Puppyboy Agend-er June 6, 2025 4:04 am

I want... I WANT SOME MILK.

Puppyboy Agend-er May 24, 2025 2:21 am

Just to be safe lol
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

'Cause why did I see his ass crying and bowing at the alter of the grandmother that basically whored him out in the very next chapter??

Naw. Naw naw naw.

Ya'll can pity him, but atp he really is just dumb af. I've only ever felt this way about a character a handful of times, and I've read over 5,000 yaoi/bl series atp so that's saying A LOT.

I thought this was gonna be some sort of horror psychological thriller, but instead I wanna strangle Saha and tell Heesu to clarify what actually happened the night Heetae died just so Saha can stop acting like the ultimate victim in all this. I felt so bad for him being put in that situation with Heetae 'cause he was actually being abused, but now Saha is basically ditching the man he got to fall in love with him AND cover his potential crimes just 'cause his ass is delusional.

I swear to God the reveal for Heetae's murder better be fucking worth this migraine.

    Hiddensecrets May 24, 2025 5:46 am

    Well I never meet an uke whose wise when it comes into decision they always make the dumbest and stupid things.

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 28, 2025 10:56 pm
    Well I never meet an uke whose wise when it comes into decision they always make the dumbest and stupid things. Hiddensecrets

    Funnily enough this isn't always so lol

    Like, yeah, they aren't omnipotent and sometimes it's needed for driving the plot, but Saha is blatantly doing things to make his life worse now.

    After reading a bit if the raws I feel like I shouldn't even continue to read this shit anymore. I keep dropping my rating lower and lower 'cause I feel like the writer is trying to force me to feel bad for Saha when really I just wanna smack the shit out of him.

Puppyboy Agend-er May 20, 2025 7:53 pm

No room for someone else to weasel in.

They complete the missing pieces in one another so perfectly. They give each other the confidence but also the love that the other has never had.

Puppyboy Agend-er May 18, 2025 1:01 am

He's asking 'cause one version of Huimin was so broken and disgusted with Iheon he died and created a whole alternate timeline for them.

Then there's the alternate timeline Huimin that was never even allowed to consider a mutual love with Iheon to the point the world stopped when Iheon tried to confess.

Then we have the current Huimin who believed he was isekai'd the entire time and that himself and the Huimin from "Silence" were two different entities till recently. He's also the only version of Huimin that even dared to fight back and work things out with Iheon on equal footing. Granted, part of this was possible due to Iheon trying to do things differently this time around, but Huimin's current personality is still a 180 from the first one. Despite still having the aversion to alpha pheromones, he doesn't cower away or think all alphas are just rapists. Somewhere down the line he genuinely wanted to heal so him and Iheon could actually fall in love and be happy.

Right now Iheon is terrified. He's formed a one-sided dependency on Huimin's pheromones and being away from him is literally killing him. He's panicked 'cause Huimin now remembers that all three versions of him are real and currently a part of him so in Iheon's mind Huimin is going to leave him again. 'Cause why wouldn't he? Iheon was the main source of Huimin's pain and eventual demise their first time around. Of course Huimin would have every right and reason to runaway and never return to Iheon.

This is them meeting and confirming what is going on. No one knows aside from Huimin and us readers what is going on in Huimin's head.

Ya'll are just too dumb or unwilling to actually think for a second to realize *why* Iheon asked that question first. I don't even know why I bother trying to explain shit anymore.

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 18, 2025 1:05 am

    Tl:dr 'cause some of ya'll apparently can't read more than a few sentences but can read 60+ chapters of gay porn for some reason;

    Iheon just wants to clarify if whether the current Huimin is still "alive" or if one of the other two has resurfaced due to current Huimin learning about the alternate timelines. The other two timelines were dead ends so he's terrified that, once again, Huimin is going to die.

    urmom May 18, 2025 1:10 am
    Tl:dr 'cause some of ya'll apparently can't read more than a few sentences but can read 60+ chapters of gay porn for some reason;Iheon just wants to clarify if whether the current Huimin is still "alive" or if ... Puppyboy Agend-er

    YES PLEASE, I'VE BEEN DYING TO EXPLAIN THIS

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 18, 2025 1:31 am
    YES PLEASE, I'VE BEEN DYING TO EXPLAIN THIS urmom

    I apparently live to passive-aggressively explain BL plots in autistic detail lol

    Woozi25 May 18, 2025 2:02 am

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 18, 2025 3:14 am

    I am so unbearably exhausted. The bar is in hell lol

Puppyboy Agend-er May 16, 2025 8:08 pm

'Cause I'm just annoyed atp lol

Like, Saha wanted to get away from Heetae and used Heesu, to a degree, to do this. He gave him pills he had no idea what they were just 'cause he wanted to have sex with Heesu behind everyone's backs.

