
When I started reading this manwha I actually hated the prince with everything he did in her past life. And I absolutely supported the two male, Allindes and Cassies (? Kinda forgot the name) I was hoping that one of them would end up the ml. But as the manwha progress, the story started showing why the boys weren't for her. And why the prince is the male lead.
First Allendis, he has this dark love for Tia. Strangling and killing her just for her the his. Tried to ruin her legitimacy and almost put her to harm. And Tia's father saw through his character and tried to keep them away for each other (I dont know if yah all remember) I dont know if that's okay for u guys and still saying thay u want him to be the ml. Because it int right and it isn't healthy. And mind u, even Allindes realize it himself that his love is wrong and distance himself.
Cassies(?) Hes a great guys. He really is. But then again he keep that attitude of happy go lucky and carefree. U all notice how he keep saying that he doesn't like Tia in that way or something in her face? Like how he handle the Tia when she's down? He would joke and make fun of it inorder the lighten up the mood. Its great and all but if they enter a relationship, that kind of attitude would be toxic. I clearly remember when he and Tia were oit and they saw someone proposing or making an oath of love or loyalty or someone and Tia said he also want something like that. And he kneel down and did it and while Tia was shock and a bit happy he TOLD HER IT WAS JUST A JOKE. Yeah, nope. Nuh uh. Toxic. That hurts like hell.
Lets remember guys Tia has trust issue.
And now for the prince.
I believe in past is past and present is present. But that doesn't erase the past. And that is what exactly is happening with Tia. When how she remember the past and wants to start over and making choices she never considered before changes a whole a lot of this that should happen but it didn't. The prince is the current prince who's sincere and love her whole hearted and he woe her in his own way. Tried to understand Tia and support her as much as he can.
Now this is where the past came in, where in Tia remember her last life of ruin. She cannot completely trust and believe the prince. As the past continue to hunts her. And the what if chasing her.
I don't know if u all read the novel but let me tell u there is always two side of the coin.
We all know what happened in the past life in Tia's perspective. I repeat, Tia's perspective. It means we only know her side, but what happened to the other side? Let me tell u, may be be the past life or the present life, both the prince and Tia LOVE EACH OTHER. Yes, u heard me right, they love each other.
What happened during the last life was not entirely Ruve's fault to why it all happened. Tia was actually at fault too. We may not remember bit Tia at the last life a was cruel and cold person with no expressions. And add to the drugs that was FEED TO BOTH OF THEM misunderstanding continue to grow. Ruve love Tia but all Ruve could see was a heartless women who doesn't care. A cold and expressionless women whk doesn't batt an eye when he's with black haired girl. He under influence of a drug and with the people whispering to his ear that Tia doesn't love him and only want his power and the position of an empress and when he look at Tia and that she's doing, it seems really legit and true.
Haiys... It was a tragic end for both of them yah know???
I believe this novel is all about trust and self love and second chances. In the present life BOTH TIA AND THE PRINCE change, hence the love for each other was clearly more shown than what it was it the past. In the past they never have the chance to talk. But in the present life was different, they talk and spend time with each other. They both have different choices in the present but there love for each other was still there.

Im not gonna talk about the brothers uniform when practicing sword was basically a tight fitting pants that emphasize the ass and butt-high boots and crop top jacket. And Im not also gonna point out about how the king's arms we're prop up high in the air when his elbows have no support. Nope. Not gonna talk about those dear. Im not. XD
What Im gonna talk about is how he literally called everyone a BETA when he was on earth. BWAHAHAHA! This literally cracks me up. He called everyone and himself a beta and not a human nor a boy! LOL! Now that's how we know that one person came from an ABO world. I must say the author did pay attention about that detail.

Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Don't you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! Dont you dare fall in love! DON'T YOU DARE FALL IN LOVE WITH HIIIMMMMM!!!!!!!!!

