I don’t know it just feel kind of obvious. But the duke is clearly the serial killer behind the murders and he does a obsession over louis ( for whatever reason ) and four months ago he drugged louis to get him to have sex with him ( you know the drug that makes you obey every order that you are given and forget everything) which can explain how submissive louis was during that night and how he couldn’t remember a thing after. But the thing is that it the prince who took louis in his carriage causing a lot of misunderstanding on his side. ┑( ̄Д  ̄)┍
I don’t understand,
Has athy always been athy ? Like the novel was her past life or something. Which means she lived 3 life , the novel , the modern world , the novel bis or was the novel some kind of prophecy of what should have happen. If she really lived the life in the novel does her mother know that she suffered and died by the hand of claude or was claude trapped with dianna when he put the curse on himself right after dianna’s death and thus didn’t make athy suffer.
And what’s the gem on dianna’s face i always thought it was a jewellery but it’s not.
Hope some kind soul will take the time to read my comment and answer my questions. ┗( T﹏T )┛
She lived now 4 times...the one in the novel, the one in modern times, novel bis(the actual novel written for us by the author), and now in this manhwa....because it is actually different, and THIS is actually the best!!! Motherly love is the best!!!
I read some spoilers a while back and it’s exactly what u said that’s mostly why I still kind of hate Claude cause he literally killed Athy in her first life
yes, she's all that, that's why lucas find her interesting because he knows that she is an old soul. and there was a chapter where athy realized all that, that during the first timeline with claude choosing jenette, second timeline where she was in korea, and this timeline where she's claude's child again was all her, she was reborn 2 times, or even more than 2.
Spoiler
Yes, she had lived 3 lives, the og novel, modern world, and this life. She’s not aware of her first life and could only remember her second life. The og novel exists somewhere in other dimension, Athy saw og Athy in ‘the lovely princess’. The reason why claude didn’t acknowledged og Athy was because the black magic he used already consumed his memories so when Claude said that he doesn’t remember (or something) Athy he literally meant it, he forgot Diana and Athy.
Some gramatical error but I hope u understand. (⌒▽⌒)
The manhwa is her fourth life ???
Yes i understand
So the “claude” who is with dianna is the part of himself he cursed ( the one in love with dianna) , BUT from when the original novel or this lifetime. Because like lucas who is able to discern the different life she lived there must be things that are outside dimension like the world tree and thus have seen athy struggle. Like maybe dianna who was in the world tree ( i think )
Or the one from this lifetime.
For me YES!! Because the novel was actually more simple and claude woke up really fast thanks to Lucas... I am gonna imagine this as a multiverse