i was rereading this 5 years later remembering it to be somewhat decent, but then chapter 8, with her first sentence, fucking cracked me up. it’s ruined for me
why did no one question that shit what the fuck
Diet... to avoid the Bad End! In a former life, Cosette was just a normal housewife. Now she's been ...
- Author: hoshimado ponkichi,fujiwara rika
- Genres: Shoujo / Comedy / Romance / Isekai / School Life / Video Games / Reincarnation
Tier: D
Plot: 4
Art Style: 5
Fast Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 3
FL Attractiveness: 5
ML Character: 3
ML Attractiveness: 6
Summary: FL is a middle aged mom from modern japan who reincarnated into the body of a count’s daughter who was part of the OGvillainess’s posse. Lives a different life and charms the ML.
Comment: It’s so ass there’s nothing remotely interesting about it
- extremely passive FL in the first half, she basically does nothing and just stands around for all the male characters to dote on while the “villainesses” get jealous.
- weird reincarnation mental age gap, and that is not the way a middle aged lady would act.
- no character had an in depth background story
- the pages being out of order was fucking hilarious when they were talking about a somber poisoning case and then suddenly were taste testing mayonnaise, then back to the poisoning discussion
- this was meant to be a romance but the story starts out with them already having mutual feelings. YAWNNN
- Male characters fall in love with FL after an exchange with like 5 sentences. Villainesses are completely reformed and redeemed and now a friend after a short monologue from the FL.
Violette, a proud and beautiful daughter of a duke, commits a crime out of jealousy towards her half...
- Author: Soratani Reina,Harukawa Haru
- Genres: Romance / Shoujo
Tier: C
Plot: 6
Art Style: 8
Slow Pace | Angst
FL Character: 7
FL Attractiveness: 8
ML Character: Unsure who
Summary: FL is a time regressor, who vows to become a nun in a convent due to being a villainess clinging to the prince in the past. She just wants to live peacefully avoiding her negligent father, clingy OGFL sister, and prince she pursued in the past.
Comment: Two potential MLs, both romances are meh. Nothing exciting ever happens.
Violette, a proud and beautiful daughter of a duke, commits a crime out of jealousy towards her half...
- Author: Soratani Reina,Harukawa Haru
- Genres: Romance / Shoujo
Tier: C
Plot: 6
Art Style: 8
Slow Pace | Angst
FL Character: 7
FL Attractiveness: 8
ML Character: Unsure who
Summary: FL is a time regressor, who vows to become a nun in a convent due to being a villainess clinging to the prince in the past. She just wants to live peacefully avoiding her negligent father, clingy OGFL sister, and prince she pursued in the past.
Comment: Two potential MLs, both romances are meh. Nothing exciting ever happens.
- In the first half why was the ML drawn in a different art style than anyone else he looked like a seme from a 2000’s yaoi
- I like stories that has a gradual romance unfurl, whereas the ML goes from intrigued to passionate, undying love within a single chapter, as if a switch were flipped
- In the last quarter the characterisation for FL that was been built up just gets thrown out the window, she acts completely differently ABRUPTLY. You don’t hear narration from her perspective anymore, and it’s mystifying because you don’t hear her thoughts and motivations to act and speak the way she does anymore. It almost feels like it was hinting at insanity by the end even though we know the manhwa would never do that. She just act extremely weird and hot-and-cold and she barely felt like a person, much less a character where we can envision ourselves in her shoes.
- The story DRAGSSSSS after the kidnapping. There are many points at which the story could’ve ended in a satisfying way, but they kept throwing in short insignificant conflicts in there that absolutely no one cared about just to extend the story. The kidnapping felt like the climax of the story, then the last HALF was the resolution. You spent HALF the story tying up uninteresting loose ends.
- FL was extremely unlikeable in the last half due to the hot-and-cold attitude we have no explanation for. ML is unlikeable and overbearing all the way through.
- I like how this manhwa does try to humanise characters who have done irredeemable things, I appreciate it, but that doesn’t mean I’ll like them as a character. They are still despicable.
- Would’ve loved to have the story give some screen time to the King before redemption because we were essentially told, not shown, his evil in the past. We do not see evil!King interact with our protag, which would’ve actually been interesting.
As the Kingdom of Elpasa fell before the blade of the Empire's greatest hero, in order to survi...
- Author: ma cherie,cierra
- Genres: Shoujo / Drama / Historical / Romance / webtoons
Tier: C+
Plot: 6
Art Style: 8
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 5
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 7
Summary: FL is a slave who was a princess for 2 years, then her kingdom was defeated by ML’s army, who took her in as a slave again. Prince ML is charmed by her happy go lucky attitude despite being a slave.
