Yoon Nakyum October 7, 2023 2:04 am

How can a mother abandoned her son like that without any effort to save him? She abandoned Jooin right after giving birth. Now she left him just like that??? The guard would let jooin die but they won't let the women die so just threaten the guard in order to save jooin. Why left him like that. What if seme didnt found him? He obviously will die... ┗( T﹏T )┛

    Rixz October 7, 2023 3:11 am

    I think the mom thinks the dad was too weak willed for the royal life thats why she left them, she thinks its better that they live a normal life. Its very evident on her advice for the ML. Also i think the guard is holding her down and if she did jumped in the guards would shoot jooin cause he's endangering her.

Yoon Nakyum October 1, 2023 12:40 am

Uke reminds me of Gotouda Aki. Their fashion sense are similar.

Yoon Nakyum October 1, 2023 12:33 am

Why is this so famous? Will there any redemption arc? Any spoiler?

    yuu not you October 4, 2023 2:27 pm

    The novel is top tier, the manhwa is on going so the progress is slow but the novel ended since 2022. And it gained popularity bcs how good it was

Yoon Nakyum September 30, 2023 2:58 pm

Sorry i don't pity you little rabbit since you're too dumb and idiot. You're the one who sees yourself as a doormat and keep giving that scum many chances. Eat up what you've been asking for. After all you chose the bastard no matter how bad he had treated you. Life is a choice. You keep choosing the same thing so why you want to cry... Pfttt..

    nogodonlymanga September 30, 2023 11:15 pm

    you're gross.

    Yoon Nakyum September 30, 2023 11:56 pm
    you're gross. nogodonlymanga

    You even worst when you know all that coming but still saying awww so you don't victim. Don't be such a hypocrite fcker in the name of sympathy. We all know the fact who was the guy and who was giving an abuser chances after all he did? Not once but many times. Don't act like you're saint by calling others gross. Such a hypocrite

    Yoon Nakyum October 1, 2023 12:04 am

    The abuser trash won't change. This is the fact. If it was about to call it was the police. But instead he's giving so many chances but will hurt eventually. It's not like he didn't know. It was him who choose to be suffer and who are you to call me gross when they don't even want to choose good path? Still choose toxic in the name of love? The way you're thinking is even worst. Love shouldn't be like this. If hurt it wasn't anymore love. Fix the way you think before calling others gross... Hypocrite!

    nogodonlymanga October 1, 2023 12:07 am
    The abuser trash won't change. This is the fact. If it was about to call it was the police. But instead he's giving so many chances but will hurt eventually. It's not like he didn't know. It was him who choose ... Yoon Nakyum

    nasty.

    Yoon Nakyum October 1, 2023 12:14 am

    Hypocrite

    марионетка October 1, 2023 1:03 am

    If you like toxic story doesn't mean you can trash others perspective

    марионетка October 1, 2023 1:08 am

    Agree.. i hate how author romantizing the whole abuse story without empowering bottom. At least redemption arc would do. Instead uke keep falling at the same trap... It same like silent lover

Yoon Nakyum September 30, 2023 2:54 am

I am shocked that uke didnt hate his mom. What a shittiest mom she is... Wtf making a child as a partway gift? No responsibility at all. Abandoned him like that after giving birth and is this how a mother should act especially looking at his child drowning like that. She don't deserve to be called mom at all..

Yoon Nakyum September 25, 2023 10:16 am

best merman waifu - Lanbo
best merman hubby - Agaras
They both hot and badass!

Yoon Nakyum September 24, 2023 2:21 am

I miss Daddy taesung and his sugar baby sooyoung.. bring them back. Enough with backstory. The chapters are too long already.

