Miamatsuoka February 24, 2021 4:18 am

To anyone desperate to know what happens, read the novel. Honestly. The donghua is not nearly accurate with the story. If anything the manhua and the live action are the more similar ones to the novel. The live action is okay, yes, the only difference is that they rearranged the order of the flashbacks to make it more fluid for the screen and due to censorship we don't have the spice of the novel. But yes, as much as haters complain, the live action is a fairly good adaption of the novel. The donghua doesn't make it any justice at all. It's the most inaccurate of them all. And if you can't wait for updates on the manhua, read the novel. I promise it's a fast reading even though it's long, because you get immersed in the story so you don't even realized how fast you're reading.

    In_the_Moonlight February 24, 2021 8:04 am

    I really thought the donghua was closer to the novel seeing that i found many details closer to that of the novel. In what way is it innacurate?

    mistral February 24, 2021 11:01 am

    yeah, i agree. i found the donghua the least accurate from the novel, and actually the most confusing story-wise. Season 2 especially left me scratching my head about some of the changes. It was the least enjoyable of all the adaptations, so not sure i want to see season 3.

    OtakuRev February 24, 2021 11:30 am
    I really thought the donghua was closer to the novel seeing that i found many details closer to that of the novel. In what way is it innacurate? In_the_Moonlight

    There are some parts that are not included which makes you think if you missed a chapter or page if you read the novel first...

    yana February 24, 2021 11:39 am

    live action as in the untamed?

    Chi February 24, 2021 1:16 pm
    live action as in the untamed? yana

    Yes

    aozi February 24, 2021 3:32 pm

    The live action is actually a lot more different than the actual plot. I don't know why you think that the donghua us the most inaccurate adaptation

    Miamatsuoka February 24, 2021 4:30 pm
    yeah, i agree. i found the donghua the least accurate from the novel, and actually the most confusing story-wise. Season 2 especially left me scratching my head about some of the changes. It was the least enjoy... mistral

    Happened the same to me. I dropped the donghua. Since i started with the untamed and then read the novel and now I'm keeping up with the manhua, when i watched season one and two of the donghua i was left so uncomfortable with how they changed the details and rearranged the story.

    Miamatsuoka February 24, 2021 4:38 pm
    The live action is actually a lot more different than the actual plot. I don't know why you think that the donghua us the most inaccurate adaptation aozi

    I think it highly depends on the order you watch all of this. I watched the untamed first and then read the novel. All of this in a week. So, the details were so fresh that i was able to compared the two of them more precisely. And i think the fans are pissed at the fact that they did a whole arc of the past in one go. But if you think about it, that actually makes the story more fluid. The fact that they cut the forest scene where Lan Zhan kissed Wei Ying when they were 15 is obviously due to censorship and the fans are really pissed that they censored all those parts. But on the donghua i can't see their connection and chemistry AT ALL. All i see is a Wei Ying in a bad place. Even the untamed has more stares, flirting and dialogues that confirm the connection of soulmates the both of them have. The thing is that is subtle, delicate and not explicit like the novel. And that's what pisses off some fans. But the donghua? The donghua has none of that. I dropped it after season 2 seeing how unimportant Lan Zhan was to Wei Ying. The lack of deep, and at the same time, subtle details when it comes to the connection the both of them have, and how they surely changed a ton of dialogues, made it unbearable to keep watching. If anything the animation is good and the drawings are pretty. That's it.

    Miamatsuoka February 24, 2021 4:40 pm
    There are some parts that are not included which makes you think if you missed a chapter or page if you read the novel first... OtakuRev

    Exactly. The donghua has parts that are absolutely unnecessary to include and completely made up. Things that never happened in the novel. At least the untamed took out some not so necessary details to the whole picture of the story but didn't add anything that wouldn't help to the story. They respected the whole essence of the story.