Comment: Story drags after the kidnapping. ML looks like he was drawn w a diff art style first half. FL characterisation goes out the window in the last quarter.
Kang Ha-Ji, who is loved by everyone, has been reduced from being the school's most popular sta...
- Author: daon creative,ma
- Genres: Fantasy / Romance / webtoons
Tier: D
Plot: 6
Art Style: 7.5
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 6
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 6
Summary: FL, who is bullied in modern Korea, saves a cat and is isekaied into another world segregated by animal species. She gets entangled with the princes of the cat kingdom and goes head to head with an old frenemy.
Comments: Very very meh. Plot is boring, ML looks like >:| the whole time. Hard to get invested in any character. 2nd ML on
couldn’t get thru the first 3 panels because the art was so ugly
Rolicia Roba’s world is turned upside down when her mother tragically passes away. And not only do...
- Author: Hadam,Lupta
- Genres: Webtoons / Shoujo / Adaptation / Fantasy / Historical / Romance Webtoons Webtoons Adaptation Fantasy Webtoons Historical Romance
Marinating
art is very meh, but i like the setup so far. waiting for the flirting tho
When I opened my eyes I had become the duchess. But something isn’t right. I went as far as be...
- Author: lee jiha,jo hyunyeong
- Genres: Romance / Drama / Fantasy / Shoujo / webtoons
Tier: C
Plot: 6
Art Style: 7
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 6
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 7
Summary: FL is a reincarnator in the body of a powerless duchess who is shunned and mocked by high society for her meekness, and unloved by her husband the duke ML. FL starts making and sharing tea.
Comments: Artists need to stop making blonde so yellow. Feels like a tea fanfic with a lacklustre romance. ML is just an allegedly hot wallet, an accessory to the FL.
- artists need to stop making blonde so yellow, pls get them some purple shampoo smfh
- i need the captain of the knights so bad what a dilf
- this is more of a tea fanfic than it is romance
- alphonse doesn’t really feel like a character, he feels like an allegedly good looking wallet, an accessory. he doesn’t have any motivation or thought or feelings except “muh wife”
The poor daughter of the Marquis, Teresse, who has been striving to save money day and night, was su...
- Author: Seo yuri,Okaya
- Genres: Adaptation / Comedy / Fantasy / Romance
Tier: C-
Plot: 7
Art Style: 7
Fast Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 7
FL Attractiveness: 6 (Child-like)
ML Character: 7
ML Attractiveness: 7
Summary: FL is selected to be a consort candidate, but aims for being a highly paid court lady instead of being the consort.
Comment: It’s short and there’s not really much time to build a solid romance, the romance barely progresses by the end of the manga.
- Somehow the ML reminds me of Yoonbum
- Just about every other character is more compelling and has more interesting stories than the main leads, esp Gerard and Louis, or Gracie, or Evgenia, literally anybody else’s plot would’ve been so much more fun to read
- I have such a thing for Gerard and Ethan
- Literally could not care any less for FL and ML
- Hate to see Dietrich get 0 reprecussions for the drama he caused????? Take responsibility you old fuck
Canaria is reincarnated as the villian of a popular cliche novel. Based on the novel, she is destine...
- Author: nokki (녹끼),abin (아빈)
- Genres: Fantasy / Romance / Shoujo / Webtoons / historical
Tier: C
Plot: 7
Art Style: 6
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 5
FL Attractiveness: 6
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 6
Summary: FL is a reincarnator who gets married to the prince ML when they were both children. Her character was meant to be the villainess so she plans to divorce him when they grow up.
Comment: The least interesting characters in the story are the main leads. Every other character is much more compelling than they are. ML reminds me of Yoonbum.
Song Ji Hyeon is a surgeon, as well as a genius doctor appointed as the youngest lecturer at Seoul ...
- Author: Mini,Yuin
- Genres: Webtoons / Fantasy / Romance
Tier: C-
Plot: 5
Art Style: 6
Slow Pace | Fluff
FL Character: 5
FL Attractiveness: 7
ML Character: 4
ML Attractiveness: 6
Summary: FL is a reincarnator + time regressor, was a villainess, then a modern doctor, and came back to save the world with modern medical knowledge.
Comment: A mary sue who never fucks up, and everyone likes her after a single conversation. Any non-relative young man immediately falls for her. Conflicts are immediately resolved.
talk about a mary sue damn
no conflict has lasted more than like 2 chapters
Adel, who entered the emperor's office due to the magic of the imperial magic, a...
- Author: dawn meteor,chimpa
- Genres: Comedy / Fantasy / Romance
Dropped for being ugly and confusing