clouds's Topics (48)

And did u see how he hit that girl, I was so shocked how could him, he did'nt even hesitate, I don't really care about that girl maybe she is bad, but I can imagine him hitting the FL, uhh my heart

Was it mention it was islaM? What chapter? It’s mAke believe you know.. and as a good muslim should you be on a site like mangago? Just curious.. with all the smut, yaoi, and weird sexual thingsr is that ok in islam?

so the author isn't respecting the cultures enough to write about it, is that what you are worried about? I don't really understand a lot because, I myself don't really know much about Islam culture
(￣∇￣")

Right, louder sis

It was abviose it was Islam from the previous chapter, and I'm also curious should a good christian (or whatever ur religion) be on mangago? See ur talking abt something unrelated, she didn't respect us and that made me annoyed, I don't know if doesn't matter to u if an author didn't respect something dear to u, but I do care.

Im agnostic so yes i can be on mangago... unlike a A pretend religious person say you a “muslim” when there are worst mangas/ comics here than can offend “religious” or even non-religious persons like same sex rApe, Rape, incest, molestation etc... i mean if you are offended by something NOT Even mentioned Specifically as islam Or (any religion) in a make believe world where magical abilities appear in a dream.. you shouldn’t be reading mangas dude. Or get that stick off your ass... why so serious?

i don’t think the author was using the religion and just took inspiration from the culture in the middle east and boiled it down.

And you didn’t answer my question. Why is a good muslim here? Does rape, yaoi, yuri, molestation, incest, bestiality NOT offend you as a muslim person? It’s literally on the cover page of this site,,, but 1 chapter in This particular manga offended you... don’t deflect the question. Clearly,you are not a good muslim. I mean..you are on mangago. Heheheeh. I have no religion.. so everything is fair go for me.

First of all, like the people before said, they didn't COMFIRM it was Muslim. And second of all, you can't just assume their religion saying they're necessarily Christian. They could also be atheist. Thirds of all, IF the people were Muslim like you said, the author could have simply not done enough research which does not mean she was necessarily disrespecting your religion. The author is trying to provide us with a fun manhwa, which you should be more grateful for instead of complaining about the author's works. And the author simply not including enough details is no reason to drop her other works too (but it doesn't really concern me)

Do you expect all people who says that they're devoted to their religion are really good people? It's simply that he isn't a good person then.. It's not like all muslim ppl (or others) are good..

But if u don't know much then u won't write about it right? But she did , and she has a lot of ppl reading her manhwas, she should have been careful, any wrong ideas she gives to her readers not all of them will know that it's wrong. I really don't hate if an author talked abt Islam but he should write right things about that religion, u know not lots of authors talk abt it so that exactly why they should be careful when they write abt it cuz ppl won't find lots of manhwas which gonna change the wrong ideas they have, and more than that when she made a Muslim character she made him looks like a bad guy? Why that, most of Muslims are really good and very kind and if u talk with them u will see that and like them, she could not make him a good character? I don't know if u understand what I'm trying to say but wish u do.

BRUH. NOBODY SAID ISLAM EVER IN THIS MANHWA. why are you being so offended of something that doesn't exist in this story in the first place? she could've just taken an inspiration from the culture for the manhwa.

Ok..so em a muslim too but what is wrong with the manhwa? I just couldn’t find any apparent fault.

And mangago maybe famous for its yaoi and smut etc but it has other content too. And this person is watching something straight with zero smut so u cant really call out to em. Plus we all do things that arent allowed in our religion , that’s between the person and his god. Stop judging others. We are humans and can get tempted too.

And so...i don't understand all this but isn't it hindu?...just saying bcs their rules is similar to hindu...also..did you confused it's muslim bcs they use sultan?..okay..i understand..but i think..the translation should be raja..we all know..sultan means king..same goes to raja..so i think the translation is wrong...
(This is what i thought..and yes..i am a sinful muslim..at least..i have knowledge)

first of all who are you to judge a muslim and what a person does , thats between them and god let them read whatever they want and let them be on the website it’s not your place to call them out on that plus the manhwa insinuated that he was muslim cause his religion included aspects of islaam like eating halal food and fasting everyone is literally gonna assume it’s islaam cause islaam is known for those things and by the author villainising him by making him seem ignorant and selfish and demanding it’s brings a bad image upon the religion, i don’t know if you know how much muslims are dying daily cause of islamaphobia cause the media literally tells us the opposite by calling us terrorists but don’t judge people where it’s not your place to and don’t be so insensitive

I don't see anything that spells out muslim. If anything they seem hindu/ India, because they have strict religious beliefs which include not eating certain types of animals. But it is obviously inspired for this fantasy world and not taken exactly.

It would also be incorrectly translated

Just one more observation from the comic, they are using elephants to get around in which is very clique India.

Finally someone said it..like it's obviously hindu..and that sultan must be mistranslation..in the history..indian use maharaja or raja..depend on the era ..(correct me if i am mistaken)

I think people are assuming it's islam bc they stated that the food must be "halal" which is the Islamic word for lawful and is often used in regard to food hence the link. Personally I think the author used a combination of Hinduism + Islam and middle Eastern + pakistani/Indian culture to create this new empire

Guys what about the dabbihah is it hindu too? Like I was shocked reading the comments, yeah he looks Indian but the dabbihah, halal, haram, all of it is from Islam, ppl said he didn't eat meat so he don't eat meat so he isn't Muslim then dabbihah was for what, fish?! She draw that the dabbihah was for animals, did u forget? Correct me if I'm wrong but she's obviously meant to write abt Islam.