Yoon Nakyum September 18, 2023 9:27 am

I don't deny how this fcker Xiao Nuo felt about his past but I WISH MO WILL STOP BEING PUSHOVER since I can see his effort just wasted. Xioa Nuo don't deserve him at all. He wasn't traumatized about his past but more like he wasn't ready to be in relationship with Mo, that's why he just wants to stay as fwb. Mo needs to stop now as I can see in the raw HE'S STILL THE ONE WHO PURSUE Xiao Nuo even until now. It just too frustrated to read. Xiao Nuo said Mo don't see him as himself but at least Mo feeling is honest and never cheat unlike him who claim he likes Mo but screw around with other people. What a lame excuse!!! Ughhhh

Yoon Nakyum September 16, 2023 5:59 am

Oh wow... Now they cut some scenes to make us less hate on this bastard Qiyu. Actually Pei Xingxu saw how Qiyu has treated Song Liqing. He was cruel to him, humiliate him infront of ppl and intimate with his mistress in front of Liqing. Since Xingxu loved Liqing very deeply, he just can't stand how his loved one has been treated like a rubbish. So he proposed to king.

Qiyu got angry and go to his mistress. Mistress said "maybe" they were in relationship since he saw them few times together. Qiyu trust his mistress and accuse him on adultery wtf. He was angry and beat Liqing up r@ped him mercilessly. Liqing didn't wake on the next morning. His bed was drench with blood. When he r@ped him, the blood flows out non-stop since he had blood disease. If they got injury the wound is hard to heal (in modern era we might called it Leukemia).

Qiyu called the docs include liqing friends. He was shocked and angry like hell to see liqing wounds. He explained to Qiyu about liqing conditions. He's mocking back and said "it's not like he could die from sex" fcccckkk i curse him like hell dude! The worst seme i could see

Next, Xingxu will come and rescue. He gave his elixir to qiyu. It was given by his dad so he can extend life about 18years (if i'm not mistaken, 1 pill could extend 6years). He gave liqing all. He loved liqing so much.

While liqing was battling with life and dead, Qiyu went to see his mistress to reduce his stress. Liqing literally dying and die if xingxu didn't give him the pill. When all ppl busy to revive liqing who was dying, Qiyu was enjoyed sxx with his mistress. Xingxu saw them with disgust.

Next morning, after Qiyu satisfied and no stress he come and check liqing. Liqing woke up from nightmare and hugs him. He thought Qiyu stays with him all night. Xingxu bitterly smile knowing Qiyu never worried and even go to slept with his mistress. Even so, he doesn't speak anything. As long liqing is healthy again, he couldn't ask more.

This entire novel will show how pure, kind and devoted pei xingxu Vs how worst Qiyu. But the ending was so tragedic to pei xingxu who literally done nothing wrong. While Qiyu and liqing are happy together. If author want Qiyu to be the end game, why put pei xingxu as an angel and killed him mercilessly??? While the scum got happy ending?

I will keep going to spill every thing since I don't want they make qiyu understandable with the scene cut.

    J1mb0 September 16, 2023 7:16 am

    Bro that's fking terrible

    dareader September 17, 2023 1:27 am

    Qiyu and Liquing is the end game???? WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCKKKK???? tell me this isn't true

    Yoon Nakyum September 17, 2023 4:27 am
    Qiyu and Liquing is the end game???? WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCKKKK???? tell me this isn't true dareader

    It is true.. when Qiyu become the king liqing become the minister. They didn't remarry and Qiyu also didn't marry anyone else. They were in relationship and raised a child together (Xingxu and liqing adopted son). Xingxu die tragedicaly with his country burnt and wiped out from the map. Just because Qiyu shows some regrets and gave his eyes to liqing, he become soft at the end. (Qiyu got another pair of eyes from others lmao). But Xingxu gave his life to liqing. He sacrifice his own life and everything he had for liqing but..... I cried so much of his last monologue before he died. He don't deserve this ending. Liqing and qiyu don't deserve happiness... These both donkeys can go to hell... What a shitty ending

    Kajistuwu September 20, 2023 2:23 am
    Qiyu and Liquing is the end game???? WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCKKKK???? tell me this isn't true dareader

    It can't be help. It always end that way isn't it in every story? Even though the seme is a jerk, as long as they're the main in the story, they will always end up together. Classic

    Unknown September 22, 2023 10:57 pm

    Omg more spoilers please!!

