pluckaduck's Topics (209)

It’s not being naive. If the author doesn’t like it they’ll speak up about it. I’m not trying to be rude but there’s no need to play savior. If the author doesn’t want the readers to assume they’re a man, they wouldn’t draw themself as one, that would be stupid, especially since a lot of authors out there draw themselves as potatoes or blobs when they don’t want to “expose their identity” or something like that ifykwim

^^

yup, that is true
It is no way for someone who does not want to be mistaken for either gender to describe themselves as one of them.
If author doesn't want to highlight their gender, they can just make the avatar look like a cute plusie or cute animal like other authors do.

im not playing savior. i just think it's strange to assume the author is a man just based on avatar when it could be an OC or smth and it's more likely the case that the author is a women. i added the last part in case the author did confirm their gender and is indeed a man

I think more than people assuming the author is a man (because they presented themselves with a masculine avatar) it's weird of you to assume they're probably a woman because of your own preconceived notions

Why do u think the author is a woman? Because HE draws comics about a dad and his son. Or because he draws bls? Because that's sexist.


He* because unless the author comes out and says he is not a man, that's what I'm calling him.

Why do u think the author is a woman? Because HE draws comics about a dad and his son. Or because he draws bls? Because that's sexist.


He* because unless the author comes out and says he is not a man, that's what I'm calling him.

if it werent for the avatar if u had to take a guess u wouldve assumed they were a woman too. cant help it if my perconcieved notions are based on facts since it's true at least 80-90% of authors of these type of stories with homoerotic tones are women

well i didnt know they drew bls. i think they're a woman cuz of artstyle. male authors when they draw men, it's different from the typical yaoi artstyle from female authors, and this story fits the latter. and regarding the content of the story, if they were a male, i simply do not think they would write a originally wholesome story with weird homoerotic tones with the son and father that's obviously pandering to a certain degenerate demographic. i have read queer books by male authors and a gay commenter mention to me how much pedophilia have hurt him, so unless the author is tone deaf to the struggles of their own gender, they wouldnt have added that weirdness. for example, think of the differences of the BL and GL story written by the author of sadisitic beauty, who is a woman. oh, and i really dont care what u call the author by. i just think it's naive, like if u assume a player is female just bc they have a female avatar in a video game

I get your point, but there’s actually a big difference between an OC and a persona! An OC would be papa wolf or the underlings. A persona is what the author uses to portray themselves like they often do in author’s notes. A person is used to give the readers an idea of who the author is, and choosing a gender rather than an object or animal is a way for them to allow their readers to make assumptions. Even if the author isn’t a man, them choosing their persona and making it a man allows the readers to make that assumptions as it quite literally is the logical thing to do. Other authors (like DJun, uses a cute character as persona without it being human. We know the author is a woman because of their Weibo (if i remember correctly) but to avoid making any assumption on their physic or gender, they chose, like many other manhua artists to use a non-human character as their persona. Idk if i explained that correctly but hope it makes sense

The reason why people are calling you out a out it is because there IS an avatar. I understand why you would assume it was a woman at first, I did too, since it’s true that most bl manhua artists are women (even this one isn’t bl, the author does post bl on their weibo i think) but the author showing their persona as a man and still assuming they’re a woman is why people don’t agree with you. I mean yea, they could be a woman and just likes using a man persona, but it wouldn’t make sense to be bothered if they’re assumed to be a man because of it, and it wouldn’t make sm sense to assume they’re a woman despite the persona, ykwim?

Also quick addition, but the homoerotic tones in some chapters aren’t related to the main story line. The author received a lot of criticism and the likes on their socials bc the story isn’t bl, so the few chapters with the bl vibes are to cater to one portion of their fans who seem angry that the story is only a cute father-son slice of life. Basically, it’s like a completely different story (except the characters looks the same which is also why i dislike it). I’ve also read a few bls novels/manhua with male authors but the difference didn’t really have anything to do with the art or the wholesomeness of the story.

exactly what I was thinking

That’s why I look forward to each and every update

They’re from attack on titan historia/christa(blonde) and yamir(freckles)

ohh. darn. i heard they were the "doomed Yuri" couple. too bad. thanks tho

The hell? How do you act like your 26? Do you mean, because she‘s 26 she has to act mature? Dude, not everyone in their 20s is mature in this world.

first of all, she doesnt believe she's the heroine, therefore she has no reason to believe they will target her. therefore she has no reason to be that anxious and easily swept away by the mls. second, the author intentionally added in the story that she's 26 yo, so that should at least have some relevance to her worldview and how she acts around the mls and in the hs setting. she doesnt need to be "mature" but there should at least be a noticeable difference in her behavior compared to the students, but there is none. for example, in her second chance at life, she wants to be academically studious, yet this doesn't have an impact on the story.

She doesnt believe she is the heroine because in the story that she wrote the heroine comes later in the story, and just because she wants to be academically studious doesnt mean she has to act her age because she can still be academically studious even if she acts like that. Everyone has their own personalities. Why does there have to be a “noticeable difference in her bahaviour” than the students? She still has the right to act how she wants and i know you didnt say she doesnt have the right but still. I hope you dont think of it as starting a fight because i really am not. If this doesnt make sense im very sorry as English isnt my first language.

to clarify, since she doesnt believe she is the heroine, she has no reason to be worried the mls will obsess over her, therefore she should be able to reject the mls firmly instead of just going along with their whims. since she wants to redo her education, it should show up in the story going forward (ie. show her actively studying or making plans about it. in fact the story could've shown her trying to study but getting interrupted by the mls. it would've still gotten the point across that the mls are unpredictable yet shows the relevance of her age and real-life circumstances). but so far, it had been meandering slice-of-life interactions with the mls. i dont think she necessarily need to act like a 26 yo, and she can have whatever personality she likes, but if it is going to be mentioned, i expect it to have some relevance to how she acts compared to the hs students around her. yet it doesnt; she acts like the typical bland self-insert and i find no difference to how a college student would act in her place. and tbh arguing over her behavior is pointless, bc it's clear the story's writing is just bad.

It’s not just you, bestie. The frustration and embarrassment are strong with these two.

ikr the second hand embarrassment and cringe are hard bear but I think I'll stick to it because the spoilers said the ml regrets a big time (idk what he regrets about tho)