    OtakuRev February 24, 2021 5:15 pm
    Exactly. The donghua has parts that are absolutely unnecessary to include and completely made up. Things that never happened in the novel. At least the untamed took out some not so necessary details to the whol... Miamatsuoka

    Hmm, is it okay to disagree that they included something? I don't remember them doing that... most I remember is taking out some parts

    OtakuRev February 24, 2021 5:19 pm
    Exactly. The donghua has parts that are absolutely unnecessary to include and completely made up. Things that never happened in the novel. At least the untamed took out some not so necessary details to the whol... Miamatsuoka

    I think my comment could be read in another way I guess... I actually meant that they did not include what was in the novel and instead took some parts out of it so you might think you skipped or missed a chapter/page... if my reply was misunderstood, I'm really sorry

    Miamatsuoka February 24, 2021 5:53 pm
    I think my comment could be read in another way I guess... I actually meant that they did not include what was in the novel and instead took some parts out of it so you might think you skipped or missed a chapt... OtakuRev

    No need to say sorry. I hardly get offended or misinterpret things written on internet. If anything I will always try to understand what you were truly trying to convey. And i got it. So no worries lol

    aozi February 25, 2021 6:13 pm
    I think it highly depends on the order you watch all of this. I watched the untamed first and then read the novel. All of this in a week. So, the details were so fresh that i was able to compared the two of the... Miamatsuoka

    Not to be rude, but I was not talking about how different they portray their affection to each other. I was actually pointing out that the plot in the novel and live action are different. For example, the yin metal and how wei wuxian is not the grandmaster or founder of the demonic cultivation in the live action. I actually dropped the live action halfway through the drama because of that. Sorry if it sounds rude

    Miamatsuoka February 25, 2021 6:22 pm
    Not to be rude, but I was not talking about how different they portray their affection to each other. I was actually pointing out that the plot in the novel and live action are different. For example, the yin m... aozi

    Why would that sound rude? You're just explaining to me your point of view.
    I understand. And like the yin iron was a reason for you to drop the live action, the addition of unnecessary scenes on the donghua, that didn't contribute at all in the comprehension of the plot, plus the lack of the essence that was needed to portray the connection between Lan Zhan and Wei Ying (and I'm not talking about explicit content) was a reason for me to drop the donghua. We just share different points of views in how we took in the entire mo dao zu shi world.

Miamatsuoka February 21, 2021 2:27 am

The fact that they both have such different concept of what having sex with someone else means kinda makes me feel down. Han is totally liberal and doesn't care to have fuck buddies and do threesomes and stuff while Hyuk thinks that kissing and masturbating each other means they're dating. Y'all T_T they're so different!


.
..
.
.


Spoiler


.

I know they end up together and they burn that bridge of the past when Han broke his heart once. But i think is really BL troupe the fact that the fuck boy (Han) decides to be monogamous for Hyuk. Even though it might be that Hyuk was actually his first love and since it didn't work at first he became a whore out of guilt? I don't remember well the raws.

Miamatsuoka February 18, 2021 2:31 pm

I started this kinda disliking the fact that the seme was the dog. And now I'm so pissed off at the uke hurting not only the dog but also the red hair guy! Because he's obviously gonna break up with him and ugh I was rooting for him so badly! Almost want the dog god to give him the happiness he deserves and fuck the uke. I freaking hate that guy now.
Sorry first time not learning the names cuz i read all 20 chapters that i had on hold in 20 minutes lol

Miamatsuoka February 18, 2021 1:49 pm

THE RAWS ARE BACK! Y'ALL GO SPOIL YOURSELF BECAUSE SEASON TWO IS SAVAGE AS WELL.


spoiler...



Soo-young is whipped for Tae-seung and Minhyuk is acting like a total whore sleeping around and it turns out that he's bi. But it's probably because she's trying to get info from people. Anyways, doesn't change the fact that he slept with that old woman and that old guy.

    MoshiMoshiYaoi February 18, 2021 2:05 pm

    Yah well he’s not dating anyone so I’m sure he can sleep around and I’m sure everyone is bi technically besides the mc

    Haii February 18, 2021 2:19 pm
    Yah well he’s not dating anyone so I’m sure he can sleep around and I’m sure everyone is bi technically besides the mc MoshiMoshiYaoi

    He probably slept with them because Taesung gave him an order to get more Information or something like that

    Miamatsuoka February 18, 2021 2:32 pm
    Yah well he’s not dating anyone so I’m sure he can sleep around and I’m sure everyone is bi technically besides the mc MoshiMoshiYaoi

    And? When did i say that it was a bad thing? I said he was a whore. If that has a bad connotation to you that's on you.