    rumochi September 23, 2023 12:00 am
    It is true.. when Qiyu become the king liqing become the minister. They didn't remarry and Qiyu also didn't marry anyone else. They were in relationship and raised a child together (Xingxu and liqing adopted so... Yoon Nakyum

    bruhhh idfk anymore,,, what's up with these trashy stories, plots and authors- I just wanna know what in the effin world are those authors thinking when they write these kind of shits, like where is your brain and just what is it doing when u write this kind of ending for your already deep in shit story!?? don't they even question themselves when they look back at their works? like??? it's not only about this one, I'm seriously frustrated because of these kind of works cuz they leave me in a state i just cannot fully describe.. i start reading without even knowing what's gonna become of the story and then I continue hoping things are gonna get solved and have a good turn of direction, but they hit me in the face like "danggg u thought bish I'm gonna be worse than your worst nightmare" then I just drown in sorrow ( yea because of a fictional story I know :') ) and be needing a long time to recover... anyways thanks a bunch for letting me know, so I won't be continuing this trash any longer. wishing u a nice day!

    Yoon Nakyum September 23, 2023 4:29 am
    Omg more spoilers please!! Unknown

    Idk how to describe this scene from Novel. It was terrible that you could imagine. Rape until he was drench with blood. While xingxu and liqing bff (doc) stays up all night, he went to have sex with his mistress.

    Next scene (seme+mistress). They fcck idk. Liqing as usual saw them in bitter. Liqing even went to see the officer to drop the mistress title (from slave title) so mistress could marry qiyu officially (concubine). Tbh he's dumb!

    Next during king's celebration, he was poisoned. So they blame Liqing. He was brutally tortured in the dungeon by Qiyu. Qiyu listen to his mistress about liqing background (he was the prince of previous king) well he didn't know about this either. After the king woke up, the real culprit was captured (his mistress). The king slapped Qiyu. Those scene was hell funny. He was spoiled brat. That was the first time daddy hit him. Lolll..

    Liqing was brutally tortured until all his fingers distorted and he become blind. To make it more terrible, Qiyu push the hot branding stamp on his arm that make him scream in pain.

    After the nightmare, he told to Qiyu that he don't love him anymore. So Qiyu was so angry and threatened him to kill all Song family. That was the time he was raged with anger and frustrated. Luckily Xingxu come to rescue again and he also saved Song family.

    Liqing later released from the prison after clear up his name. Qiyu shamelessly apologize and said "they are husband and wife" so don't keep in heart. TTFFFUCCKK. Let me tear your skin alive like you did to him whipped all body until your white robe become red. Pfftt.. thats what he did to him. I said this very very very bad.if Xingxu didn't come to rescue, he probably died.

    He proposed divorce after few days. Well... The king approved it since he knew his dumb son already touched Liqing weaknesses (adoptive dad/general song). He won't easily back up. If he didn't touch General song, maybe he still could accept him.. so stupid this uke

    Unknown September 23, 2023 5:16 am
    Idk how to describe this scene from Novel. It was terrible that you could imagine. Rape until he was drench with blood. While xingxu and liqing bff (doc) stays up all night, he went to have sex with his mistres... Yoon Nakyum

    Wow, he’s much more worst than his father. I hate that they still ended up, and Qiyu didn’t even have to do a lot to get him back. That’s just annoying.

    Purupuru September 23, 2023 9:45 am
    Idk how to describe this scene from Novel. It was terrible that you could imagine. Rape until he was drench with blood. While xingxu and liqing bff (doc) stays up all night, he went to have sex with his mistres... Yoon Nakyum

    No what ...I thought he'll end up with the second lead that seme is trash he don't deserve happiness at all

    Aaaaaa September 23, 2023 5:17 pm
    Idk how to describe this scene from Novel. It was terrible that you could imagine. Rape until he was drench with blood. While xingxu and liqing bff (doc) stays up all night, he went to have sex with his mistres... Yoon Nakyum

    Really love the way you narrated the entire story! Now I don't even see any point of continuing it! Baseless accusations and torture after torture?? Where is the story even heading to?? And the author justifying seme's actions by sacrificing his eyes is a pure mockery!

