I feel so damn pissed rn from reading all these comments blaming Jeanette like what's wrong with you all don't you think your being a bit harsh when this girl has been told that Claude is her father she can't help it not like she can do a DNA test lmao and she's been trying to get close to both of them but Claude is only using her for pain relief and athy is just nah and she's being used by the Duke and her real ass father and you saw how she's not gonna have a happy ending because athy is the Mc ofc she will so I'm not that worried about her I just hope she won't turn evil this girl has literally no one
Naivety is only sweet and understandable as long as it does not hurt others. Even if she was purely made of sugar and nice things, the fact is that her lack of self-awareness got Athy and Claude killed. And she is going the same path again. It's not even a "taking responsability" problem. Her naivity clearly make her insensible to others suffering and selfish both. She could have plaided for Anathasia's case. She could have felt at least a little bad for being the only one to talk with Claude for a while. But she did not. On the contrary, when Athy came back she felt insecure and jealous... I can't help but see her as Ibelin in Miss not so side-kick. She is only this way because she was sheltered and thus lacked growth. She is basically a time bomb ready to explose at a moment notice.
well you're questioning other people's judgments with an attempt to sway people into justifying her or something. that's all. in other cases she has a different personality in the novel. and the fact that her character's generally built to be an antagonist just means it's logical to hate her ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭
She is indeed naive and does trust others easily and yes that's because she's been sheltered all her life and she's the typical Mc naive and sweet I want her to grow and just want her to have a happy ending I want her character to grow but It's all up to the author you feel me ik she's not that innocent but I still can't help but feel bad for her it's just a feeling..
When I talked about the "same path" I was talking about their first timeline, not the novel (it has already been revealed in the manhwa so no spoilers here). You can be mad all that you want that her ending won't be that happy (even if franckly it will most likely not even be a "bad end") but readers have a lot of reasons to not like her/ not root for her. You can either ignore the comments or try to debunk them. For putting the blame on her, she is definitly guilty for what she did in the first timeline. Currently, in the new timeline, we will have to wait to see what she is going to do. But she is already showing signs that she will turn antagonistic soon so...
i agree lmao. think people are too harsh on jeanette... i dont know why people are bringing her personality in the novel in this thread to justify their dislike when its clear that this webtoon diverges from the novel a bit? plus if im not wrong, [SPOILER MAYBE]........................novel readers have said that the reason why athanasia got her chance again was bc jeanette wished for it or sth along those lines [END OF SPOILER]....... either ways even if its not true, shes a young girl who was told lies since she was young from adults so its inevitable that she thinks the way she does... how is she supposed to know the “truth” like us readers who can see the whole story man...and its not as if shes malicious she just wants to be together with them????? bc she thinks that they are part of the same family???? its not like she brought the curse to them on purpose☠ stop it yall haters u guys sound very unsympathetic
It's not the case in the manhwa for the second chance. It was already revealed that Athy's magic was time magic, she brought herself back in the past apparently. For the novel part, she is showing signs of turning antagonistic and we are supposed to be biased because of what she did in the first timeline so...
I too don't understand the hate on Jeanette. It's like people are hating her just so that they can have a character to hate. Like the girl is literally being used, is alone and lonely, and people think she's naive and stupid. She's a child for god's sake and I admire her for being able to live through her loneliness and be optimistic. I truly wish that both Jeanette and Athanasia will get happy endings, and not Athanasia alone
That's what I hated about the novel. The same cliche plot that if one girl is the lead, then the second lead must be a bitch. There's enough girl on girl hate in too many stories, and I was truly disappointed when I read how Jeanette was portrayed. Here's hoping that the author will change the storyline so that Jeanette can be happy too (๑•ㅂ•)و✧
ikr people don't get it. shes meant to be hated because shes an antagonist. the fact that readers actually hate her is a compliment to the story. it just means the author was able to effectively create a character who coerces the exact reactions she/he wanted from the readers. if yall so hung up on jeanette being hated then what about claude? he has more if not all reasons to be hated but why isn't he? because the story's flow diverted us from that. same thing applies to jeanette. get the jizz people
The fuck i just skipped alot of chapters the mc is with her sister's boyfriend having sex WASN'T HE HER SISTER'S BOYFRIEND WHAT SHE DOING (⊙…⊙ )