Hello, I’m an alien (she/her) from Mars who recently discovered the world of webtoons. I’ve always loved all things BL and yaoi, but these webtoons have left me absolutely flabbergasted. My biggest flaw as a BL reader is trying to find meaning in even the shittiest stories.
My rating scale
5 Beyond Great Unique plots or exceptional storytelling, even if the plot is cliched. Memorable characters and/or compelling redemption arcs
4 Great A pretty good plot with solid characters. A few minor flaws like short length, a rushed ending, or small inconsistencies
3 Good Enjoyable for a one time read, but not worth revisiting. Ultimately forgettable
2 Meh A mediocre or messy plot with too many inconsistencies, poor pacing, shallow depth, and bland characters
1 Trash I regret ever touching this. Either the characters are completely irredeemable, or the writing is just awful. I can’t drop things, so I suffer through to the end
I don’t put any emphasis on art style when rating. A good story stays good, even with rough art. That said, I do have a soft spot for pretty visuals, so I still rate art purely based on what catches my eye.