extraterrestrial_'s Topics (16)

It's long so read at your own risk fellow earthlings.
-
-
I have read multiple things before that've made my blood boil, but oh boy this one might take the cake.
I mean, she endured all that crap and abuse as a child for years, finally getting freedom upon leaving for university, only for her to get her world turned upside down by becoming the villainess(who isn't really a villain, more-so just a kid that got the short end of the stick when they thought they drew the long stick) of a game, who endures the same abuse that she just got away from.

That's not what makes me upset though, it's the actual dnjDNSFjnakjdnKJ AuDaCiTy that her 'family' has, to be shOcked when they see what Penelope is going through. Apparently it's possible that the head of the house, the Duke no less, has no clue that the child he willingly brought in, was subject to such abuse basically for the entire time since she was brought to the mansion(six-ish years). It's his literal home, you can't tell me that he doesn't know what is happening in his own home-- it's his job to know, to look after the estate as well as the subjects, to know what's happening in his estate. How ignorant do you have to be blind to such blatant neglect.
oh hO, and the 'brOtHeRs'. Those little turds, who know how the people of the estate see her(which is negatively, and as a matter of fact, the father also knows), choose to ignore it. Only when the 2nd brother actually catches Penelope's maid feeding her rotten food does he intervene, first surprised at the meal she's forcing herself to eat(because it's before the choice option was removed), then getting mad at the maid for doing so. Like buddy, you've also joined in on the bullying, so it is really so surprising to see a maid treating Penelope without and ounce of respect, when the entire family doesn't even show her respect? And when she's apologizing to the eldest son for the 'commotion' that wasn't her fault, which he also know's wasn't her fault, but still blamed her for making a ruckus? wOrDs fAiL to explain just how frustrating it is(I know it was in a beginning chapter, but I could go on and on about these bastards).

Personally, to me it doesn't matter that they're just now(throughout the story) realizing how terribly they and the household have been treating Penelope, and are just now starting to care a little bit more about her well-being, and even showing some kindness here and there to her. But, I say it doesn't matter because they had 6 long years to realize, hey maybe Penelope is acting out for a reason-- granted she of course changed only after the MC woke up in Penelope's body, but that doesn't mean they couldn't have, idk, maybe actually given a fuck before.
When you put a child in a neglectful, abusive, or un-nurturing environment what do you think is going to happen to the child? there are different outcomes, some children lose their will, they become quiet or subdued versions of themselves; some children act out with pranks, because maybe that'll garner some attention positive or not, maybe even a few laughs; some become overly anxious or fearful or overly apologetic since they don't know what they did to deserve such an unloving environment; some just take it as it comes, because children are so innocently forgiving when they're young, they'll think maybe after this my parent will start to like me; and some children will lash out in anger, throwing tantrums, or being aggressive, because any attention is attention, regardless if it's bad attention. It's heartbreaking.
Only after six years of neglect do they start to change, and for what? do they think she'll be happy, grateful? She'll be somewhat grateful, but the question can also be asked "Where was all this care for me when I was younger? Why now?". Both the MC and the Penelope before the MC transmigrated to the game, grew up in the same situation/environment, they both dealt with it differently, the MC trying her best to be invisible, and the Penelope of the game lashed out and threw tantrums, but do you expect that the current Penelope/MC is going to be like "Oh my family is being nicer to me now, guess that makes everything okay"? No, she's not going to act that way. them being nicer-ish doesn't make up for their past neglect, it's a start in the right direction- towards being better as people and as a family members, but that doesn't change the fact that there was a time where they didn't care. Of course, you can't change the past, you can only learn from it, but for Penelope, who wasn't really shown any kindness at the Duchy, simply being nicer doesn't mean anything unless it's shown in their future actions.

As a note, I don't mean to offend anyone with my rant, nor do I claim to be an expert in child psychology or child development, but I know from firsthand experiences, from seeing my friends and other kids change because of the unhealthy environment at home, that neglectful or abusive homes are fricking detrimental to children. And I specifically mean parents that have the Choice or the Ability to hang out with their kid, get to know their kid, but choose to ignore or abuse them. Parents like the Duke who had the ability to be a parent to Penelope, but ultimately just chose not, ignoring her when she needed a parental figure(because she was only 12djskfnajkdsedksnfjdasnjdsf what a jerk) letting her spend money as she pleased because that'll apparently make up for his lack of absence.
And When she finally stands up for herself, against the 2nd brother, and says what she actually wants to say, it was really satisfying. Also my frustration, doesn't mean that I don't like the story, because I really enjoy reading this, I just don't really like her families ignorance. The story/plot and art though? Chefs Kiss, bellissima.

This concludes my frustrated and extremely long rant.

I translated a few of the chapters in russian, do you think it's fine if I just go over it with the english translation?

Aight first off she is in no way obligated to show respect to this guy. She didn't know him and to top it off she found out that he was stalking her. she's not a "bitch" for not wanting to go or for burning that creepy ass notebook.
I mean, how would you feel if some fucking guy asked you to go to the funeral of a guy who you didn't even know, just because the dead guy had a crush on you. And then while at the funeral his mom gives you his diary that's filled with thing's about you, with specific dates and times. LIKe bitch? I'd be creeped the fuck out!
what's worse is that his own mother and best friend just stood on the sidelines and let him be a little creeper, they inhibited that stalking behaviour, which would only make him think that he isn't doing anything wrong.

I honestly have no idea as to why anyone hates this girl. She's coping quite well with having found out that she was being stalked.

Can someone tell me if the plot is good overall? Like do you find yourself cringing from secondhand embarrassment all the time when reading this, or are there other elements to the story that help further the plot?
Her thoughts, her actions are a bit much, but if the plot is good, then I'm going to read it of course. I started reading it, but I already feel myself cringing a bit from the secondhand embarrassment, but I'm not sure if that's all there is to the story. I'd just like to know, before I get too invested in the story, thanks.
(also, does anyone know where the guy with the ponytail is from? the guy at the end of the chapter on the credit page(●'◡'●) )

Yo, so I started this thinking it was going to be cute n stuff, but noO, it's not. It's not cute. Once I saw Yul/Yuri's room in one of the beginning chapters, I was like aight Imma head out. It's quite scary when you see how obsessed Yul/Yuri is, in regards to Sian, and then when you find out all the effort he's put into stalking Sian, it's just wAcK, it has passed just being 'obsessive' or 'infatuated'. The best advice for Yul, is to Stop it. Get some help.

I understand the pressure of society, given that in comparison to us, the time period seems to be late medieval and later than that(idk, maybe early to mid 1700 at the latest(? Feel free to correct me)), and as much as I want to claim that the injury to the girls honor is exaggerated, it isn't. Like the smallest 'scandal' could mean social suicide, which is like so f**king annoying, like get off your high horse you damn Oedipus. But it sucks big time for Yuri, because homeboy was just like "oh sh*t I think this gorl's suffocating" and she just wanted to help. The rational thing to do, would be to get help, however we can't expect everyone to be rational in stressful situations. Yuri panicked, because she was scared of the girl dying right then and there, which is completely understandable, she couldn't have possibly known that the corset wasn't the root of the problem. Which is why the chaos that ensued feels so frustrating.
That aside I do believe that the queens punishment/challenge is more than a little unfair(damn high society) but Yuri will probably be able to pull it off, because she's just that amazing.
Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.