agathat August 5, 2024 3:55 pm

Honestly I want to know before I continue reading! Will she forgive her horrible family and father in this life, will she abandon them and ignore them or will she destroy them?

Seeing how horrible is her family I don't want she forgive them nor have a good relationship with them, specially the horrible witch she has a grandma and her good for nothing father!

Seeing how the family abandon/exile children to their death, I want full karma on them and see them suffer, specially because we can see how bad they are in this life too!!!

I hate the stories where the child is only loved because she/he acts like an adult and not a child, like they are saying they are the cause of the hate instead the victim of it!

    Cashew August 5, 2024 4:59 pm

    Honestly it looks like this will fall into the trope of FL becomes strong(which she is showing now), family fawns over her/gains a member at a time and she forgives them/become a happy family

    Thewomenwastostunnedtospeak August 6, 2024 10:39 am

    I mean, she's lived multiple lives with them and it's pretty aware of how horrible they are
    She mustn't really care anymore and it's more set on her goals yk
    Cus in her other life she still kinda managed to have good relationships with her brothers and everything
    I'm bad at explaining my point sorry

agathat June 16, 2024 5:14 pm

I decided to search spoilers because I refuce to read this if the CP is the ML, but look like he is the ML!!!

The author jusgify the bullying because MC and her brother look like his mom and he has PTSD from his mom and later he was mind controled my the villain!!!

Sighhhh!!! Not a justification!!!

    Kyo September 30, 2024 8:05 pm

    Any more spoilers you have?

agathat May 24, 2024 9:57 am

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

Remi will do experiments to save Emi soul, while doing that she saved the original Pina's soul making her her son. Like Remi who could see what Emi was doing with her body, Pina could see what that evil woman was doing and ended with PTSD so she asked be born as a boy!

Emi will reborn as Remy and Angel's daughter. In the novel there was an Extra where the evil Pina never existed, Emi married the second prince (she was really in love with him) and Remi reincarnated as their daughter!

Remi's son sometimes has dreams when he was Pina and how much she suffered when that woman took her body, but he never remember the dreams! I'm happy the original Pina had her happily ever after with a family who loves him!!!

    Dami-nyan May 26, 2024 5:02 am

    TY FOR THE SPOILERS, I'm so happy the good OG characters and Emi get happy endings :')

agathat May 17, 2024 5:50 am

Honestly I have hard time understanding some stuff, it is like someone used Google translate and didn't correct anything, it is tiring to read because I have to decipher what they are talking about and/or who are they talking about all the time!!!

- Given names and family names are changing all the time, so I have a hard time following who is who.
- Using wrong pronouns all the time making hard to understand half the time, like using you instead I, he instead she, me instead his, your instead my, etc... half of the time I don't know if the character is talking about herself or another character!

I stopped reading in chapter 18!

    SPUCI May 23, 2024 6:03 am

    Once you read enough weirdly translated manga enough your mind will auto correct the words

    Spartanae May 24, 2024 11:11 am

    Bc it is exactly as you said : google translation

agathat May 12, 2024 1:29 pm

It is again that trope where the ML abused the FL in her last life but in this one she forgives him and they get married again!!!

    Sofie.Bofie May 12, 2024 2:59 pm

    Hey now, abuse is too strong of a word, he never laid a hand on her or insulted, used or manipulated her in anyway.

    HOWEVER, the word I believe you are looking for is neglect, he never treated her in the way a wife should be treated.

    But the guy got his body disfigured, saw himself as hideous monster, who did not deserve another human touch, suffered from severe PTSD after the war, and grieving losing all of his family.

    now that’s not an excuse for the years she suffered in loneliness, but will you be able to open your heart after going through what he had been through?

    Besides Madeline is not completely blameless in their marriage ending up in tragedy.

    And Compered to things like for example Abandoned Empress this like a wake in the park, and more realistic.

    Yuna May 14, 2024 5:56 pm
    Hey now, abuse is too strong of a word, he never laid a hand on her or insulted, used or manipulated her in anyway.HOWEVER, the word I believe you are looking for is neglect, he never treated her in the way a w... Sofie.Bofie

    The fact that their relationship in past actually got better, but it worsened because someone else.

    Motto May 14, 2024 7:26 pm

    The ml didn't abuse flThis ml aint one of those trashy ml.

    This guy literally fought in war where he saw his friends getting burned to crisp and himself got burned and injuredThis man was traumatized by war. THEN was tortured by the doctor.

    Chocolate May 15, 2024 2:29 am

    Could be a spoiler.
    Scroll on ur own accord.
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    Yup, as the 3 users before me mentioned, it's not "Abandoned Empress". Here's the thing, abuse doesn't not have to be physical, it can also be mental. The worn down type.
    The premise is WW1. The thing is, ml has war PTSD. Then comes self doubt, fear, low confidence from it. A spoiler, he had a big family, but lost them all within just 1-3 years. Which is another kind of pain. Survivors's guilt eats away at a person. So, he left FL to be in her world, thinking it's best for her.
    Fortunately, she took action, eventually, after a long time. So, ml took her hands & started to get better. But alas! PTSD!
    So, ml decides to get treatment for himself & for FL. This is where things go boo boo. & the psychotherapy then... We all make fun of & scare people of that past. But, for those people of that time it was the latest, upgraded & better option. So... Yeah, that's where their relationship go downhill.

    suhorang June 12, 2024 7:26 am
    Could be a spoiler.Scroll on ur own accord. . . . . . . . . Yup, as the 3 users before me mentioned, it's not "Abandoned Empress". Here's the thing, abuse doesn't not have to be physical, it can also be mental.... Chocolate

    That's still not abuse, that's being a neglectful and terrible husband. Honestly, I would consider making him go through electroshock """therapy""" more abusive than anything he ever did. I wouldn't say the FL is terrible for prioritising her feelings, that's valid, but don't expect a traumatised person not to, I dont know, act traumatised.

agathat April 22, 2024 11:21 am

The mangaka is teasing us with this one!!!

I really want a manga with those two finally deciding to become a couple!!!

agathat October 16, 2023 11:39 pm

What happen with Will and Julio???

agathat July 25, 2023 3:41 pm

I read every chapter stressed praying that nothing happens to his mom. In those stories many times the mom or the family member the MC loves the most die or suffer a lot for plot sake!

I hope nothing nad happens to his mom!

I also love that she is strong!!!

And I pray it is not harem! I can accept the 2 girls but no more!

agathat July 24, 2023 9:15 pm

Please tell me she will not forgive her father and she will destroy him!

    justpassingby July 29, 2023 1:08 pm

    She wont. His dad is the epitome of evil and
    Minor spoiler—



    she regressed to her young self (she already experience how vile he was)

agathat July 18, 2023 8:00 am

I hope the prince is not the ML!!!

I hope he is not even the 2nd ML!!!

I hope the FL doesn't give a shit for him!!!

What topics will be shown here?

Topics that you posted in a manga's page will be shown here, as well as replies from other users.