Agathe's Manga

39 soso plot holes are gigantic
I don’t get why authors feel the need to make characters that have so many life experiences that they would need more than one lifetime to get them all
The MC, probably being in her late 20 (?) was a slave working in the mines, then a gladiator (?) , then a mercenary with a slave spell holding her (??) , then became a swordsmaster (!). but she’s also a mage (!!) and a high level one enough to teach the soon to be tower master (!?!)
As if not enough, she knows the inside out of the bank of another country, where to find the top secret information guild (yes, vstill another country), she also knows magic herbs and poison, and lets jot forget the law of that very same foreign country, knows etiquette , is politically savvy, etc?
I probably forgot some bit, but she might hold a small record there

Then come te complicated pact with the demon that doesn’t make sense : obviously she, herself, never made the pact, souls are what supposed to matter there and for once, hers is not involved, second, the body owner obviously already paid ( she died , so much for soul collusion )
That contract brings us a system screen and she’s not freaking out ?
The contract is about choosing a husband and bind ito herself, the devil’s way, in a meager harem
Then of course, the very predictable trio is pretty miserable
Two out of three are pinning for her previous incarnation : one would readily jump on board, but she doesn’t want, the second she dread , but is the obvious end game ( the prince, of course . But for ´now, she set her goal on the one guy who sees her like a kid
Duh
Then you could also wonder about her being the missing sister … every thing is so predictable

59
Long violent fights, but interesting story
Once again the MC can not be a hero, although he wants to be kind
It’s strange because, all in all, it’s descring heroes as people who would be dumb enough to make useless sacrifices of their lifes, cannot see the bigger scale oof things and would not make a sacrifice for the big picture
Our MC then would be a « cynical » hero, or a « hero with a brain « (?) , but not a hero
Well he does have a big vengeful bone, but vengeful heroes are a thing too
In any case, it’s pretty fun and interesting
Honestly the fighting parts are too long for my taste, but the whole regression thing with multiple pasts lives is interesting

29
Too much child abuse as background
The story where family members have to kill each other to be the strongest is really sick
But if you leave it out, it’s quite entertaining

15
Tale of miserable children and their evil selfish father trying to use them
The MC is a writer facing the consequences of the mistreatment she wrote of as a background and indeed child neglect or abuse should not be used so freely to tell stories
Sadly miscommunication and hidden truths seems to be a baase of the story
Beautiful art

31
The good: it’s fun, evil food from hell giving super painful bonuses , huge misunderstandings about bad food loves, it works pretty well
The bad : another rebirth + dungeon + op + solo self cntered MC - of course, to be that oblivious to others it was expected, but in some place you have a kingly attitude ( spend all your retirement money on a random item, because i want itvas a nutcracker ?), and the super self centered attitude ( voh ? Bad guys killing innocent people … their technique is interesting, let’s observe more ) - ok it’s congruent with the demn martial artists king thing, but it’s still rotten
The guy isca monster, he can effortlessly bring down the villains but won’t if it doesn’t concern or benefit him ?
Well it stinks
I understand one might question if super powered beings have to go out of their way to help others in situations, no one else can do - that is already a question bringing lots of moral point to be debated
But here, it’s not like going out of his way to: he is just there
Selfishness brought to new highs seems to be on the rise : but you know what, even 6 months old babies are shocked when shown simulation where pro social interaction are missing : watching people pain without blinking is not normal or better : it’s a mental disease

32
Thre major fglaw is to namr constrllzion after earth zodiac in a forreign world
But th rest is pretty fun
Despite being more of a head first character, the MC doesn’t feel too calculting or too cold, but more like exceptionally cautious in circumstances that deserve that much
On top of that she is rather righteous, doing things right and doing the right thing without the ridiculous addition of selfish motivations
She has a quasi OP ability being able to interact (use ?) multiple treasures, but as she is super weak, lacking strength and stamina, she can only use this sparingly. Also it’s an anormality that could put her in danger.
At the end of the day, it makes a rather well rounded character carrying a story with a good pace, variety and many more questions to answer
Good entertainment

37
The child feels like a child, not like an adult in a child suit and this is refreshing
The sisters are great, they are very different and all are independent women
The rest, meh, dukes and emperors, battle crazed men, bleh
But overall cuteness is overloaded and it is nice it feels well written, with a lot of characters who actually do make sense.

39
Transmigration, plus soap opera vibes, a possible curse or something while bring in modern time
It’s refreshing and feels like a change from many rofan

30
Op knows it all reborn , that is usually tiresome, at least this one has a strongly cooperative mindset

23
Strange one
Good pace
The shut in abilities however are double edged in my book
I don’t like the « vassal «  concept, nor the idea that the MC is using people like tools he could discard
Thankfully the character is sane and not abusive at all, but the bias in the relationship is both too strong and too unnatural- the money part is plain weird too
The good thing is that he is also dependent on people and their trust in him matters a lot. That, and the fact that he’s trapped in a small space gives balance to a bunch of OP powers. In the end, he has some sort of managerial function ?
Nonetheless there are a bunch of nice characters , as long as it doesn’t feel like the MC is toying with them, it could be really entertaining