple avec le redhead sinon Dear Door. FanFanTulipe

Ça fait un petit moment que je n'ai pas lu Here you are, comment ça progresse?

MangaSanctuary September 24, 2019 10:05 pm
Qu’il soit en couple...oups FanFanTulipe

Et je ne vois plus dans POTN

Hello and welcome,

I read eveything, mostly Seinen, Shonen and BL, Yaoi.
I prefer to buy physical books, so sadly there won't be many of the stories I like here that I can buy, but I'm grateful I can read freely on this site. Thanks to all the people who can make this happen.

*****

BL AND YAOI, ANALYSIS AND HISTORY:
A fuck up genre where SA and rape are parts of the process of building a romantic relationship.

In regards of this, people who are fighting over rape in these fictions are both right and wrong, because there is romance, then rape/SA involved and entangled all together.

Reminding: BL was created by the Japanese people, who have a fucked up imaginary and phantasms of hetero relationship and sex (a patriarcal society), where rape and SA are romanticized in these interactions; this is shown through their culture, anime... and this aspect is particularly prevalent in medias like MANGA (specially Hentai, Yaoi, Josei.... porn frange of anime) where when the ML SA/forces the Uke, MC, FL into intercourse, this is seen as parts of the relationship's process/build up. "I like you so much that I can't help myself...", "I secretly desire you but since I don't know what to do about it...", "You're so precious, so innocent that I can't help but force you and ruin that innocence..." blabla and other bullshits... To sum, we can see the fucked up reasoning and kinda pedo and disturbing mindset behind this. While this was greatly prevalent in Hentai and seen as a natural element to that category, it takes also places in Yaoi (the more NSFW version of BL) despite the authors and creators of such works being females for the most.

In the end, there is romance, and also SA, rape in these stories that are clearly romanticized in the Japanese BL/Yaoi. One of the first BLs that got very popular contains a lot of rape despite its cute and shojo art.
The popularity of this specific story launched the BL genre and contributes for its growth to the lectures we know today.
Korean authors who produce today Yaoi grew up reading Japanese Yaoi, that's why their stories are similar to the Japanese's.

This is not to say that rape in these fictions is excusable, but to remind that in these stories, rape and SA are yes, romanticized and parts of the roots core of BL. You can see this as the evil root of the BL tree.
Since Asian Eastern (Japan)'s view on rape, SA... differs from the West's (at least in their fantasy), this results in these endless fights between readers, contributing into making this kind of stories even more popular.

Since romance and rape are so entangled together in BL and the gravity of such mixture mostly brushed off, if we want to make these stories less rapey, we may as well anihilate the whole BL. We can try, but it'll be difficult...


*****
> 76 people followed MangaSanctuary