Hello hello hello this is not from me ah ha ha...
“u/ta4579”
“Sorry for the rant but I just have to let it out.
Ok, so I saw this novel earlier and immediately got interested, but there's this one important thing that will decide whether I give it a chance or not.
Are they blood-related?
It's a shame that they are, as people have mentioned above. (What they mean is that a very good amount of people also agree that the siblings should indeed be endgame.) Let's be honest, we are all here for the incest, the kind of excitement that only a forbidden relationship could provide. If they are not related, or not going to be a couple then WHAT IS THE POINT OF THIS? The author tempted us with brother-sister complex but didn't go all the way with it, which feels like a scam to me.
A lot of novels and mangas out there also have this kind of cheap plot device, and I'm sick of it. Authors please, just go with the incest route already, I know you want it.”
I mean... I’m here for the siscon-brocon dynamic, not straight up incest JAHSJAHS. Pretty sure a lot of ppl will say the same.
But in terms of what ur talking abt, I’m pretty sure almost all “incest” mangas/novels go down the “it’s ok we’re not blood related” or the “it’s ok we’re only half siblings” route. Honestly it makes me wonder whether the publishers have certain rules for the artists/writers to follow (eg. ‘if you’re writing incest, it can only be bait-incest, not fully blood related, or else we can’t publish it’), or if the creators are all just concerned about the backlash. And yes, some ppl (eg, you) like fictional incest bc of the forbidden love ~vibes~ BUT it is a very dividing topic & it absolutely DISGUSTS some ppl (+ others just aren’t into it). I don’t think they’d be willing to risk sales like that or risk receiving a shit ton of backlash since it’s so taboo, but they also wanna appeal to the incest-liking crowd (+ maybe they wanna fulfil their own urges to create a kind-of-incest manga, as u said), so they go for a compromise.?? Idk, these r just my thoughts.
Either way honestly I doubt there will be many (shoujo) mangas that will give u what you’re looking for. Or at least, I doubt it will happen in THIS genre - maybe you’d have better luck with hentai/smut/ecchi or like seinen (?) genres if u wanna see 2 full siblings together. Maybe more full-incest novels will come out, idk, but I do wonder if they’d be able to get manga adaptations for those..
Actually when i see stories like this, authors do usually rope me in by the sibling con or something, sometimes they also use the "actually not related" trope... And I also usually find it a big painful when they don't gp through with it.
And, almost every stories I see with a fem mc of both isekai and harem, never has the incest ending. I'd like to see some tbh.
My tastes are actually a bit heavy sometimes lol (ofc only if it's fictional).
Why reposting exactly the same thing ? You already got answers... even if you did not get the response you wanted, people took their time to reply. Besides if this is a copy/paste of "someone else's comment". What's the point especially if you intend to delete and repost it because you are bothered by the answers ?
Dietrich knew all along???