Katkit's Manga

Story was alright, lots of comments saying it was bad or that the pacing was off, honestly I've seen worse. Art was great, characters were alright and overall readability was not bad. A high 7/10 from me, probably won't read again though. Read 2025 April

Honestly, got a little confusing but very good story in the end. Loved the art, loved the characters, liked the archs and each of the character growths, and I liked that the second male lead finally got an ending that made sense :) though I feel bad for him. 10/10 maybe read again. Wish there were more afterwards about the kids. Last read 2025 Apr

Pretty alright, had so.e real good emotional portrayal and I enjoyed the pacing. Lacked for only a better ending for the side characters, felt like they were left behind or something. The father-daughter dynamic was good, though I'm confused that the father was not more upset that the daughter couldn't save her mother this time around when she told him about the multiple rewinds. Felt like story didn't wrap up the rewind shenanigans with Sylvain since he could only rewind with her....death?? So confused. Anyways, great art, good story, decent characters, 8/10 :) last read 2025 Apr

Pretty good story! Fast paced in some areas and slow paced in others but overall good story. Enjoyed how Aila finally figured out that there was never a side character or story book ending that needed to happen, just that there was differences from her first life to her third. 8/10 maybe read again but maybe not as I had to take a break mid way. Last read 4-19-2025

Pretty good. Didn't see too many plot holes and even if the translators weren't the best it was readable and made sense. Liked MC, liked the ML, liked the supporting cast of characters and overall the story was well done. Not super long and had a clear ending with some afterward stories. 9/10 could read again sometime.
Last read 2025 March

So sloppy, the characters are so dumb but I wanted to finish the story ;-; I regret. Story came together in the end, but it was so sloppy with how the characters interacted and didn't explain to each other what they meant and how the words were so easy but they just didn't say it for dramas sake I was so frustrated. Do not read again. 4/10. Only because the art was alright, and the story finally gave up the ghost and completed but yeah. Chapters 40-70 were useless drivel my God.

Very fun! Loved the characters and the redemption archs and the passion and also the convenience of some of the scenes to really make this story work. I'm glad the main characters got together in the end, and I guess I'm happy the one Duke guy repented for his sins and went off to be exciled. 10/10 story made sense and had a complete ending, and great characters to boot. Helps that it wasn't too long either, finished it in 24 hours. Art was great, I noticed the change in art, but it was still alright by the end. Overall a great read.