    Heu77 September 24, 2023 1:29 am

    Did the stupid shitty ML really sleep with the mistress while mc was suffering??!!!!!
    (I’m not talking about the first season couple, but their son and another guy that is the uke and suffering now)

    Yoon Nakyum September 24, 2023 1:56 am
    Did the stupid shitty ML really sleep with the mistress while mc was suffering??!!!!!(I’m not talking about the first season couple, but their son and another guy that is the uke and suffering now) Heu77

    Yes. He was feeling annoying when xingxu ask to be alone with liqing for the treatment process. He was waiting outside of the room and feel irritated. His mistress came to see seme since he didn't see him that day. So mistress flirting with Qiyu by saying to reduce his uncomfortable feeling or burden or whatever it is and so yeah... They went to the bed to have sex. Xingxu saw them with anger and frustration but he didn't bother since he was busy to treat dying uke.. idk how long they had sex but he only came back until next morning to check on uke. Liqing hugged xingxu. He thought it was Qiyu. He asked about Qiyu and Xingxu also lies about "Qiyu stays and worry about you". The fact he didn't care. The reason why he lied because he can see liqing hopeful eyes. He don't want to break his heart by saying truth. At that time Qiyu came and they talked. Liqing said sorry for his mistake pfftt what an idiot!! So qiyu said... Now you know, don't try to make me angry again if you don't want to suffer like this anymore. What a fckup story!!

    Heu77 September 24, 2023 2:01 am
    Yes. He was feeling annoying when xingxu ask to be alone with liqing for the treatment process. He was waiting outside of the room and feel irritated. His mistress came to see seme since he didn't see him that ... Yoon Nakyum

    Did the novel really say they had sex or it just says he went to his mistress’s room? I really just can’t believe knowing this author

    Yoon Nakyum September 24, 2023 2:07 am
    No what ...I thought he'll end up with the second lead that seme is trash he don't deserve happiness at all Purupuru

    No actually he married 2nd ML. They raised adoptive son together. But not for long. After Loulan kingdom (2nd ML country) under attack, they split. Uke choose to follow 1st ML back to his country (bcause 1st ML use eye problem as excuses). That's when the love start to bud again fccck! While they were in lovey dovey, 2nd ML was captured and been put in the dark and cold dungeon. His limbs are all cut off. His eyes was freshly gouged. His face mutilated. They cut his nose. It was horrified. Imagine my angel pretty and kind man became like this??? He finally died with his burnt kingdom and his kingdom was wipe out of the map. It was awful ending for him. How could author make and angel, innocent, saviour and Charming man end up tragedy? He done nothing wrong. Absolutely nothing! And uke choose to be with 1st seme. So they end up together.

    Yoon Nakyum September 24, 2023 2:14 am
    Did the novel really say they had sex or it just says he went to his mistress’s room? I really just can’t believe knowing this author Heu77

    It wasn't directly says sex but outside of Liqing room they perform intimacy like entagled skin to skin and kisses passionately. It was witnessed by Xingxu. Soon after, both of them went to mistress room. Misstress says he will make seme forget all the stress and unsettling feelings. Actually Qiyu usually go to misstress room only for sex. He went back to liqing if he wants to sleep.

    Heu77 September 24, 2023 2:39 am
    It wasn't directly says sex but outside of Liqing room they perform intimacy like entagled skin to skin and kisses passionately. It was witnessed by Xingxu. Soon after, both of them went to mistress room. Misst... Yoon Nakyum

    I thought the first couple Seme was worst. Jesus I hate their son so much

    Heu77 September 24, 2023 2:39 am
    No actually he married 2nd ML. They raised adoptive son together. But not for long. After Loulan kingdom (2nd ML country) under attack, they split. Uke choose to follow 1st ML back to his country (bcause 1st ML... Yoon Nakyum

    Wait the second season uke married the 2nd ML but went back to the shitty ML?? Fuck

    Yoon Nakyum September 24, 2023 2:52 am
    Wait the second season uke married the 2nd ML but went back to the shitty ML?? Fuck Heu77

    Yeah. After divorce 1st ML, he married 2nd ML after long ride. And after 2nd ML died, he back with 1st ML but they didn't remarry.. When 1st ML become king, uke become his minister and they were in relationship. Just not married

    Heu77 September 24, 2023 3:01 am
    Yeah. After divorce 1st ML, he married 2nd ML after long ride. And after 2nd ML died, he back with 1st ML but they didn't remarry.. When 1st ML become king, uke become his minister and they were in relationship... Yoon Nakyum

    This is the second couple right you’re talking about? Not the first season couple? You’re talking about the first couple’s son and the scholar uke right?

