LoserLover's Topics (129)

Crap I meant to upvote

we also now know that ines current life is actually her 4th life not 3rd. She had a life where she was with carcel before the life she was with oscar but she can’t remember that life because she probably died before her fated time so she was allowed to repeat her life thus leading to her life with oscar.

Then, in her life with oscar she killed herself, which allowed her to keep her memories when she started the life with emiliano. She also killed herself in the life with emiliano which is how she was able to keep her memories from that life now in her 4th life

emiliano was able to keep his memories because he died before his fated time when luciano killed him so he made a wish to keep his memories in this life that he gets to repeat instead of having them erased

i think carcel is able to recall memories from all the past lives because god is helping him but i’m probably wrong lol

And i genuinely have no idea how oscar has all the memories of their past lives the only explanation i can think of is he also lolled himself in those lives or he did the same thing emiliano did and made a wish to keep his memories

I HAVE NOT READ THE NOVEL so this is just stuff from the manhwa until here so i might be wrong obviously. This is mostly for myself coz ik im gonna get confused

ALSO ALSO anastasio the apostle has appeared in the story i think it was in chapter 95 he was the guy with the long hair ines recognised and confronted on the street and when she confronted him she saw flashbacks from all her past lives when he was there (1st life - he was a priest praying for her on her deathbed. 2nd life - he was executed for being a protestant priest i think. 3rd life - he was the priest that officiated ines and emilianos wedding. 4th life - ines saw him on the street)

In which chapter her life with carcel before the life she was with oscar apers?

In which chapter her life with carcel before the life she was with oscar apears?

Wow. Thank you for explaining that <333

I think, it was in the beginning, in the first chapter maybe(?) but it's only a glimpse tho so you might not realize it.

The glimpses of her first life with Carcel were in ch7 when she was seducing him and the last panels of ch 95 and first 22 pages of ch 96.

It's mad impressive how much information you have gathered for simply reading the manhwa and without the novels since it's quite vague in the manhwa, as well as how the information you've provided is probably close to accurate

Maybe he killed himself after Innes first death?

Yeah, but I think he killed himself before Ines had a chance to die which is why neither her nor Carsel remembers the first life and would make sense as to why he chose Ines. Oscar from what we know seems to be really jealous of Carsel including his marriage to Ines and it would make sense why they didn't remember the previous life like Oscar seems to bang on about because they never even died to make a wish just like everyone other person in the manga. So Oscar is infatuated with Ines and Jealous of Carsel, Carsel and Ines get married and his jealousy is further heightened, then somewhere along the line Oscar probably starts falling in the eyes of the nobles and Carsel continues to rise as with his perfect marriage further drowning Oscar and then he takes his own life. Which I think would fit into the nnarrative quite well.

Thanksss! I reread those chapters. 96 felt like her life with Carcel was the third one, 'cause she says it’s the first time she died in a bed. But in 7, I couldn’t find anything about past lives — for me it just seemed like his imagination, since he was totally crazy for her haha.

In ep6. The dream scene is taken from the first life. I mixed up the chapters.

"ik they’re just drawings and characters from a story but their stories came from somewhere and they deserve better"
I like that, a lot