data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b5fd7/b5fd7b692c6e3a8c77039c9a82621d2dd1e87e0b" alt=""
But in last life, the duke didn't kill Luca which made him become the successor and was able to use the wishing cup. Isn't that means the duke's fear isn't about the wishing cup will be used? Maybe it is more like to prevent the wrongness become the reality because of the wishing cup. The duke either put his trust on Luca ( so he didn't kill him) or he just decided to fuck it all off and let everything happen, happened.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b5fd7/b5fd7b692c6e3a8c77039c9a82621d2dd1e87e0b" alt=""
"For once... You used to treat me like I didn't even exist. So why you chose me now"
Gaaahhhh I'm savoring this pain!! My heart bleed but I feel content.
Through the requited love (1st timeline), through the unrequited (2nd & 3rd timeline), no matter if it is happiness or pain, he loves Ines all the time. Doing that much, he still feels he is undeserved for her.
Carcel is one of the few male lead that deserved to be the male lead, not just because the universe crowned him for it.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b5fd7/b5fd7b692c6e3a8c77039c9a82621d2dd1e87e0b" alt=""
It will never trouble Camilla if she can't be the only daughter in the dukedom. She can set herself free and she won't be worry of suffering. She only stays for the filial piety to the person who've raised her, the duke. She only stays to complete the mission from Rania's true soul and protect the dukedom from that wild-wench of a soul who took over Rania's body.
I read this because a youtuber who's channel reviewed manhwas keep repeating how she loves this series. I judge the work by the title, thinking this will be another cliche where every characters are the fool for the heroine and the plots just revolving for her.
Oh how wrong I was.
Everything happen here is just how real people will do. No excessive hatred, no suddenly falling in love for the heroine, no ridiculous reasons just to live up the heroine's character, no that cliche cliche.
while me reading hoping it would be the cliche bc i was tired of reading serious stuff, but here we are. lol