
Carcel has loved Ines in all 4 of his lives and I say 4 because him and Ines regressed 4 times.
No spoiler warning because fuck all of you. And yes this is for all the bitches who are whining about a cheating ML. This was intentionally done by ines and after their marroage, he has never cheated on her again.
In the very first timeline, him and Ines are originally married. But Carcel died in war and Ines died to sickness right after. This is the only timeline Ines does not remember.
The second timeline the prince had something to do with them regressing. Him and Ines got married. Then he cheated on her multiple times and gave her std and she died. Carcel silently loved her and supported her in the sidelines but he could not do anything more because she was the king's wife. You have no idea what this man went through. But yeah he did love her. I don't remember what happened to him after.
The third life Ines had the chance to turn things around so she used the painter to get out of her situation. She never loved him tho. But she did immensely pity him because she dragged him into the situation. All the while Carcel helped her through it, even down to her escape . Because the king was after her and wanted to lock her up. Ines' hot brother also somehow helped and don't misunderstand him because the man is GOOD. Also Carcel loved her in this timeline even if she didn't love him back.
Now timeline 2 & 3 Ines remembers. Carcel I think remembers later on. They also have 3 kids together and they have lots of sex.
No, Carcel had never cheated after marriage. Ines also planned it out for him. And yes he had loved her ever since their first life.
Correct me if I'm wrong as this is just based on memory from when I read the novel + spoilers.
Now everyone who hates Carcel SHUT THE FUCK UP.

Might wanna check yourself before clocking other people.
Policing comments? Where did I say that? If people are going to be loud about their opinions I am going to be as well.
The point of this entire rant is to call out people who ruin other people's reading experience simply because they did not read the plot or tags.
I myself did not like the fact Carcel cheated. I avoided this manhwa for so long because of this. Did I throw a bitch fit? No. Instead I went on my merry day and found other manhwas to read.
I only got around reading this because of the reviews. I didn't argue with people who actually read the manhwa.
Bottomline is: I minded my own fucking business. Unless I finished the manhwa or understood what the story the author/artist is trying to put out I don't criticize.
So get off my dick and shove a cucumber up your ass.

She is so terribly written omfg.
She has a really solid backstory. But the way she acts like a kid is pissing me off.
Like I get wanting to take revenge and all but even for her coming after the emperor's descendants who had NOTHING TO DO WITH IT is pretty low.
It's no different from an adult beefing with a child. Woman you are centuries years old. Maybe act like it????
Maybe if she was written like Roxanna or the villainess from one within the villainess I vould understand. But bro she just reminds me of those weak ass villainess mcs.
I'm willing to bet that when she discovers the truth about the emperor she goes all cry cry l

It is pretty realistic to be honest.
You can see many cases where a crime happened 20-40 years ago and the victim or there family kill the children and grandchildren just because they think criminals descendants shouldn't be living happily.
If you research about this kind psychological situation, you will know how injustice can make human lose all the reasoning.

Being realistic does not constitute good writing.
You can be a villainess and still have good writing. Anetta just looks pathetic here. She's grasping at straws.
Maybe if Anetta had acknowledged that what she is doing is unreasonable. Or make her seem crazy instead of desperate.
Her character is flat and lacking idk what to tell you

She has a good backstory. A solid ass foundation for her to act the way she does.
But her character is just terrible. I usually like my villains unjustifiable and just evil for the sake of evil. Or something like once they go down the path of darkness they don't look back. Backstory and all.
Anetta is ALMOST the same. Because she had everything she needed. But no instead she acts like a kid despite the trauma she went through. She doesn't act like a real villainess but a villainess who thinks she is the main character.
I wouldn't read her manhwa if she was an mc. She's far too weak of a character and wussy.
So no, her character writing is weak. Then again, a lot of the characters here have very weak writing.
I really regret picking this up again I was hoping it would get better ugh

She acts like a child/immature because she isnt rational. Roxanna is a cool headed and coniving character, while annetta is purely driven by blind rage.
She definitely could be used better, but i think her immaturity adds to her character, shes a lousy hypocrite who blames the emperor and doesn't realise anything shes done wrong. She's annoying but she's strong. She acts impulsively because she truly believes she's the stongest.
I really hope she doesn't cry when the truth is revealed. And i genuinely wish for her to get stabbed.
Been looking for a uke just as funny and delusional as punch drunk love and this did NOT disappoint!