GenkiJaNaiiii's Topics (2469)

wait hold up what she’s gonna end up with ijekiel i thought the ml was lucas

I have no idea. I'm assuming the ml is Lucas but people are insisting that Ijekiel is the one because of what he said to Jeanette.

well i hope not cuz i can’t see ijekiel and anthy together. like lucas is better fitted for anthy he was there helping her majority of the time #teamlucas for da win

The ml is Lucas not ijekiel

I understand where you are coming from, and I agree that is not hard being in her position, but I cannot sympathize with her, because her position in the story is so conflictive that it overrides any regard I have for her as a character. She is not Claude's daughter. She is not Athy's sister. And her intention to keep clinging to those positions and thus creating the conflict she is creating for no good reason, completely nullifies any sympathy I can have for her. I understand it is not her fault of course, but I like Athy significantly more, and the fact that Jeanette's very existence is a source of stress for Athy, when it doesn't have to be (because all of the things she thinks she is and deserves are not true), really puts her on my bad side.

I don't think the author is asking for sympathy for Jeanette, but instead making it clear that she isn't an enemy. Also, I'm pretty sure in the novel/original of this webcomic, she is actually Claude's daughter or somewhat related to him. She also isn't aware that she might not be his daughter, mainly because of her eyes, which I think everyone forgets that she doesn't know anything about the plot of the story.

I see where you're coming from, but recently I've been thinking about this:

Since Jennette did not reincarnate with her past knowledge, we can say that her character has stayed exactly the same as it was in their first life. Now, this information is important because we can see how she would act once she has everything she wants. In the first life, she has the love of her father (she thinks Claude is her father), she has a lovely sister, she marries the guy she wants and he is literally perfect, she becomes a princess, she gets new clothes and a whole palace just for herself. So, what does she do? She sees that Athy's palace/items get taken but says nothing, she notices that Claude acts bad towards Athy but does nothing, she sees that everyone favors her even though they're both princesses and she does n o t h i n g. She has the affection of Claude, so surely if she said some nice words about Athy to Claude, Claude would start to see Athy in a different light. We can see that she's also a bit possessive? Like when she saw Ejekiel and Athy talking she got upset because she doesn't to share Athy OR Ejekiel.

Also I didn't write this paragraph to hate on Jennette but to analize her character.

In the original she is not Claude's daughter either. Also, in the novel she actually is an enemy and tried to harm Athy

say it louder for the people in da back this was what i’ve been tryna say

This is also a really important aspect of her character. However, since we've seen that she feels her only place in the world is to be a princess, the product of said psychological manipulation, what happens when that comes true for her? Like I've said, she's not the brightest person and is extremely naive. Her only goal is to be loved by the emperor, and she does receive it, which takes away her only reason for doing pretty much anything. Since she's so naive, I doubt it ever occurred to her that Athy was suffering or wasn't loved, or she could even assume that because she has the emperor's love that she has the perfect family and nothing could go wrong if Athy died or went away. Jeanette often doesn't have the foresight for her actions and I'm assuming that she was blinded by what she was given.

same (ಥ_ಥ)

She's a fictional character honestly there's nothing wrong with people wanting her to die. Not that i want her to die of course, she should get a decent ending as well.

But see, this is where basic human empathy comes in. Especially as a fictional character, her whole life has been told to us, the readers, and us only. So asking her to die, meaning end her life permanently, after knowing about her birth, her life, and even her identity as a chimera which she herself doesn't even know, is a little harsh don't you think?

That's a good point but i still disagree. Her dying or people wanting her to die will have no consequences in real life, if people wanted a real person to die though, that would surely be different.

It might have no consequence in real life, but would it be justified in the story? I guess what I'm trying to say is asking for her death reasonable for her actions? She's introduced as kind, empathetic or sympathetic, lonely, and very very naive. If Jeanette were a real person, or if any character were a real person, I feel that the readers should keep in mind that if they wouldn't want it in real life, it's wrong to ask it of fictional characters simply because they have no worth.

I mean no it’s a fictional story jennatte has her issues and I can see how her death would be beneficial to the story you have to spectate reality from fiction. I have oc’s I kill off who I have written every aspect to thier lives but they just simply don’t serve a purpose to the plot and would help the story move along better dead

What would Jeanette's death do? It might lessen the threat to Claude and Athy, but Athy has been kind and forgiving to her. At times she almost thought of her as a sister. Also, don't forget that the readers have almost no say in what happens. So asking her to die despite not being able to change anything? Does a fictional character who is both a child and an idiot, deserve so much hate that it's spurred people to want her dead?

It’s a fictional character hated or not it doesn’t matter people find her obnoxious you can’t change that and it would spice up the story since Claude obviously sees something in her and avenge her. If it’s him who killed her the opponents could use it to their advantage and spark a rebellion and you seem to be forgetting she is a valuable chess piece with her gone the antagonists would have to go forward with a more direct or violent plan. Perhaps Jeannette’s father and old white hair guy really did care for her so assasination attempts on Claude and Athy. Plus yes it could help Claude’s relationship With Athy or it could ruin it. Maybe Athy was part of the reason she died causing mental distress to herself and probably distancing herself from others until she has some character development. Or Claude killed Jeannette and it upsets Athy and Claude finally understands killing is wrong and He has some character development

Killing off characters tends to benifit the story unless the character has a lot of wasted potential or it seems unnatural but Claude killing others has already been established and she doesn’t have a lot of lose ends

Her death does change quite a bit. Anastacius (well, the wizard inside Anastacius) wouldn't be able to hurt Claude. And he's the villain of the story so that would help in defeating him.

AHHHH SRYY I ACCIDENTALLY DISLIKED

right! like she was raised with him and she thought of him as a brother and when she finds out they arent related, it becomes incest? like wtf ew