
I feel immense pity for both Lilian and karloi
If at least one person had given them some kind of love as kids they wouldn't have been so messed up. Especially karloi since he had absolutely no one not even his own mother. At least Lilian had her mother so her issues are a little less but karloi was even abandoned by his own parents and the one aunt he had left blamed him a child for the death of her sister. I guess that explains why karloi is so obsessed with Lilian cuz she was the only one who treated him with kindness and helped him when even his mother abandoned him cuz she got pregnant again that would continue the royal family line even if karloi were to be killed by the kidnappers

I love how this manga shows a redemption arc. That just because her dad started to like her AFTER she started acting differently to get his approval did not mean she should just forget all the cruel things he said about her.
I love that he actually found what he did wrong and apologized to her for all the trauma he caused her. If he wants a relationship with her it was to start with an apology and it's up to her to forgive him
What does him going crazy after her death do for her? She was tortured to death countless times, murdered countless time and even BURNED to death once and not once was there anyone there with her. Her dad might have loved her but he was never there for her not even once( at least according to the chapters we've seen till now) He needs to grovel for forgiveness from her and needs to go through even more pain just like her. I also hope that he sees all her past deaths and bear all the guilt of abandoning her for all the 9 lives.
Do people feel sorry for him cuz he's supposedly handsome? Plz he deserves so much more pain(๑•ㅂ•)و✧
I understand why he did that tho. He thinks that if he gets too close to her, she'll get hurt like what happened to Beatrice or he'll cause trouble for her. Personally I really like his character but it's just my opinion.
I do understand that he stayed away for protecting her but at the same time he should have at least made sure he got news of her well being somehow cuz that poor girl has been tortured and killed so many times. If he had at least gotten some news about what was happening to her he might have been able to save her in any one of lives. But of course then we wouldn't have had a story so it makes sense. Anyhow in my opinion he needs to work extra hard to get his daughter's approval and trust this time
He might've not gotten news about her life tho. He wasn't even near her in her past life cause she was living under Aquila or something like that so how could he have known about her? It said that Aquila framed her for dark magic so it isn't impossible that she might've lied about how Asha was doing. I'm just saying it isn't completely his fault, he did what he thought was right
I understand his thinking why he 'thought' not being by his daughter's side makes her feel more safe but hey, at least he finally understands what the princess felt (not completely tho but he is trying) and learned his lessons. Now he is atoning/correcting his mistakes by becoming a better father and chase after her.
I agree that he needs to see all nine lives of her Being tortured and dying because he deserve to suffer through all the guilt and he needs to ask for forgiveness for the rest of his life. from what I understood he was trying to flee the kingdom with Beatrice and her right after she was born but but couldn’t so he should’ve done it when he found her or something. The i’m staying awake to protect you statement only applies to parents who already are horrible parents to their children such as abusers and neglectful parents. Which if he truly love her he wouldn’t be one of those however it is a selfish way to protect himself from having to face the consequences. Because in reality he was going to dump her at the palace and make her go through another torturous life if she did not coming to him like she did. Truthfully I like his character just because he is a vital part of the story but it doesn’t mean that he doesn’t pissed me off.