
I'll go with the black-hair dude. Why? NOT only of his FACE CARD, HIS GORGEOUS HAIR, AND BLUE EYES (I'M SCARED OF HIM) But because he actually saved the mc back to life and granted him his wishes. He just did what he's supposed to do, granting human wishes.
But his approach, like his gaslighting is bad and toxic, the mc deserves better. He should change his ways to more something more humane. But I guess he's a supernatural and not a human being, he is yet incapable of thinking like a human.
But as he said the thing that keeps him alive is the mc's desire, so the mc does desire him. In the previous chapters, he actually had an existential crisis LOL but because the mc came and begged for his help, maybe he found his purpose again. So in conclusion, they found each other.
I was actually very scared of him at first but I came to like him after I knew his past. Anyways, that's just what I think. Maybe I like supernatural stuff so much that I feel gravitated towards him. To me, he is the better option for NOW. :)
this horndog can't really say no this fucker