    Making sure. I’m in complete utter disbelief. How did a once-trash’s son become more of a trash, a garbage.
    Jesus. Poor uke. Why did the scholar uke divorce 1st ML? What led to the divorce? And why did he marry 2nd ML?

    Yoon Nakyum September 24, 2023 3:14 am
    This is the second couple right you’re talking about? Not the first season couple? You’re talking about the first couple’s son and the scholar uke right?Making sure. I’m in complete utter disbelief. How... Heu77

    Yes. I'm talking about their son, Qiyu who is the worst than his dad. You can read my spoiler under this thread why he asked for divorce. It was a nightmare

    Heu77 September 24, 2023 3:30 am
    Yes. I'm talking about their son, Qiyu who is the worst than his dad. You can read my spoiler under this thread why he asked for divorce. It was a nightmare Yoon Nakyum

    I heard Shen Yu (uke of first couple) never disciplined their son Qiyu. No wonder why their son sucks ass, I expected he would discipline him and make sure he didn’t do the same shit his other father did.

    Also I can’t find your spoiler, link? Thank you! Gosh I hate them all

    Heu77 September 24, 2023 3:30 am
    Yes. I'm talking about their son, Qiyu who is the worst than his dad. You can read my spoiler under this thread why he asked for divorce. It was a nightmare Yoon Nakyum

    And 2nd ML deserved better

    dareader September 26, 2023 4:03 pm

    fuck dis, I'm dropping it. they should've just ended it with lian er and his husband together with their son being a happy family

    Soti September 29, 2023 7:00 am

    After reading the spoilers in this thread, I am definitely dropping this. Thank you so much for the warning. The 2nd ML didn't deserve to die the way he did.
    May I know who attacked his kingdom? Was it Qiyu that did it? And Qiyu's mistress that framed Song Liqing, I hope he got the same punishment as Song Liqing?

    I am also wondering why Qiyu's parents never sat him down to tell him about their own story. Maybe that could have taught him to be kinder to those he loved.

    As for the author, I have no words for them. You would think that after what they did with the first story, they would do better with the second story. This is what happens when keep enabling sadistic semes and tolerating their stupid attitudes all because they are handsome. I already started the novel but I haven't even finished the first chapter yet. I'm dropping both the novel and the manhwa as of this moment.

    Soti September 29, 2023 7:02 am

    I still can't believe that Song Liqing left his husband to die and followed Qiyu back to his country. Gosh! The second male lead died alone. I'm crying so much just thinking about it. My goodness! I wish I never even started this story.

    Soti September 29, 2023 7:06 am
    No actually he married 2nd ML. They raised adoptive son together. But not for long. After Loulan kingdom (2nd ML country) under attack, they split. Uke choose to follow 1st ML back to his country (bcause 1st ML... Yoon Nakyum

    Don't tell me he abandoned Xingxu? Don't tell Xingxu died knowing that he has been abandoned? Please tell me he at least died with a happy memory of Song Liqing??? Oh my God! Please tell me it's not what I'm thinking! My entire day is ruined!

    Heu77 September 29, 2023 8:11 am
    Don't tell me he abandoned Xingxu? Don't tell Xingxu died knowing that he has been abandoned? Please tell me he at least died with a happy memory of Song Liqing??? Oh my God! Please tell me it's not what I'm th... Soti

    Ugh uke is dumb for following after the seme. That 2nd ML was fine (from what I hear some people are saying) more so than the ML. It’s annoying how good ukes always end with trashy ass ML. Poor 2nd ML.

Yoon Nakyum September 15, 2023 2:45 pm

I can't tell a Canis lupus (grey wolf) to give up on his owner Jooin since their nature is loyal and faithful but we know what Hachiko went thru afterwards. I cried like hell. so i'm wishing Cain to just give up on Jooin before he was left alone and hurt for his entire life. Kitty sunbae was Jooin's first love. Jooin was Cain's first love. Jooin keeps thinking about Yahwi but he only thinks about Cain when he just called... Tbh i want someone to love cain as much as he love them. Period

    butipromiseihavehappypaws September 15, 2023 3:07 pm

    You make good points -- but your comment is underrated for its funniness lol


    That said, good points. I second.

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.