Thank u very much

Thank you very much

Thank you very much

please don't get so protective over a conjecture you made with barely any info

The author most likely took inspiration from many religions and cultures. Most authors do that. I don't personally find anything offensive to any culture in this. Also I don't know if those words are in the original text or if they were the closet thing the translator could use. Idk. Even the whole "European" concept is not totally accurate. But like you said if you find it offensive don't read it.Do what you feel is best for you mate.

I know what you mean like it’s fantasy of course people should not think this is real or 1% real and if they have any inkling about thinking oh could that possibly be true to look at it by themselves

Exactly

I don't dislike her, but I don't particularly like her either. I feel like she has a lot of....growing up to do?...before she becomes a character worth liking. Like, the character development up until the most recent chapter 22 was non-existent (for good reasons), but I believe c.22 was a good step in her development.
I think I'll like her more as the story progresses~

Yeah, I don't got a problem with her. I feel like she was acting all fussy because she didn't get her freedom. I think once everything is cleared over and she gets closer to the mc I think she'll be just fine. Her character design is pretty nice though.

Ooh yeah u r right,but I think the author showed us that she is really a spoiled girl, her father really likes her so of course she wouldn't be an awesome character from the begeing.

Yep!!

I don't thin my issue with her was that she was spoiled. I've read other works where the FL was a spoiled princess, some with good personalities, some bad; I think the issue was that up until recent chapters she hadn't seemed to be all that intelligent. We saw that she could be kind and caring, with the cat in the earliest introduction chapters, but other than that it just seemed that she didn't care about the importance of her situation at all.
We didn't get much from her perspective. Only that she knew she had a lot of bodyguards, knew that her dad was incredibly protective of her, and that she knew she was supposedly in danger. But then she completely disregarded these things, and that it was obviously in place for a reason, time and again. She lied and tricked and manipulated all the people trying desperately to protect her, just so she could have an hour to go to a park or restaurant or get ice cream. It seemed stupid and selfish. Like she didn't care one bit about the people who were hired to protect, or truly did care for her and wanted to protect her even if it wasn't their job.
We, the readers, knew that she had been kidnapped and hurt before but it wasn't mentioned until recently that she didn't remember the incident...Now that we had a small explanation chapter from her perspective, where she seriously didn't think she was in any danger because, for her, it's never happened before...It makes sense why she acted the way she did.
I think I can like her more now, because she's not a selfish idiot. Just misinformed about her own situation.

I'm also hoping she's not a super tsundere type though. I'm not a fan of tsunderes all that much~ Though I can tolerate it if the story is good.

Lol ur just like me,yep I feel her personality would be very good without much tsundere, I felt that she is strong woman sometimes and I liked that,it suits her appearance, anyway how old is she ? Did the author mentioned it or no ....? Maybe I didn't notice..

I think she's maybe 15 or 16? I feel like she's either the same age as our MC or a year younger, but I could have just made that up in my head, lol (￣∇￣")
I really think she's 15 tho.

Yeah same here

Why are you laughing?

I think the face is happy not laughing? :

Ohh sorry then what is there to be happy.....

I felt happy because people know that we cherish our religion :)

That part made dislike the crown prince and his attendant more. They're just brushing it off like it wasn't a big deal.

Oh my!! Same here..... I love how they mention that no matter what the situation they will always do thing which according to the teaching of Islam..... They would rather fast then to eat haram thing.... I love how they told the way Muslims slaughter Hilal animals in order to eat

Yep!

Mmm,I think what the crown prince thought is what an unmuslim person would think, of course I didn't like it but it was relastic, and what his attendant said after that, for me he just was telling the crown prince why the Muslim guy got mad, I felt he showed that we really care about our religion, so maybe the author wanted to show that by that sentence :) cuz if u read the sentence alone It's a beautiful sentence, so the prince wondered about what the Muslim guy did, and the attendant said what he felt from that incident, this my POV I explained it to u so maybe u can see it the way I see it, and read the comment under yours maybe u will feel what we felt more :) and in the end Only Allah knows everything the author thinks

And I think any clever author won't write something would make her Muslim readers angry, she even searched well about the dabbihah, so I think, not because there is people who are saying bad things about Islam and Muslims that we think everybody are like them, I know unmuslim who are different from those, soo I don't know what the author really think abt Islam so I'm not sure if she is a good person or not , but I won't judge her until I know her well :)

OK I'm here to say something, the author should have wrote the importance of the dabbihah cuz ppl (maybe)will just be like he made a fuss cuz he's blinded by his religion, cuz they are not like us know the good thing about it so they will think islam is strict or st like that, she as an author should be careful cuz a lot of ppl will read this and she shouldn't write something slightly,she described the dabbihah but didn't mention why the Muslim guy cared about it a lot and that because its actually very important, so I understand now Y u thought like that, she is talking about a religion and any ideas may stick in the readers mind whether it's good or not.she didn't show the beautiful about Islam and his teaching and I don't think she even knows that.

But maybe she wrote about the idea without a proper think so it's a mistake and someone should tell her to be careful and not to do that next time if she wrote about a religion.

I guess, at a stretch anyway, you could say that because he was representing his country and they theirs that not ‘acknowledging’ his religion in this way was like insulting a whole country. That it couldn’t just be taken as a lack of knowledge, and if he was to say it’s fine it’s be like he was saying that could disregard his faith.
At a stretch anyway.

The author probably could have made him seem more angry calm than excitable calm though, that would have made him seem more reasonable

Yeah, i think u r right

Yeah us muslims will just not eat the food and keep quiet

We shall not eat but at at least tell them bring the meat slaughtered according to our Islamic ways and in this way no one would be insulted

lmao i’m thinking the same thing

Good thing u noticed that like me