mimichi want to read (All 90)
beta
So i actually read the all abt lust and bad dog comic to see where the plagiarism allegation comes from since some ppl said the copying goes beyond art style but also emcompass plot and characters.
However, ive only read about 10 ch each (of tirano's works), so i could be wrong
Plot : no similarity whatsoever so far
Characters & dynamic :
Cfc : childhood friends, and really close
Aal : sunbae hoobae
Bad dog: roommate's bro whom the ml see for the first time
Only similarity is they are all college students
All their personalities are different too
Their first intimate scene started diffrently too
In bad dog : they kinda went 'wanna hook up?' 'Yeah, cool'
In all abt lust : cant remember, nothing strikes as being copied into cfc. Im sure they didnt start with one party being curious abt sexual relationship like in cfc. Again, correct me if im wrong
Cover art:
Retro/pop-ish art style. Nothing new, nothing unique. Been used in any other manga/manhwa, even western comics and other art medium as well
All cover art compositions are obviously different despite side by side comparison
Smut scene sequences/build up:
The infamous side by side comparison going around on twitter
Touching body : ....seriously?
Kissing intensify : generic smut scene
Sequences : a lot of panels in between were cut off on cfc's side, making the sequence looks similar to aal. each panels does not look identical either
People who were quick on the hating/blaming train, do you even try to look into the issue or simply believing on the next blown up tweet? If i were eunhi, i would sue too when your claims come with a horde of defensive and offensive bl lovers and slander my work with no solid evidence.
Exactlyyyy. Itâs one thing if it was copying word for word and tracing, but several of these âplagiarizedâ things have existed long before either of them made their works. Hooking up with a friend is a trope that has been used for a long time. I saw the art covers/single piece works, side by side comparison and it is similar but never exact. I would say this author definitely took inspiration, and they should just say they were inspired. But the BL authors cover art/single piece art was definitely not the first to come up with those retro ideas (many artists use that style before them too).
Also idk if people realize it but Iâm 99% sure every manhwa on earth is inspired by manga. Since it seems like mangas were the first to come out and manhwas are more of a newer creation, only posted digitally. Any trope in manhwa you can find, was likely inspired by a manga before it. (Like transmigration historical hetero romance was huge in manhwa, the very first time I saw such a genre was a manga and it wasnât a popular trope back then). I do believe people either love to jump on the hate train, arenât even knowledgeable on the subject, or are those kinds of triggered ppl who dont know what theyâre talking about and just wanna be a defender.
So the plagiarism is mostly based on all about lust season 2 not the season 1.
The one you been explain in aal hoobae and sunbae is the season 1. The season 2 is between 2 friendnemy and one of them got curious and somehow it escalate sex friend situation.
The reason why it got flag as plagiarism is not only because of the similar art style or the similar plot. On some cases they even literally use the same dialog as aal (you can check the korean raw comparison on twitter) .
Additional the character name is way too similar to be coincidence even the bottom and the female has similar ass name.
Additional notes :
1. The childhood friend complex used to follow tirano on twitter for a long time and then suddenly unfollowed him after tirano call them out for the similarities (via private message)
2. After that tirano has tried multiple times asking for clarification from this author (still on dm) and never got responses so tirano posted on his blog about this whole issue
3. Until the end the author insisted that they took no inspiration from tirano and everything is coincidence when one of the cover pic is literally the same as tirano's. How unlikely for such coincidence to happen
Calisto reminds me of sylus idk they have similar vibes i think
I agree 100%
from what series?
It's an otome gacha game, love and deepspace
Hmmm??? No. Calisto is better than Sylus lmao. Sorry
in what way? i donât think we can compare fully but i see how they are a lil similar. also have you finished this storyâs novel plus all sylusâs lore or ur just a causal reader? genuinely curious
Sylus wouldnât hold a sword to your neck in the firts meeting