    Miamatsuoka February 18, 2021 2:32 pm
    He probably slept with them because Taesung gave him an order to get more Information or something like that Haii

    "he's probably trying to get info from people" was what I wrote too.

    Haii February 18, 2021 2:34 pm
    And? When did i say that it was a bad thing? I said he was a whore. If that has a bad connotation to you that's on you. Miamatsuoka

    sorry if I sounded rude

    MoshiMoshiYaoi February 18, 2021 2:35 pm
    And? When did i say that it was a bad thing? I said he was a whore. If that has a bad connotation to you that's on you. Miamatsuoka

    Bruh

    Haii February 18, 2021 2:36 pm
    sorry if I sounded rude Haii

    Oh sorry wrong comment I thought you responded to me on that one

    Miamatsuoka February 18, 2021 2:36 pm
    Oh sorry wrong comment I thought you responded to me on that one Haii

    No worries i replied to the wrong message too lol

    MahirF February 18, 2021 2:48 pm

    But what about the first chapter of S2 where Taesung confront the mafia guy who hurt Sooyoung and he reveals he killed Sooyoung father or grandfather in the past? Can someone please explain that part because it's clearly the most important one yet no one is talking about it and I don't freaking speak Korean :,((( Did Taesung really killed Sooyoung's relative in tha past and that's why he keeps saying that he knows Sooyoung way before their first official meeting...

    Miamatsuoka February 18, 2021 3:09 pm
    But what about the first chapter of S2 where Taesung confront the mafia guy who hurt Sooyoung and he reveals he killed Sooyoung father or grandfather in the past? Can someone please explain that part because it... MahirF

    There has been some hints about it. And there's actually a scene of a short flashback where Tae-seung shows us how he's been beaten by Soo-young (which is weird because we all know Tae-sung would never let himself get beaten by anyone). By the looks of it, seems that Soo-young is the one who doesn't remember. But yeah they definitely have past. And it wouldn't be weird that Tae-sung killed his father since the father left the debt to Soo-young.
    Also, before anyone starts attacking Tae-sung for this too, remember that Soo-young's father was a piece of shit to him too.

    MahirF February 18, 2021 3:57 pm
    There has been some hints about it. And there's actually a scene of a short flashback where Tae-seung shows us how he's been beaten by Soo-young (which is weird because we all know Tae-sung would never let hims... Miamatsuoka

    Thanks for replying! I thought the beating scene was from chapter 3 (last pages) when Taeseung first kidnaps Sooyoung and asks him to pay his father's debt. When he was beating him, Sooyoung suddenly reacts and gets on top of him and beat the shit out of him with strong punches just like what we see in the flashback you mentioned. Go check it out and you'll see. Also, the mafia guys in S2 tells Taesung that he killed the dad of Sooyoung and he remembers how he was just a teenager with uniform crying... and we do see very briefly a sort of teen with black uniform in Taesung's flashback which I imagines being Sooyoung...

    Actually, from the first chapter, Taesung keeps saying that he met Sooyoung somewhere but he cannot remember... and then in the last chapters of S1, he finally remembers and tells to himself that he must protect him and keep him by his side. I was hoping someone else noticed these details and could tell me if I am wrong or right. Because it does not make too much sense. If Taesung killed Sooyoung dad and then comes to ask for the debt to be paid then he surely knows who Sooyoung was...

    Miamatsuoka February 19, 2021 3:18 am
    Thanks for replying! I thought the beating scene was from chapter 3 (last pages) when Taeseung first kidnaps Sooyoung and asks him to pay his father's debt. When he was beating him, Sooyoung suddenly reacts and... MahirF

    I will definitely read again. But that aside don't you think that it's weird that Tae-sung killed Soo-young's father when he was a teenager and waited so long to come to Soo-young to demand him to pay his father's debt? There's a missing piece there. I think will have to wait a bit more to know. But yeah, I agree, there's definitely history between them.