Me: Ohhh harry and malfoy? Im curious!
Brain: No.
Me: come on~
Brain: we are already deep enough in this rabbit hole and you want to sink deeper?
Me: but im curious about this
Brain: no
Me: yes
Brain: no
Me: just one
Brain: no. Nah-uh
Me: just this one I promise
Brain...just one?
Me: yes!
Brain: promise?
Me: yes
Brain: for real?
Me: for real
Brain:...fine
Me: yehey!
Reading: *enters malfoy
Brain: oh no...
Me: oh no...
Brain: hey, lets get out of here while we still can
Me: yeah lets go
*Few seconds later
Me: dammit! I wanna know how its goes!
Brain: me too! Damn this reader mentality and CURIOUSITY!
Me and brain: lets read this one and just this one.
*After reading
Me and brain: ...shit

Few spoiler ahead
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Elijah - Arthur's best friend both in the present and PAST WORLD. (MAJOR SPOILER: Here to take revenge against arthur since arthur(grey) killed his fiancee right in front of him from the past world)
Tess: Thr Fl of the story(ugh) Dumb as shit. So immature, join the war to "prove" that she is strong and "mature", in the end because of her selfishness cause a lot of death in there side including her squadron. Told not to get out of the shelter since once the enemy gets her its game over for their continent still go out (YOU DUMB SHIT!) In the end causing Arthus to almost LIKE ALMOST LIKE REEAALLYY ALMOST die in order to save her, arthur only managed to survive because of his bond(selvy) SACRIFICE (NOOOO! POOR POOR SYLVY! HUHU) And causing Arthus his mana core. Yes. Arthur lost his mana core ALL BECAUSE OF HER STUPIDNESS!! (I REALLY HATE HER)
Tess parents: They betrayed the continent for tess (ugh again) to keep her safe and they died.
Arthur's parents: After Arthur confess his secret about his past life they were confuse and angry and mad and full of what if (I mean if I am in their shoe I would too) it took them years to accept that their son is in his second life. They r still on the process of healing and accepting. But they keep fighting with arthus because they participate in the war and arthus dont want them causing them to fight about it every time it is brought up. But they still love each other. AND DADDY DIED. (FUCK!)
(Bro let me tell you it was such a horrible scene and u will cry ur heart out. Arthur's emotion was so real and it was FUCKING PAINFUL! Arthur worked hard ever since he was born so he can protect his family and all of it came crashing down and the hard work and effort of all those years all crumble with the death of his father. (HUHUHU) Arthur didn't even attend his father funeral afraid that his mother would would blame him and hate him(And no Arthur's mother didn't blame him, she was so sorry that because of her arthur couldn't attend his father's funeral and ooh boy arthur cried while his mother hug him) AND MIND U LIKE LITERALLY A DAY AFTER THE DEATH OF ARTHUR'S DAD HE HAVE TO GO AND CONSOLE TESS BECAUSE SHE ISN'T RESPONDING OR TALKING OT EATING BECAUSE SHE FEEL OF THE SELFISHNESS THAT CAUSE A LOT OF DEATH. CAN U BELIEVE THAT? LIKE GIRL!! ARTHUS IS SO MUCH MUCH HURT THAN YOU! WHY DO HE HAVE TO CONSOLE U BECAUSE OF YOUR OWN MISTAKE?!)
Arthur's sister: At one point she hated arthur. She hated that he is not always there the moment they needed him the most. Hated that she couldn't have a normal life as the little sister of the youngest lance. Hated him for the reason because of him mom and dad join the war feeling obliged to. And she train to much and also join the war as a magic archer. Basically all the leywen members joined the war. And she now has a bond a fucking tall bear she called boo.
Regis: Arthur's weapon (MY FUCKING FAVORITE CHARACTER) a living weapon that grow from arthurs memory. He has first an appearance of a black blob who only floats before turning into a wolf. And he van transform into a guntlet (pfft! Athur and him argue about the name because arthur would shout "regis, come into my hand!" and he didn't like it cause of its yuck so they devide to call it guanlet form) He is the sunshine of this novel. His personality is freaking perfect. Like a 100x version of arthur that was more loveble and the quirkyness is soo good. Even if the novel is already dark his the light of that novel. He made me laugh with all his convo and usage of modern terms! (BEST CHARACTER EVER)
My thumbs is quite sore now hahaha. Anyway u guys can read the novel. Im not gonna cover all the characters and all the happening in the novel cause oh boy It wah too much. And I honestly like Tess before until the she pulled that stupid move. She is now the hatest character in the novel. The princess is less annoying.

I wanna clarify, do Arthur and Elijah end up as enemies? Or maybe at the least Elijah hating Arthur because of past life? Or if not what exactly happens to their friendship. I don't think I can take the events to happen in the future with all these deaths, sadness, and stupidity (yes, that's you Tess (๑•ㅂ•)و✧)

Unfortunately yes. Elijah got noticed by the enemies and they recognized that he's one of them and kidnapped him. After years when Art and Elijah meet again, Elijah already recovered memories of his past life as Nico and is burning with resentment from past life. The hatered is one-sided, but Elijah is working with the enemy side, so they do become enemies.

