Ayo why this gem has only 9.0 rating, THIS SHI FIRE!! I love FL she is such a baddie, ML is a green forest who respects and supports FL without treating her like damsel in distress, trash ex-husband is suffering so satisfying to read, and the manhwa is so unserious at times makes me laugh a lot at times lol 10/10 recommend it a lot <3
who's ml. what's the color of hair and eyes?
You really know how to make me cry
When you gimme those ocean eyesss
And black hair
Ugh why the temple is always an evil bitch, like I get it in real history religious institutions always used their power to control masses, but at least in fictional world let us have temples who work for a good cause
Bro author is trying so hard to make it like BJ Alex, but it’s gonna flop hard I think. Because first of all, Alex was WAY FUCKING LESS TOXIC than this horsey. He was not a narcissist either and had empathy and common sense. So that’s why, him realizing his mistakes, trying to redeem himself and asking for forgiveness was not out of character and made sense. And I personally, and I think a lot of people also ate that redemption arc up, because he was genuinely regretting his actions and was chasing after Dong Gyun like a dog lol
Second of all, Dong Gyun was also wayyy less traumatized and mentally wounded compared to our poor baby Kim Dan. Obviously I’m not undermining his past traumas (before Alex), but like at least he had friends, more stable life, and he had much more self-respect. So that’s why, when he finally accepted he was not treated well and said fuck off to Alex, it was again, not out of character and made sense. But here, I feel like Kim Dan in season 1 vs 2 are not consistent. He never accepted that he was treated like shit. Even in birthday card, he wrote about how he can finally breathe near this horsey (oh boy), and how he is happy now. Shit, even when he left, he never acknowledged that Jaekyung was being ass not trusting him, and said that it was his own mistake, and that he was not worthy being his physician. So like, him suddenly saying out of nowhere that Jaekyung always wanted his body and never respected him as a person feels kinda out of character to me, because unlike in BJ Alex where Dong Gyun slowly realizes the mistreatment, here such unfolding was never built-up before, unless he visited a therapist behind the scenes. To me, it feels like author is trying a bit hard to push the same BJ Alex scenario here as well, but it feels so out-of-character for both of them. At this point, they don’t need romance; they need therapy. Like asap
I think Dan is slowly realizing he was treated badly. In previous chapters there were concrete flashbacks and in this chapter too. The only reason he wants to have sex with JK iis to end everything with him as soon as possible...
It's sad he was forced to end it this way, next chapter won't be easy to read..
I really like how ML and FL converse about casual things and even deep topics like their ambitions, expectations from a relationship & romantic partner etc. like this was such a breath of fresh air. In almost majority of shoujo manhwas, MLs and FLs never have proper talks, so their emotional connection always felt shallow to me.
On the other side, one thing I think doesn’t really make sense is that how they portray that the duke’s family is one of the strongest and respected one in the empire etc., but them bitches disrespect his sister and his fiancee so casually. Like even though this takes place in a very misogynistic world, there is still a hierarchy, so if you disrespect a lady of a prominent house, you basically disrespect that house itself. Bro even that aside, a mere marquis technically insults the empress, mother of the empire in front of everyone in the imperial court, and the emperor sits there like
Exactly what I was thinking!! like he shouldn't have been able to get away with insulting a Duke's fiance let alone the EMPRESS??? Like that made no sense.
Okay I just started reading so can’t say anything about the plot yet, BUT FINALLY AN ML WITH NO RED EYES & BLACK HAIR thank god my eyes have been blessed with more original ML aesthetics, like yes purple hair gimme that
Im on ch6 and please tell me whether FL’s emotional intelligence gets at least closer to her real age, because I can’t believe a grown woman is picking up a fight with a 8 years old child (Cedric) just because he called her ugly, and throws tantrums because her sister doesn’t give her tarts lol I’m cringing reading about it, like sis you’re 20 please
As you read the following chapters, you will be irritated more (this is how i felt before). Yes she did grown a lot but still can't sort out her own emotions. She keep thinking she's just a substitute of the real "Lili" that's why she keeps pushing away people.
ch 59 and I think I'm dropping. Don't get me wrong it's not bad, it's just I think I'm tired of reading manhwas where FL is the one who always solves things and all the other characters are there for just decoration. I think it's not only this manhwa, in general, in iseaki manhwas it's always FL versus the rest of the world, but I wanna see others being involved in matters too. As someone else said, the relationships she developed with others are also shallow and one dimensional; I get that she has trauma from her past life, but still, I would rather prefer the story digging deeper into that trauma of hers and showing how she recovers and slowly learns to build deeper connections with others and to trust and rely on others more. Maybe it will happen later in the story, but for now, it doesn't seem the story goes somewhere near there, it's just been the continuous cycle of death attacks on FL and FL being big brain and solving them. Atp it got boring for me since there is no revelation about anything at all, about who the FL actually is, what happened to og Charl and what was the relationship between her and ML (only hints to their certain interactions that wasn't in novel), who is the villain and what their motives are etc etc. And on top of that, author adds more and more new "mysteries" without clearing anything so maybe the story will get more interesting if more clearance is provided idk for now it's just the same things being repeated in different forms.
Also, I really like the ML and wish his story would be explored more. He has this usual being smart, powerful etc. ML buffs but on top of that, he has such a sweet and caring personality, and is very respectful and supportive towards FL, not your usual possessive "You're mine, my object" ahh ML. He is a whole green forest <3 and I hope he gets more depth into his story and character
It's been some time since I read this; does Carcel also know about their past lives? and if so, Does Ines know that he knows too? Also he was taking something not to have a kid, what about it? Gimme spoilers pls ^^
Answer
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1. Carcel received some memories. They’re just a few right now. He knows Ines was with two other men in the past two lives. He also knows Ines was always indifferent to him and never chose him. That’s why he wondered why she chose him this time. He will figure out the answers soon when he receives more memories. Among those memories, he will also discover a HUGE revelation.
2. Ines doesn’t know that he knows. She will find out eventually when she confesses first that in a past life she was married to the crown prince. Then as the story progresses until the end, she finds out he knows about everything. So both of them are true confidants. They only have one secret between them which Carcel finds painful to talk about and he doesn’t want to burden her with that memory. Only, Ines does know about that memory and wishes he would talk about it.
3. He stopped taking contraceptives during their hunting trip. Since he realized it was the first time Ines talked sincerely about having a child with him. He didn’t want to betray that sincerity so he stopped taking it.
u're amazing thank uu <33
Thank you for this!
Thanks for these wonderful spoilers, can u let me know what are these huge revelation and painful memory Carcel finds hard to talk about?
Huge Spoiler
Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler Huge Spoiler
1. Carcel is Ines’s original husband. There’s a timeline that exists before the two previous timelines
2. Carcel gets the full memory of the original timeline later and Ines would often ask him to tell her about it and he talks about it like a fairy tale. However, he would never talk about their children who died. When they go back to Esposa to give birth to their third child in this final timeline, both of them recall the death of their first child in the original timeline and Carcel even reacts a certain way and Ines knows it’s because he remembers the death of their 9 months old son in the original timeline. He behaves even more protective of her in Esposa because of this. The irony is, both their original first born and the third child she gives birth to in this final timeline look exactly like Carcel. They’re also the only two of their sons who were born in Esposa. All their other children were born in Calztela including a little girl in the original timeline. Even to the end of the story, both think about their original timeline children but never talk about them to each other. Carcel thinks this memory is his to bear since their three children from the original timeline died.
Got it, thank you for taking the time to answer :)
On everyone’s soul but mine JK will become a good man
We all dying