beta
(this is gonna be a bit of a long hot take so be warned)
let's get this straight, I totally get the comments feeling repulsed by the dubious consent/rape here, but most of those comments are completely missing the point. Jaxx is writing this scene with the literal intent to underline the tragic climax of them finally confronting a major plot point. Let's also not forget that Under the Greenlight isn't a fluffy BL by all means, so there's going to be heavy elements like murder, gang-fighting, manipulation, and in this case, dubious consent. Nevertheless, we're also forgetting that Matthew is literally not in his right mind to even make decisions, let alone even realize the ramifications of what he's even doing. Jin even gave consent to Matthew so he could help alleviate the drug in Matthew's system. That doesn't excuse Matthew's actions however, just helps explain them. That being said, I totally understand if dubious consent/rape isn't up someone's alley and I wont shame those who feel completely uncomfortable seeing those topics. However, comparing this scene to the likes of other BL which actually DO have rape for no plot reason/writing purpose (looking at you Champagne and Roses) or getting angry at the presentation is missing the point. Matthew is literally intoxicated out of his mind and cannot fathom what he's doing, Jin gave consent (though Matthew isn't being very caring and gentle with it), and Jaxx wanted to write this scene as a tragic sort of climax (very much in bounds with the macabre setting and mood of Under the Greenlight).