He confesses his love to Heesu, Heetae is murdered and we don't know for certain who did it, and now Saha wants to play switch-up on Heesu?

The only thing keeping me seated is my damned curiosity as to who or how Heetae died. I don't even blame Heesu for not clearing anything up 'cause Saha can't even handle anything mildly distressing and never has been able to.

Now he's wanting to run back to the family that deserted and sold him off?? Like, fuck your sister and grandma!! If your sister cared she would've taken off with you or done something about your grandma. And you think your grandma is just gonna be ok with you returning after your charge died?? He's so fucking stupid it hurts.

And I hate when series make me sympathize with someone who uses physical force, but I feel more upset for Heesu rn 'cause he fell for Saha's weepy confessions and is now being made out to be a monster.

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 16, 2025 8:13 pm

    And do NOT get me started on Saha saying shit just to piss off and hurt Heesu.

    Like, why would you even lie about having sex with a man that was abusing you like a maniac in front of the man who is clearly in love with you?????? Is his head full of rocks or some shit?

    I know for a fact that Heesu is covering shit up for his and Saha's sake 'cause it's almost too coincidental that all these events are happening at the same time.

    I'm just tired of trying to be manipulated into feeling bad for Saha when he's just stupid.

Puppyboy Agend-er May 11, 2025 2:25 am

At the people thinking this wouldn't somehow become more fucked up given the whole premise of the series lol

Like, yes, they apparently have a "happy end", but the ending is just that. The whole fucking journey has been nothing but one long psychotic roller coaster lol even if they do get a "happy end" is it really that? After all the trauma, abuse, stalking, toxic dependency, drug abuse and idolizing is it really a "happy" end lol

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 11, 2025 2:29 am

    "What was I expecting" "why won't he get him help" "this is just disgusting"--

    Have you been reading with your eyes closed? I specifically picked this up 'CAUSE it's fucked up and unapologetically so. We been knowing since ch1 that this was gonna be all kinds of toxic. So why are we now expecting the current events to be resolved within a chapter so they can "live happily ever after" lol

    Meee May 11, 2025 3:38 am
    "What was I expecting" "why won't he get him help" "this is just disgusting"--Have you been reading with your eyes closed? I specifically picked this up 'CAUSE it's fucked up and unapologetically so. We been kn... Puppyboy Agend-er

    Okay well that’s “good” for u that you picked it up for that but others maybe didn’t know or heard different about the story considering it’s pretty popular on Pinterest yet many narratives of the story are going in different directions.

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 11, 2025 4:38 pm
    Okay well that’s “good” for u that you picked it up for that but others maybe didn’t know or heard different about the story considering it’s pretty popular on Pinterest yet many narratives of the sto... Meee

    If I started a series, saw how it was going in a direction I didn't like within the first couple of chapters I would promptly drop it.

    To continue to subject yourself to something that could last for 30-200 chapters is nothing but sheer lunacy and I'm tired of ya'll making excuses for it.

    If you were eating something that tasted disgusting to you would you continue to eat it and cry the entire time or would you stop and simply eat something else more enjoyable??

    Meee May 11, 2025 8:21 pm
    If I started a series, saw how it was going in a direction I didn't like within the first couple of chapters I would promptly drop it.To continue to subject yourself to something that could last for 30-200 chap... Puppyboy Agend-er

    that comparison between eating and reading something needs to stop that’s just stupid and not at all the same☠ and like i said before they might’ve heard something different somewhere else such as “it’ll get better” when u hear things like that about something it makes u want to get to that point until u can’t take anymore and just drop it so it’s not “excuses” it’s just how the brain works.

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 12, 2025 12:15 am
    that comparison between eating and reading something needs to stop that’s just stupid and not at all the same☠ and like i said before they might’ve heard something different somewhere else such as “it�... Meee

    No, it's not a bad example 'cause it dumbs it down to a simpler point for you people to digest. But here's one that is closer to the same medium as manga/hua/hwa; if you're watching a show or anime series for about 5-10 episodes but you still don't like it or it just isn't your cup of tea would you still watch it? Would you potentially waste what lil time you have left on this planet subjecting yourself to something you can't stomach or bores you?