    MahirF February 21, 2021 10:11 am
    I will definitely read again. But that aside don't you think that it's weird that Tae-sung killed Soo-young's father when he was a teenager and waited so long to come to Soo-young to demand him to pay his fathe... Miamatsuoka

    Yep, I agree. Something is missing and that's why I've been asking for Korean speakers to help out with the translation of the last 2 chapters... they are key in understanding a bit what happened!

Miamatsuoka February 17, 2021 5:29 pm

It's happening people! We got a sadist and a masochist! Keep calm! Stay calm. Don't lose it! I knew Andy was the type that liked to be forced into submission.

Miamatsuoka February 16, 2021 2:05 pm

Y'all do know that the other "uploader" is not translating anything right? They're just uploading the official translation from Lezhin. I knew you were all gonna play the white knight in shining armour and destroy the current translator. But y'all are too much. You live to create wars between translators and uploaders. Hope y'all feel happy about yourselves by doing this. I personally don't mind because I read the raws and then come to check the english versions here. But some of y'all are too much. Really.

    yuhi_sama February 16, 2021 2:19 pm

    Uhm they legit translated only to mess with the original uploader so the people in the comment section who attack them are pretty right

    Miamatsuoka February 17, 2021 2:46 am
    Uhm they legit translated only to mess with the original uploader so the people in the comment section who attack them are pretty right yuhi_sama

    People on english sites are so petty i swear. On other languages several groups translate at the same time and upload at the same time on other sites and there's no war over it. It literally means you have the option to choose whatever translation you like even if that means having fastest releases with bad quality images or translations. I don't know why english sites feel entitled to decide they're gonna be THE ONE AND ONLY uploader/translator. If anyone can complain about this is the authors themselves. No one else.

    yuhi_sama February 17, 2021 7:08 am
    People on english sites are so petty i swear. On other languages several groups translate at the same time and upload at the same time on other sites and there's no war over it. It literally means you have the ... Miamatsuoka

    İ completly agree with you and that s manly bc this site got a lots of dumb american and then other ppl think that their dumbness is qhat right so also do the same thing but- like bro this person legit just translated to MESS with the original uploader out of boredom not to actually give readers a chapter so thats extremely petty itself and rather than the uploader bad quality translation i think people are more angry that they are legit trynna to mess with someone for absolutely 0 reason and wrote a note abt it as if it was something good

Miamatsuoka February 15, 2021 6:30 am

I don't know what to do with my life. Lmfaoooooooo
But I'm so picky with BL lately that I currently like like 10 stories and they're all on hiatus because seasons 1 or 2 just ended. That means i still have to wait at least a month for new chapters and now you're telling me this season ends in three more chapters. Y'all i have nothing to currently read. I'm in pain and having yaoi withdrawal. Help!

    Bakugou February 15, 2021 6:32 am

    You are picky with BL as in? You like Respectful semes?

    alex February 15, 2021 6:36 am

    have you tried "a strange joke" and "at the end of the road"?

    Miamatsuoka February 15, 2021 8:31 pm
    You are picky with BL as in? You like Respectful semes? Bakugou

    No. I tend to read stories with darker elements. I've been reading BL for almost 10 years. And generally speaking i like dark elements in stories. In literature, manga, manwha, etc.. And lately a lot of stories are too sweet to my taste.

    Miamatsuoka February 15, 2021 8:32 pm
    have you tried "a strange joke" and "at the end of the road"? alex

    I already read "at the end of the road" a few years ago. Haven't tried "a strange joke" is it too sweet and normal?

Miamatsuoka February 14, 2021 7:38 pm

Résistance is futile. Even you already know that lol

Miamatsuoka February 14, 2021 1:21 pm

This uploader said "fuck you moralist hypocrites" and in living for it! Thanks for the chapters!

Miamatsuoka February 12, 2021 9:19 pm

They stopped updating the raws y'all I'm dying here. Because they left us in a major cliffhanger.

    Yourdaddy~ February 12, 2021 10:34 pm

    You saw it too rightttt jdjxnxksnxksjsjxjdksncjdjdd I'm so scaredddd

    cygnus February 12, 2021 11:31 pm

    What you know and I don't please tell me.....

    Yourdaddy~ February 13, 2021 2:02 am
    What you know and I don't please tell me..... cygnus

    Spoiler****


    That prince in chapter 21 but human sizeddddd;))))

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.