Deep inside i'm sure Catherine felt regrets of what happen to Annette's life now. She might think what if I didn't tell her about her brother. She took her in out of pity and Annette kindness somehow makes her sad. Yk, from a rich to a homeless? And inflicted in war now. I don't blame annete or cath but heiner. Heiner wants to make her a rag which nobody even want her. He succeed for what cost?? It just like you get revenge to a kid who just learn how to live. I don't think i can like him. His backstory was sad but it won't justify by what he did to annete and crazy enough to blame her of his own actions. Bruhh they can never make me like heiner