    I can't stand live action chick flicks or romcoms. If I started a series only to realize it's one of these things I'd stop and go find something else I'll actually enjoy.

    You guys will read something for 30+ chapters whining and bellyaching the whole time that everything is disgusting or horrible or how you wish the mc would end up with the soyboy second ml. Ya'll do this and think it's some sort of God given right that those around you, who are actually enjoying the material for what it is, just put up with your incessant whining.

    And lord forbid anyone suggest you move on to another series for your own sanity. Then all of a sudden it's a personal attack and "everyone has their right to an opinion." Well, newsflash, opinions are like assholes; everyone has one but most of the time they're best kept to yourself.

    Meee May 12, 2025 6:52 pm
    No, it's not a bad example 'cause it dumbs it down to a simpler point for you people to digest. But here's one that is closer to the same medium as manga/hua/hwa; if you're watching a show or anime series for a... Puppyboy Agend-er

    it is though, one u try a food u don’t like you can see the ending in that very moment so u can automatically choose to quit because there’s no hope in it getting better. with shows and books it’s completely different, they change nearly all the time and may suprise you. there can be moments that just before you’re about to drop it something sucks you back in making you want to continue. people are allowed to read things they don’t like that’s literally how you figure out if you like something or not. if you don’t like the “whining” and peoples opinions then you can simply not read comments where it’s ALL about opinions good or bad. Nobody has to keep their opinion to themselves just because you don’t like seeing it. if you don’t like seeing them then stop reading them. it’s better to let your opinions out on small stuff like this instead of just holding it all in it’s not actually affecting anyone and if it is affecting you today then oh well you’ll be fine the next day this is the internet you can get off anytime.

Puppyboy Agend-er May 7, 2025 4:27 am

Started reading this back in 2019 and stopped around chapter 20.

Years later I have returned to binge read all 191 current chapters in one sitting and have completed this task.

I'm fucking nuts.

    evilpeach May 7, 2025 7:10 am

    I don't think you're nuts lol
    I've had this on my to read list since 2022, and I might just binge it now all in one go

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 7, 2025 3:24 pm
    I don't think you're nuts lolI've had this on my to read list since 2022, and I might just binge it now all in one go evilpeach

    Yeah I had started it at 2 am Tuesday morning and finished it arooooound 11:30 pm Tuesday night lol

    I kept putting it off for some reason, but had forgotten why so I was just like "fuck it, nothing else is interesting to me right now."

    Now I've got a shipment for the hardcover versions of vol. 1 & 2 coming in this weekend--

Puppyboy Agend-er May 1, 2025 1:36 am

Refusing to read the officials 'cause all I hear is Kratos's voice saying "boy" any time CY says it.

Can we just go back to using pup/puppers?

... totally not biased btw lol

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 1, 2025 1:37 am

    It sucks 'cause originally I'd think of Tyki Mikk from d.gm since he calls Allen "boy" any chance he gets, but God of War has been a more recent memory so now I just fucking hear Kratos OTL

    Doppye May 1, 2025 12:05 pm

    I thought of that too ! But honestly it's just a cute pet name address.

    When you have a pet you don't always address them by their name, you'd sat "boy" or "girl". Even if their human, they're still animals. Like when someone says "come'er boy!" Or "baby boy" or "my boy" to their pet. It's not really weird or anything.

    Puppyboy Agend-er May 2, 2025 2:47 am
    I thought of that too ! But honestly it's just a cute pet name address. When you have a pet you don't always address them by their name, you'd sat "boy" or "girl". Even if their human, they're still animals. Li... Doppye

    I mean, calling something a gold boy/girl isn't the same as referring to them as just boy lol

    Like, I call my cats kitty baby and kitty mama or my old lady cat or rotten child. I don't refer to them as just girls lol even when I had my old man dog I made up cute nicknames like boogabear ((his name was Bear)) or grandpa since he was old af.

    We don't even refer to my mom's 7 month old puppy as girl. We call her baby, pupper or Sug since her name is Sugar lol it just feels out of place.

    Like, imagine if the person you were dating just called you boy/girl all the time. It's not endearing in the least lol

Puppyboy Agend-er April 26, 2025 1:13 am

*watching ya'll crash out in the comment section*

Puppyboy Agend-er April 22, 2025 9:27 pm

To force Jaekyung and Kim Dan to hug it out for two whole months lol

Either way, hope the surgery goes well and we get to successfully return to our regularly scheduled sPain.

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.