
Okay guys small spoilers I got this off someone else so correct me if I’m wrong :p
The man we just saw is her father, he lost his memories so he doesn’t know shes his daughter or he didn’t know I can’t remember. Apparently he was looking at her because of her ring. its an heirloom of his family’s so he was surprised to see her wearing it. Also once he found out she’s his daughter he wanted her to stay with him ect but she didn’t want to so she went back home. No he’s not the father of her brother too, he’s just her father. The second oldest brother dad was a mage who died. Also apparently the FL mom remained three times. One with the guy we saw, then the mage and now the duke. From what I heard she only loved her first husband.

TBH I don’t think the top is overreacting like y’all are saying. Let’s be honest if you guys found out ur lover didn’t like u in the beginning and just used u for his writing wouldn’t you’ve been hurt and heartbroken regardless, if now he has feelings for u?
I understand that the bottom has feelings for the top now but y’all gotta understand the top has been through things and now after all that finding out the man he loved used him in the beginning of their relationship. Obviously he’s gonna be hurt and break up with him. And obviously he lost trust in the bottom and can’t trust his word anymore, I mean I would too if I found that out it’s understandable.

I agree. His trust was basically wronged. After that, you would always doubt if anything left was also a lie. It's not logical thinking, it's a emotional respond to the hurt. The wound is fresh and what to you do when you get hurt ? You fight back, you want them to be hurt too. Probably why he struck exactly where it hurt the most.
If anything, it's the most human respond that you could have if anyone encounter such event. And even worst, he have HUGE trust issue trauma that he just somewhat get over it because of this relationship. And now that ? You can't blame the man. :O
After that, they will eventually turn around because, it was a slight misunderstanding (he still lie and still wanted to hide everything) but they still love each others. So tbh, I would have been very surprised (and kind of dispointed) if he didn't had any negative reaction after knowing such thing happened.

OK, this is what I’m grasping from everything and this is just like what I’m thinking is a plot so it could not be the plot, im thinking the ml went back in time to fix his mistake after everything that happened you know and I feel like the main character isn’t actually in a novel like he think he is. I think his mind is just making him think he’s in a novel because of what he went through and I think Like his mind is so traumatized that he’s thinking he’s in a novel to replace those bad memories and tricked his mind into thinking that this isn’t like a real thing you know. I feel like the main character did go back in time along with the ML, but since everything that happened to him and all that trauma, his mind changed his memories rearranged his memories and changed it to an altered universe where there’s another male lead who’s completely different and kind, and they lived a normal life until you know he went into the novel. Regardless, I hate the ml he’s completely trash because regardless of how he’s acting now it does not change the fact what he did to the original bottom. He literally locked him up, forced him to get pregnant and raped him on a daily basis and God knows what else he did to him. I don’t care that he has issues or that he’s suffering because he thinks the main character is gonna leave him does not change the fact he’s literally raped him and pregnant him and locked him up. And of course, the original bottom was like trauma bond to him in a way and couldn’t imagine life without him and twisted away. I guess he did love him. Regardless I hate him do I feel a little bad for him maybe a tad bit but I hate him. Will I continue to read this. Yes I will. Also, I feel like the main character will regain his memories at some point and when that happens, I feel like the male lead will react badly to this and maybe lock him up or even rape him but I’m hoping it doesn’t happen, but I feel like it might happen due to it like what happened in the past and everything.

Everyone excusing what he did cus of how he was brought up like js cus u was raised mad shitty doesn’t excuses ur actions. It’s been like 80 chapters and he’s still a psychopath like he literally shot our Mc cus he thought he was leaving him let’s be sooo fr. He’s a hugeeeeee black flag not even a red one LOL. Though I like The plot but sometimes I want to Mc to tell him shit and set more boundaries on how he behaves and teach him that shit isn’t okayyyh(づ ̄ ³ ̄)づ

OK, this could be just my opinion and if you disagree you disagree with me, but oh my God I found the bottom a bit annoying because first off he saying he likes the future top but he doesn’t even know him like he knows nothing about him the only thing he likes is his looks and for me, that’s not you liking someone that’s you being attracted to them And that kind of like an annoyed me bc he’s like oh I like him so much already and all this other shit but he doesn’t like him. That’s just him being attracted to him not liking him. Also, when he found out, the guy was married, he didn’t just lbe like “oh he’s married” and move on. He still liked him and tbh he still liked him and for me like it’s wild cus he’s a teacher to the guys kid he should keep things professional keep his feelings, professional, and not make his feelings get in the way of things and don’t try to get close to his kid just to get close to the father of the kid you know(if I remember his friend said to get close to the kid so he can find things out abt him). I also understand people can’t help how they feel but dude he has a child and ex-wife and everything else so originally he was straight so atp he is asking for his heart to get hurt in the process you know and it seems like it’s not the only time he’s done this before liking straight guy. It seems like that’s who he normally fall for a straight guys. He got to grow some balls and just like stand up for himself when it comes to the old crush, you know, but this is just me and I know some people have harder times and some people fall quicker than others, but for me and my perspective, I feel like it’s so fucking dumb how he felt so quickly when he literally knows nothing about the future top.
Also, the reason why I kind of seem a little much on how he fell in love quickly without knowing the person is because I’ve had people do that and it’s so annoying. Because you don’t like the person you’re just attracted to them in terms of looks(づ ̄ ³ ̄)づ

OK, so I read some spoilersthat the main character‘s brother is kind of like obsessed with the main character and has like a weird obsession for him, etc. but I’m wondering, like is it in a incest type of obsession cause it kinda look like that and the latest chapter, but I don’t know. Or is it just in an obsession way, or is it he’s like infatuated with his brother and wants to complete control over him like an incest type way?
Cause I know his brother has an obsession over the main character, but I don’t know in what way?
also, I read the top kind of fell apart after the main character death. Is that true because in the first chapter it just looked like he was like kinda like blankly, staring at the main character when he was gonna die so I’m kind of confused on that as well. Please respond if you know any of the questions I’ve just asked.(づ ̄ ³ ̄)づ

it's been awhile since I read the novel so I can't really remember much about the brother other then he pissed me the fuck off. Now spoiler time about the top:
The top fell apart mentally for years in the past life cuz he was in love with the mc but he thought the mc hated him, if you want even more spoilers about the top falling apart I can tell you but it's a major plot spoiler that you wouldn't know about until close to the end of the novel

I got you, also sorry if my explanation isn't great I will try my best
At the end of the novel it's the tops pov: so the whole time the ml has been in love with the mc but cuz the mc in his past life started out as a asshole the ml thought that the mc hated him, as the ml started getting closer to the mc and started falling more in love with him he realized that the mc had become his weakness(not in a bad way). he started to distance himself from the mc as a means of protecting him(some other stuff happens but I think it's better to just wait for it to come up in the story at some point) so when the mc dies the ml goes through years of heart break cuz he never had the chance to tell the mc how much he loved and cared about him, when the ml finally started to completely break down he used his his powers as a last resort to try and turn back time but cuz he was so mentally broken from the death of the mc he wished at the same time that he'd loss his memories so he wouldn't have to remember the mc dying and how horrible it was for him and it actually works which but while the mc remembers his past the ml doesn't.

some other spoilers someone else brought up here if you wanna read it
https://www.mangago.zone/home/mangatopic/17939026/
I kinda miss the old art, her boobs are like always out or showing in the recent chapters and it’s kinda throwing me off seeing them. Also Ik this is a harem ect but the only one I like is the guy with black hair lol. I don’t really care for the others.