Arthur's appearance CHANGED! His hair and eye color changed because of Sylvie's SACRIFICE. A reminder of Arthur of Salvie's sacrefice. And he also upset that the only striking and prominent resemblance of him of his parents are gone. He doesn't like his appearance at all. He will be forever be reminded that things have change and wouldn't be the same.

What the f. Why? Why?! My poor baby sylvie why did she have to die huhuh. I cant believe this. Arthur also lost his man core like what?! He worked so hard for that. Why?! I cant with this ╥﹏╥ ugh sylvie i loved her so much. Im really hating tess. I thought she was great but her friggin stupidity killed my poor baby huhuh

pleasee not ya’ll spreading false information..
it was said in the novel that Grey never even died. He was transported into this world, n into the body of Alice n Reynolds child. meaning that the real body of Arthur leywin was a body to support Grey’s body n he was never truly born. When the attack happens n they take Elijah, he’s still Elijah. The person who took him, agrona is an ancient mage person who studied reincarnation with the use of relics. He experimented those studies on Elijah bc he proved to be powerful when he fought to get Tess back during the school attack. During the experiments, Nico got into Elijahs body n is now using it as a vessel. Nico is using his body to get Cecilia back, his fiancé who died in the hands of grey. Although Cecilia made Grey kill her, Nico doesn’t know that n blames Grey for killing the love of his life. He wants to bring her back, but in the body of Tess.

https://www.lightnovelworld.com/novel/the-beginning-after-the-end-novel-09011258
it starts around 46 or 45

That's not how I understood it. Elijah didn't know his origins and was raised with the dwarves, a nation that secretly supported Argona. He awakened a power that is identical to what we later see Alacryans use. From what I see, Elijah was Nico from birth, but didn't have memories from previous life the same way Art has and Argona left im to be raised by dwarves so there's a chance to interact with Grey, but at the same time a chance to take him back easily through connection with dwarves. As Elijah and Art are about the same age, they can both be experiments by Argona on fate, with one resulting in incomplete reincarnation without memories and one complete with memories. After Alacryans attack the academy and notice him and his power raging without control, they take him back to get his power and mind in order. After Elijah is taken to Alacrya, I assume Argona helped Elijah to remember his past life as Nico and gain control over his power.
I even searched through the novel and in ch 250 there's this fragment:
"Actually, Elijah might’ve always been Nico - I remembered Elijah telling me how his memories before arriving in the kingdom of Darv was all a blur."
So i would say my interpretation makes more sense than Elijah suddenly turning into Nico in Alacrya.
And bout Grey being dead or not, it was never resolved. He only remembers falling asleep as Grey and then being born as Art. He assumed he died as Grey and was reborn, but it was never confirmed what happened with Grey in the end.

That's why to other people I told only general info of what happened. The details in my discussion with you are my understanding of events that happened and were not fully explained. What you wrote can also be called false info, because you told, that Nico got into Elijah's body only after kidnapping and that is also unconfirmed and only your interpretation. The same as saying that Art was never truly born?? This even I don't understand what you mean...
If you're calling people out on false information then don't spread it yourself. What I told people in the post that you called out was only things that were strictly told in the novel, without any additional interpretations of my own.
If you want to say that the false info is saying "Elijah already recovered memories of his past life as Nico", then no, it's not false. No matter when Nico got into Elijah's body, right now Elijah has both his own and Nico's memories, where Nico is not his current persona, ergo is his past life. True, Nico's emotions about Grey were stronger than the relationship Elijah build with Art, but Elijah personality isn't completely overwritten and taken over by Nico, so his current self as Elijah and his past self as Nico are both present.

As I can remember It was Tess. Tess is the fl of this story. Arthur chose Tess and he kissed her like very quickly before wiping his lips cause his kissing a kid. Haha. He was disgusted but what can he do? He like Tess. I don't really remember what he said, I think he said he would wait until they are older or something? Anyway, I need to catch up to thr novel haha
Director Kang's flirting skill: MAX
KYAAAAHHHHHHH ε=ε=(ノ≧∇≦)ノ