RATINGS:
STORY AND PLOT: 8.8/10
(I caught plot holes but since there are still many undiscovered truths in season 1, this might change. Give it a shot. It's comedic, drama driven, action packed, tragic life, slice of life)
DIALOGUE: 9.3/10
(It's decent and understandable tho there are some errors, it's the usual honest mistakes due to mistranslations and grammar.)
CHARACTERS: 8.7/10
(On one hand, complex and compelling characters with believable plotlines. But one the other hand, there are existing characters that are just dry and wasted potential)
PROTAGONIST: 9.9/10
(Talking about the MC, By far the most complex and compelling character in the story, really deserves to be the MC, tho some of the things he do is questionable. Can be considered a morally grey person)
ANTAGONIST: 10/10
(Surprisingly, this is one of the cases where I am so triggered by every single antagonist because they are so @#$_&&_$##!!!!!!!!!!!!! F*ck all of them. I'm writing another comment for this because I'm dragging them all one by one!!! 10 points for making me so angry at them)
FLOW OF THE STORY: 8.6/10
(A bit too fast, but also very slow paced. There are three main arcs in season 1 which gives us 25 chapters each arcs. So many things happened in one single arc but they fit 3-5 settings that it's crowded yet it's also stretched out that it feels slow paced.)
DIRECTION: 9.5/10
(I am anticipating for the next season~ it's about to go down and I cannot wait!!! I'm getting popcorn!!! But I'm kinda scared of what's going to happen cuz I have a gut feeling the situation they're facing would only get worse.)
CLIMAX: 10/10
(Each climax of an arc is highly satisfying and driven with great emotions. A truly fascinating roller coaster)
ARTISTRY: 10/10
(Characters are good looking and character design is amazing. They don't look wonky nor have the same face syndrome. Each panel is well furnished and crispy good.)
*Note: this is only my opinion, if you disagree then just read past it.
I just want to wrap FL in the softest blankets and spoil her with love cuz she doesn't deserve any of that. She needs to be protected at all costs!!
ML IS THE KING OF CONSENT AND COMFORT. He truly let's FL choose our the goodness of his heart. No hidden agenda, no double meanings or anything. He just wants the best for FL , and it's not out of pity but because he truly believes that no one deserves those kinds of treatments FL have gone through.Very good guy
The FL is turning to be a "I'm going to save everyone even if I'm incompetent" type.
Im glad that the ML knows who she was and was actually into her but bruh, he should just reveal that he knows her identity.
I get that she is naive and dumb cuz of her upbringing but she's s still very incompetent at the moment.
The antagonist, his face is getting into my nerves.
Im just reading this cuz I'm still interested on the other twin's story line.... Also interested with the maid and the knight
Finally got the time to read this.
IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT
If you are looking for a good revenge plot, this isn't that story. You won't see any satisfying revenge.
It's more focused to the "butterfly effect" if someone is going back to the past and changed an event to prevent the future. You will change the whole future and it happened that she changed her fate and also change others.
Is it a waste of time?
Nopes. I still love the growth of the FL. She became close with her father, the knights, and even made friends in her 2nd life. If I don't focus on the romance, I'm proud of FL for having meaningful relationships outside her love interests.
The love interest?
Not really a fan. I wanted the ML to SUFFERRRR or at least showed that he suffered in his 1st life... I want the 2nd male lead to suffer. The only decent love interest is the 3rd male lead but there is no chemistry with FL. I actually hoped she would take her vow not to fall in love again, but alas, FL is kinda dumb. Smart but very very dumb.
Antagonists?
The other woman is also caught up is this fucked up world so I don't blame her. The other dukes is just boring.... I wished the FL knew the betrayal of her "beloved friend".
Improvements?
I wished this isn't focused on the romance of FL. She clearly has talent. I like the politics. I like when they did trades and crafts. I wished they focused also in her knight training. Also..... I wish ML would just... I just wanna strangle him to death because even if he isn't the same person in the 1st life, his face triggers me and I hate it.
Total rating: 7.3/10
I'm generous cuz I liked the dad >:)
Also, Weed and Carrot is a cute pair~
Sadness: 8.3/10 (could be sadder, but I cried)
Anger: 9/10 (they just can't communicate!)
Happiness: 7/10 (only on the last parts were they truly happy. FL deserves to be more happy)
Love: 8/10 (they became so cute in the last parts)
Angst: 8.8/10 (so many misunderstandings bruh)
Satisfaction: 9/10 (everything solved in the end)
Cliches: 7.5/10 (I predicted many cliches, but it didn't ruin the mood of the story)
Revenge factor: 8/10 (They should have killed that motherfucker and the in-laws. Atleast ML suffered hahahaha)
I've read it to the latest (Chpt. 15) I have mixed feelings about this with this Manwha...
Don't get me wrong, It's good!! One of the well-written stories I've read in a while... but are the SmuttY scenes really necessary?
It's already a well-rounded story! Comedic, wholesome, and the characters are great!!! Daiki's relationship with his subordinates is good. THOMAS IS THE CUTEST!! I sympathized with Min-jun because of his experience. The interactions and dialogue exchanges are getting better with every chapter and the art is good!! But the "Spicy scenes" are bland like it only exists in here "for fanservice" and it doesn't really contribute to the plot.
I can't help but skip the smut scenes because it just ruins the wholesomeness that I feel...
Still!!! It's a GREAT READ!!! And I love it!!
you horny animal lmao
maybe we r bit similar i like rape scene, etc. and i think u r right this one has "smut" genre but i dont see any smoothies so far but thats fine by me ╮(￣▽￣)╭
i like shounen ai/light smut aswell
I'm not trying to be a hypocrite because I also read smut and other kinky stuff. But my point is that the smut here isn't placed well and was just placed there without any reason other than fanservice.
Like, I was cooing over how wholesome one scene is then it suddenly shifted to a predator/prey smut without warning and it doesn't sit well with the overall mood.
Ain't no problem with smut as long as it is placed well in the story and won't ruin the reader's mood (I still love you, author-san). And there is no sexual build-up, so the smut is just rushed and random.
This so beautiful and it speaks for itself!!! The photos on the last pages made me cry so much!! Im so proud of them!!!
Dear Deon,
please get a therapist and learn how to say no. Also, PLEASE GET A VACATION!!! Stop the drugs and alcohol too. Fucking get a hobby! Please take care of yourself too. You were just dragged by fucking adults who cannot mind their own business
Dear Cruel,
I will be kind to you since you're a ghost now. BUT I'm still mad at you that you literally cannot communicate well with your brother or your parents or the Emperor or the Duke. But it's not your fault... It's your parents fault
Dear parents of Deon and Cruel,
F U C K YOU
I have never heard a single affirmation that love your kids. NOT A SINGLE AFFIRMATION NOR FINDING ANY HELP FOR YOUR SON?! I will fucking infiltrate the front lines to take Deon away. HE'S 14!!!! AND NO LETTERS NOR VISITS?! Yeah it's dangerous because of the war but what did you exactly do? Wait on the emperor's doorstep... Then what??? So FUCK YOU.
Dear Demon King,
You literally just used a child for your bets. What do I expect from a demon king? Of course you're evil. But still....