Rudadee's Topics (46)

Brooo u might be onto something or on something cus like ciel being wanted by the yard is like ciel being wanted by rciel and pluto being dead is like snake being dead

As a Black Butler fan who's watched the anime and reads the manga I've never noticed this at all, a lot of season 1 of the anime was non canon to the manga, I'm not sure if the creator was involved with season 1. Maybe she was? I'm not for sure, a lot of times the anime version has a different writer.

And as for the ending, I'm not really sure if it's going to end like season 1 did. It could end completely different

The second book follows Yukiya and the Crown Prince, while the first book follows only the events in the Sakura Palace. They're very different stories because of the difference in perspectives. Also, having also watched the anime, I wouldn't say that the first book is the main plot. The anime is trying to cover both perspectives at the same time to give a more full picture of the events. As an example, reading only the first book wouldn't tell you why Yukiya is the Prince's aid and how he got there. He's very much a background character of the book since it focuses on the consort candidates and their competition. However, in the second book we can see who he is and what he's experiencing. It gives us another point of view of the power struggle between the yatagarasu and the four families. Why do you think the second book is purposeless?

Like you said its just giving us different pov. IMO I like the anime more as it seems more complete. So my question is, is the 2nd book a remake of the 1st book? Because the core of the story is the same just with different pov. If so, how about the other books? Is it going to be the same story but with different pov also?

The second book is not a remake of the first. They're not the exact same story either. It's the events that occur outside of the Sakura Palace from Yukiya's POV. The events overlap, but what Yukiya experiences is different from from those in the Sakura Palace experiences and vice versa. A remake would follow the same exact events. I know the 3rd and 4th volumes have to do with Yukiya going forward. The 5th and 6th volumes are books that cover the same time period from different perspectives

For me even if the pov is different there's still for example the death of Kazumi. Why would they repeat the same story with different pov for 4 books. We would know it by then. The books just add a few details, with the same conclusion in the end. I much prefer a new story like 3rd & 4th book. Can you imagine creating books for every character in a story. That would be tedious

Wow. You didn't read what I wrote at all. Like I said before, Kazumi's death is touched on twice because this is the same time period from POV. Just because they're two different POV doesn't mean they don't see the same events at times. Kazumi's death was important to the narrative on both sides. Thus, the perspective from both sides is given. As I also said before, the 3rd and 4th books cover Yukiya going forward. As in pass the events in book 1 and 2. I never said that they're the same events from a different perspective.

The 5th and 6th cover the same time period from different perspectives, but don't follow the same plot as books 1 and 2. There are no 4 perspectives of the same events.

I was referring to the '5 & 6 books that cover the same time period from different perspectives'. Which I assume 'time period' is the same events in book 1 and 2. Hence there are 4 books. Well let's just agree to disagree and enjoy the story wherever direction it takes ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~

Hey, could you share the link where I can read these?

Am I pregante?

i am praganant

Can you get pregante? On a second note, I miss exiled rebels scans.

Am I pregananant

Andrim lives his life as the evil minister. That is him. He never changes. He is the evil minister. Having an info of a past life is just a bonus to avoid any death flags on the game.

Oh, so he's just living as Andrim. I am so used to reincarnation manga that wants to change their character. So I thought his past life will have big impact on his decision making. That's interesting. Thank you for the reply

So the only thing that really changes about him as a person when he gains memories of his past life is that he learns familial love. He had a wonderful family and a little sister he adored, plus the fact that when he played the game he felt kind of bad for Julieta. So he regains his memories, and he learns to love his daughter who was previously nothing but a tool to him. Other than that, he is exactly the same person he has always been. He’s in his forties. Forty years of his awful personality and behavior, it’s kind of a miracle that even that much changed about him.

I read somewhere that he used his daughter after regained his past memory

Spoiler.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
He is did use his daughter for the revenge against the prince and his fiancee, but rather than 'use' per SE, they have become an accomplice (together with mallachia). That's a more equal relationship than before he regained his original memory

For the end of the volume. There's a cure for the curse, (that killed their family when they reached age 55) but only one person can have it. He gave the cure to his daughter.

Oh wow, thank you for the spoiler. So he did change a bit.

No, Sebastian hired them to protect him, he can't do it all himself.

I mean of course Sebastian hire them for protection. But our ciel also cares for them. For example Agni and now Snake. If this goes on won't our ciel be broken?

Yes, but Sebastian didn't plan for them to die? I know Sebastian is a bastard but he doesn't want that lol

I think it's weird how you're blaming everything on Sebastian like he can control everything going on around him...

If this is true then Sebastian would have let Baldroy die but he didn't because Baldroy still has a job to do, protect the young master. Sebastian didn't hire a quitter!

I'm not blaming on Sebastian if anyone dies. Yes, just like you said he can't control everything. But ultimately what Sebastian wants is for our ciel to break or something (I am still not sure) so that our ciel's soul will become more delicious to be consumed.

I think that what sebastian wants is for ciel to get his revenge so he can take his soul as said in the contract. If he wanted a broken soul he would have make sure to break ciel. If you remember, in cp 94, when ciel lost his memories and didn't want to do anything sebastian was going to eat his soul because he abandoned his revenge and before he was going to eat his soul he said "it's not was I was hoping for but it might fill me a little", which means his soul will be more delicious if ciel will fulfill the contract and get his revenge. Also, the title of cp 95 Is "an unsatisfying dinner"

Um no, Sebastian doesn't want Ciel to mentally break and I don't think souls get more flavorful lol

If you read chapter 63, Sebastian said when our ciel gets his crown decorated with despair. Sebastian wants our ciel to get his revenge and it will be more delicious when at that time he will be left with nothing. Everyone who he fought alongside being dead leaving him alone again. Anyways that's my prediction.

Sebastian wouldn't let any of them die when they have a job to do and Sebastian doesn't want to leave him left with nothing. Stop talking nonsense...

Ok, l rest my case. Anyways like I said it's my prediction not the absolute truth. Let's agree to disagree ┑(￣Д ￣)┍

Sebastian wouldn't have hired them if that's his main goal lol

just ignore the person replying to you, they're always a major troll when they disagree w anyone's pov

Yeah, I thought it would be a good discussion for once. But when there's no conclusive input, I just gave up. Thanks for the advice though ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ﾉ~

Where can i read the novel? Is it all translated to english?

In Tumblr SF translation. You need to DM them

I like the manwhaaaaaa moreeeee